The patriarch listened in silence to these arguments, and knew that his acts were worthy of blame, nor had he any defence to offer for them: finally however he answered as follows; 'As I perceive that you are troubled and offended at this annulling of your orders,—for so I conclude from what you have said, and to which I have given a patient audience,—if this matter is set right, and the annulling of your ordinations discontinued, will you be contented, and enter into union with me?' But they replied, 'What setting right is possible, after all this corruption and disorder which you have wrought contrary to law? Nor have your proceedings even been confined to your own diocese, nor limits put by you to your violence and heat and hatred, but you have extended even into other countries this your violation of law, and your opposition to all the constitutions and canons of the church: as regards which, one of two things must be the case, that either in ignorance of their injunctions, you have broken and transgressed them,; and trampled them under foot, or, if acquainted with them, that you have despised and contemned them, and purposely set them at nought. But of this be well assured, that whenever the time shall come, whether in your lifetime, or, if so be, after your death, there will be a strict investigation, and canonical inquiry into all these transactions, if the world last so long, and the existence of the church of God. Moreover your last proceeding is a thing worthy of wonder, and a proverb, and the clapping of hands; whether it be the result of hasty passion, or of hatred, or of the pride of power; or whatever was the object for which you did it; do you settle this and decide it in. your own mind, and whether it was an act fittingly done, and after careful examination; that after you had fallen upon your captives, as if they had been the spoil of war, or like a robber on his prey, and forced them to submit to communion with you; that then, after they had taken part with you in thirty-six consecrations of the Eucharist, and the liturgies during the whole feast of Passover as well as subsequently, and you had received them in right of their former ordination, and had made the presbyters sit with your presbyters in the chancel during all those days called the love feasts, and similarly had admitted the deacons to perform the office of the diaconate with the rest of your deacons, and had placed them according to their degree, that then finally, after all this, you ventured upon the annulling of their former ordination by some strange act of senseless audacity. But a point which we would now leave to your consideration and judgment is this, that in case you were determined, contrary to order and the canons of the church, thus to act, you should have done so before you had admitted them to officiate with you at the consecration of the Eucharist, and not, after all these communions, at which they had been present and taken part with you by right of their former priesthood, then to turn round, and depose them and ordain them afresh.' Much further was said on both sides, which from its copiousness and length we must omit; but it proved to him that his conduct was open to censure, and that, if he examined what he had done, he could not acquit himself of fault, especially in his last and most extraordinary act of annulling the orders of those whom he had himself admitted to officiate with him. Upon these points his silence plainly showed that he felt he was wrong, as he had nothing to answer but arguments of a most trifling and unmeaning character.
{"author":"Historical John of Ephesus collection (ancient narrative with English translator explanatory bridges)","date_end":null,"date_label":"Date uncertain","date_start":null,"edition_year":null,"edition_year_basis":"Historical Oxford English translation1860; native2002transcription; exact physical printing unestablished","id":"native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:ddb978a2c2681595bfce","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"license_url":"https://tertullian.org/fathers/ephesus_1_book1.htm","public_import_allowed":true,"publication_location":"source-library","record_type":"source-library-passage","references":[],"rights_approved":true,"section":"Original source paragraph 28","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_library_url":"/library/daca0e07a49d11399f83/#native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:ddb978a2c2681595bfce","source_url":"https://tertullian.org/fathers/ephesus_1_book1.htm#p26","translator":"R. Payne Smith (historical English translation and explanatory bridges,1860); Roger Pearse (2002 transcription, explicitly dedicated to public domain)","verification":{"proof_file":"raw/review/john-ephesus-batch-0152/proof-records.jsonl","proof_file_sha256":"0178d888dc858ca9d0b79f375bdd6a9380f3a30538c33bd103907ef5f5e10664","proof_record_id":"native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:ddb978a2c2681595bfce"},"verified":true,"work":"Ecclesiastical History of John of Ephesus, Part III, Book 1 (historical Payne Smith English edition, including explanatory bridges)","work_id":"john-ephesus-history-part3-book1"}
{"author":"Historical John of Ephesus collection (ancient narrative with English translator explanatory bridges)","date_end":null,"date_label":"Date uncertain","date_start":null,"edition_year":null,"edition_year_basis":"Historical Oxford English translation1860; native2002transcription; exact physical printing unestablished","id":"native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:ddb978a2c2681595bfce","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"license_url":"https://tertullian.org/fathers/ephesus_1_book1.htm","public_import_allowed":true,"publication_location":"source-library","record_type":"source-library-passage","references":[],"rights_approved":true,"section":"Original source paragraph 28","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_library_url":"/library/daca0e07a49d11399f83/#native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:ddb978a2c2681595bfce","source_url":"https://tertullian.org/fathers/ephesus_1_book1.htm#p26","translator":"R. Payne Smith (historical English translation and explanatory bridges,1860); Roger Pearse (2002 transcription, explicitly dedicated to public domain)","verification":{"note":null,"reference_proofs":[],"source_id":"daca0e07a49d11399f83","source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"264eda63bb6891007b740df480c81638dcd8512e31bed27fc2f268e7eeef5f91"},"html_sha256":"264eda63bb6891007b740df480c81638dcd8512e31bed27fc2f268e7eeef5f91","xpath":"/html/body/p[28]"},"source_paragraph_index":28,"source_path":"raw/review/john-ephesus-payne-smith-source-stage-20261015/daca0e07a49d11399f83.html","source_record_file":"raw/review/john-ephesus-batch-0152/original-source-records.jsonl","source_record_file_bytes":2688788,"source_record_file_sha256":"c343d00b21214d320ca2ab78baf2792439073e891685c3584f0418d9b322577f","source_record_id":"native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:ddb978a2c2681595bfce","source_sha256":"132e163d61291163ec166323a605cebca57c112b5e8ea2fd0b732636a45f529d","text_sha256":"2f71248139e52cecd3f92a6a55a2bc98894e34ccc0dff749c02ddd1f3cea7950","type":"whole-john-ephesus-native-prose"},"verified":true,"work":"Ecclesiastical History of John of Ephesus, Part III, Book 1 (historical Payne Smith English edition, including explanatory bridges)","work_id":"john-ephesus-history-part3-book1"}