340 JEROME.
we have not to thank you for it, that only be-
gotten sons also are called first-born. . 13. The last proposition of Helvidius was
this, and it is what he wished to show when
he treated of the first-born, that brethren of the
Lord are mentioned in the Gospels. For ex-
ample,1 " Behold, his mother and his brethren
stood without, seeking to speak to him."
And elsewhere,2 " After this he went down to Capernaum, he, and his mother, and his
brethren." And again,3 "His brethren there- fore said unto him, Depart hence, and go into
Judaea, that thy disciples also may behold the works which thou doest. For no man doeth
anything in secret, and himself seeketh to be
known openly. If thou doest these things,
manifest thyself to the world." And John
adds,4 " For even his brethren did not believe
on him." Mark also and Matthew,6 " And coming into his own country he taught them
in their synagogues, insomuch that they were
astonished, and said, Whence hath this man
this wisdom, and mighty works ? Is not this
the carpenter's son ? is not his mother called Mary? and his brethren James, and Joseph,
and Simon, and Judas ? And his sisters, are
they not all with us?" Luke also in the Acts
of the Apostles relates,8 " These all with one accord continued stedfastly in prayer, with
the women and Mary the mother of Jesus,
and with his brethren." Paul the Apostle also is at one with them, and witnesses to their
historical accuracy, ' " And I went up by revelation, but other of the apostles saw I
none, save Peter and James the Lord's
brother." And again in another place,8 " Have we no right to eat and drink ? Have we no
right to lead about wives even as the rest of
the Apostles, and the brethren of the Lord,
and Cephas ? " And for fear any one should not allow the evidence of the Jews, since it
was they from whose mouth we hear the name
of His brothers, but should maintain that
His countrymen were deceived by the same
error in respect of the brothers into which
they fell in their belief about the father,
Helvidius utters a sharp note of warning
and cries, " The same names are repeated by the Evangelists in another place, and
the same persons are there brethren of the
Lord and sons of Mary." Matthew says,9
" And many women were there (doubtless at
the Lord's cross) beholding from afar, which had followed Jesus from Galilee, ministering
unto him : among whom was Mary Magda-
lene, and Mary the mother of James and
1 S. Matt. xii. 46. » S. John ii. 12.
3 S. John vii. 3, 4. * S. John vii. 5.
6 S. Matt. xiii. 54, 55. S. Mark vi. 1-3 6 Acts i. 14.
8 i Cor. ix. 4, 5.
8 S. Matt, xxvii. 55, 56. Foryoses, Jerome has Joseph.
Gal. ii.
Joses, and the mother of the sons of Zebe-
dee." Mark also,1 "And there were also women beholding from afar, among whom
were both Mary Magdalene, and Mary the
mother of James the less and of Joses, and
Salome " ; and in the same place shortly after,
" And many other women which came up with
him unto Jerusalem." Luke too,* " Now there were Mary Magdalene, and Joanna, and Mary
the mother of James, and the other women
with them." 14. My reason for repeating the same thing
again and again is to prevent him from rais-
ing a false issue and crying out that I have
withheld such passages as make for him, and that his view has been torn to shreds
not by evidence of Scripture, but by eva-
sive arguments. Observe, he says, James
and Joses are sons of Mary, and the same
persons who were called brethren by the
Jews. Observe, Mary is the mother of James
the less and of Joses. And James is called
the less to distinguish him from James the
greater, who was the son of Zebedee, as
Mark elsewhere states,3 " And Mary Magda- lene and Mary the mother of Joses beheld where he was laid. And when the sabbath
was past, they bought spices, that they might
come and anoint him." And, as might be ex-
pected, he says: "What a poor and impious view we take of Mary, if we hold that when other women were concerned about the burial
of Jesus, she His mother was absent ; or if we
invent some kind of a second Mary ; and all
the more because the Gospel of S. John testifies
that she was there present, when the Lord
upon the cross commended her, as His mother
and now a widow, to the care of John. Or
must we suppose that the Evangelists were so far mistaken and so far mislead us as to call
Mary the mother of those who were known
to the Jews as brethren of Jesus ? " 15. What darkness, what raging madness
rushing to its own destruction ! You say that
the mother of the Lord was present at the
cross, you say that she was entrusted to the
disciple John on account of her widowhood and
solitary condition : as if upon your own show-
ing, she had not four sons, and numerous
daughters, with whose solace she might com- fort herself ? You also apply to her the name
of widow which is not found in Scripture.
And although you quote all instances in the
Gospels, the words of John alone displease
you. You say in passing that she was pres- ent at the cross, that you may not appear to
have omitted it on purpose, and yet not a
word about the women who were with her.
could pardon you if you were ignorant, but I
1 S. Marc. xv. 40, 41. For Joses, Jerome has Joseph. 2 S. Luc. xxiv. 10. 3 S. Mark xv. 47 : xvi. i.