58 MEMORIALS OF TWO SISTERS [1850-1
be too. Don't laugh at me for making plans for a garden I
shall never have. I may defend myself by appealing to so
great an example as Lord Bacon ! ! Didn't he write two
whole Essays about a house and garden such as he should
like (just as children make plans which they half hope the
fairies may realize) and put them in among Essays on
Government and all the Virtues ?
July i6th. Yesterday Emily called on Alice's Miss
Martineau
*
and Miss Pilkington, and had a great deal of
talk with them about Mr. Newman's new book, which had
made a painful impression on them, and a false one as to
his character ; as it would do on every one, I think, who
had not read his " Soul " with comprehension, and who
was not acquainted with Mr. Newman himself. It made
them think him cold and hard, with extraordinary powers
of intellect, but without the capacity for deep religious
feeling. That was natural, because Mr. N., more than
any one I ever knew, has a faculty of separating feeling
and reasoning, of looking at things simply on the side of
feeling, and of looking at things on which he feels most
deeply, simplyon the scientific and intellectual side. In the
" Phases of Faith " he does the latter, and moreover gives
only the negative part of the intellectual side ; it is simply
a history of the destructive process in his own mind. It is
almost impossible to keep this in mind in reading his
"
Phases," there is so much to shock one, yet it is also
impossible to judge rightly of it without.
1 Miss RachelMartineau, the eldest of Mr. James Martineau's sisters,
for many years kept a boarding-school at Liverpool, which was, I think,
about the most admirably managed of any schools I have ever known,
both with regard to the thoroughness of the intellectual training
imparted, and also the very wise care which Miss Martineau took
of the health of her pupils, which was really a sanitary education
for them. Several schools came under discussion, but it was finally
arranged that Alice went to Miss Martineau's, where, besides the ex-
cellent general instruction, she had the advantage of lessons from
Mr. Martineau himself, in Latin, mathematics, and history (afterwards
from Mr. J. H. Hutton, during Mr. Martineau's absence in Germany),
and of learning music from Mr. James Herrmann, the leader of the
Liverpool Concerts.