come to the knowledge of the Being of God, is that which the apostle speaks of, Rom. i.20.
The invisible things of him, from the creation of the world, are clearly seen; being understood
by the things that are made; even his eternal power and Godhead. We first ascend, and prove
a posteriori, or from effects, that there must be an eternal Cause; and then secondly, prove
by argumentation, not intuition, that this Being must be necessarily existent; and then
thirdly, from the proved necessity of his existence, we may descend, and prove many of his
perfections a priori. 109
But if once this grand principle of common sense be given up, that what is not necessary
in itself, must have a Cause; and we begin to maintain, that things which heretofore have
not been, may come into existence, and begin to be of themselves, without any cause; all
our means of ascending in our arguing from the creature to the Creator, and all our evidence
of the Being of God, is cut off at one blow. In this case, we cannot prove that there is a God,
either from the Being of the world, and the creatures in it, or from the manner of their Being,
their order, beauty, and use. For if things may come into existence without any Cause at all,
then they doubtless may without any Cause answerable to the effect. Our minds do alike
naturally suppose and determine both these things; namely, that what begins to be has a
Cause, and also that it has a Cause proportionable to the effect. The same principle which
leads us to determine, that there cannot be any thing coming to pass without a Cause, leads
us to determine that there cannot be more in the effect than in the Cause.
Yea, if once it should be allowed, that things may come to pass without a Cause, we
should not only have no proof of the Being of God, but we should be without evidence of
the existence of any thing whatsoever, but our own immediately present ideas and conscious-
109 To the inquirer after the truth it may here be recommended, as a matter of some consequence, to keep
in mind the precise difference between an argument a priori and one a posteriori, a distinction of considerable
use, as well as of long standing, among divines, metaphysicians, and logical writers. An argument from either
of these, when legitimately applied, may amount to a demonstration, when used for instance, relatively to the
being and perfections of God; but the one should be confined to the existence of Deity, while the other is applicable
to his perfections. By the argument a posteriori we rise from the effect to the cause, from the stream to the
fountain, from what is posterior to what is prior; in other words, from what is contingent to what is absolute,
from number to unity; that is, from the manifestation of God to his existence. By the argument a priori we descend
from the cause to the effect, from the fountain to the stream, from what is prior to what is posterior; that is,
from the necessary existence of God we safely infer certain properties and perfections. To attempt a demonstration
of the existence of a first cause, or the Being of God, a priori, would be most absurd; for it would be an attempt
to prove a prior ground or cause of existence of a first cause; or, that there is some cause before the very first.
The argument a priori, therefore, is not applicable to prove the divine existence. For this end, the argument a
posteriori alone is legitimate; and its conclusiveness rests on this axiom, that “there can be no effect without a
cause.”–The absurdity of denying this axiom is abundantly demonstrated by our author.—W.
552
SECTION III. Whether any Event whatsoever, and Volition in particular,…