SECT. III.
The case of such as are given up of God to sin, and of fallen man in general, proves moral
Necessity and Inability to be consistent with Blameworthiness.
Dr. Whitby asserts freedom, not only from coaction, but Necessity, to be essential to
any thing deserving the name of sin, and to an action being culpable; in these words, (Dis-
course on Five Points, edit. 3. p. 348.) “If they be thus necessitated, then neither their sins
of omission or commission could deserve that name: it being essential to the nature of sin,
according to St. Austin’s definition, that it be an action a quo liberum est abstinere. Three
things seem plainly necessary to make an action or omission culpable; 1. That it be in our
power to perform or forbear it: for, as Origen, and all the fathers, say, no man is blameworthy
for not doing what he could not do.” And elsewhere the Doctor insists, that “when any do
evil of Necessity, what they do is no vice, that they are guilty of no fault, 126 are worthy of
no blame, dispraise, 127 or dishonour, 128 but are unblamable.” 129
If these things are true, in Dr. Whitby’s sense of Necessity, they will prove all such to
be blameless, who are given up of God to sin, in what they commit after they are thus given
up,—That there is such a thing as men being judicially given up to sin, is certain, if the
Scripture rightly informs us; such a thing being often there spoken of: as in Psal. lxxxi. 12.“So
I gave them up to their own hearts’ lust, and they walked in their own counsels.” (Acts vii.
42.) “Then God turned, and gave them up to worship the host of heaven.” (Rom. i. 24.)
“Wherefore, God also gave them up to uncleanness, through the lusts of their own hearts,
to dishonour their own bodies between themselves.” (Rom. I. 26.) “For this cause God gave
them up to vile affections.” (Rom. i. 28.) “And even as they did not like to retain God in
their knowledge, God gave them over to a reprobate mind, to do those things that are not
convenient.”
It is needless to stand particularly to inquire, what God’s “giving men up to their own
hearts’ lusts” signifies: it is sufficient to observe, that hereby is certainly meant God so order-
ing or disposing things, in some respect or other, either by doing or forbearing to do, as that
the consequence should be men continuing in their sins. So much as men are given up to,
so much is the consequence of their being given up, whether that be less or more. If God
does not order things so, by action or permission, that sin will be the consequence, then the
event proves that they are not given up to that consequence. If good be the consequence,
instead of evil, then God’s mercy is to be acknowledged in that good; which mercy must be
contrary to God’s judgment in giving up to evil. If the event must prove, that they are given
126 Discourse on the five Points, p. 347, 360, 361, 377
127 303, 326, 329, and many other places.
128 371.
129 304, 361.
SECTION III. The case of such as are given up of God to sin, and of fallen man in general, proves moral Necessity and Inability to be consistent with Blameworthiness.
637
SECTION III. The case of such as are given up of God to sin, and of fallen…