Boox 11. | ARNOBIUS ADVERSUS GENTES. 105
have been destined to live here and be the tenants of an
earthly body for no purpose? They have a share, [my oppo-
nent says,] in perfecting the completeness of this immense
mass, and without their addition this whole universe is in-
complete and imperfect. What then? If there were not
men, would the world cease to discharge its functions ? would
the stars not go through their changes? would there not
be summers and winters? would the blasts of the winds be
lulled? and from the clouds gathered and hanging [over-
head] would not the showers come down upon the earth to
temper droughts? But now’ all things must go on in their
own courses, and not give up following the arrangement
established by nature, even if there should be no name of
man heard in the world, and this earth should be still with
the silence of an unpeopled desert. How then is it alleged
that it was necessary that an inhabitant should be given to
these regions, since it is clear that by man comes nothing
to [aid in] perfecting the world, and that all his exertions
regard his private convenience always, and never cease to
aim at his own advantage?
38. For, to begin with what is important, what advantage
is it to the world that the mightiest kings are here? What,
that there are tyrants, lords, [and] other innumerable and
very illustrious powers? What, that there are generals of
the greatest experience in war, skilled in taking cities;
soldiers steady and utterly invincible in battles of cavalry;
or in fighting hand to hand on foot? What, that there
are orators, grammarians, poets, writers, logicians, musi-
cians, ballet-dancers, mimics, actors, singers, trumpeters, flute
and reed players? What, that there are runners, boxers,
charioteers, vaulters,’ walkers on stilts, rope-dancers, jugglers ?
where the Epicurean argument is brought forward, What profit has God
in man, that he should have created him? In doing this, it seems not
to have been observed that the question asked by Arnobius is a very
different one: What place has man in the world, that God should be
supposed to have sent him to fill it ?
1 i.e. so far from this being the case.
? i.e. from one horse to another—desultores.