SECT. III.
That propensity, which has been proved to be in the nature of all mankind, must be a very
evil, depraved, and pernicious propensity; making it manifest, that the soul of man, as it is by
nature, is in a corrupt, fallen, and ruined state; which is the other part of the consequence,
drawn from the proposition laid down in the first section.
The question to be considered, in order to determine whether man’s nature be depraved
and ruined, is not, Whether he is inclined to perform as many good deeds as bad ones? But,
to which of these two he preponderates, in the frame of his heart, and the state of his nature,
a state of innocence and righteousness, and favour with God; or a state of sin, guiltiness, and
abhorrence in the sight of God?—Persevering sinless righteousness, or else the guilt of sin,
is the alternative, on the decision of which depends—according to the nature and truth of
things, as they are in themselves, and according to the rule of right, and of perfect
justice—man being approved and accepted of his Maker and eternally blessed as good; or
his being rejected, and cursed as bad. And therefore the determination of the tendency of
man’s heart and nature, with respect to these terms, is that which is to be looked at, in order
to determine whether his nature is good or evil, pure or corrupt, sound or ruined. If such
be man’s nature, and the state of his heart, that he has an infallibly effectual propensity to
the latter of those terms; then it is wholly impertinent to talk of the innocent and kind actions,
152
even of criminals themselves, surpassing their crimes in numbers, and of the prevailing inno-
cence, good nature, industry, felicity, and cheerfulness of the greater part of mankind. Let
never so many thousands or millions of acts of honesty, good nature, &c. be supposed; yet,
by the supposition, there is an unfailing propensity to such moral evil, as in its dreadful
consequences infinitely outweighs all effects or consequences of any supposed good. Surely
that tendency, which, in effect, is an infallible tendency to eternal destruction, is an infinitely
dreadful and pernicious tendency: and that nature and frame of mind, which implies such
a tendency, must be an infinitely dreadful and pernicious frame of mind. It would be much
more absurd to suppose, that such a state of nature is not bad, under a notion of men doing
more honest and kind things than evil ones; than to say, the state of that ship is good, for
crossing the Atlantic ocean, though such as cannot hold together through the voyage, but
will infallibly founder and sink, under a notion that it may probably go great part of the way
before it sinks, or that it will proceed and sail above water more hours than it will be in
sinking: or, to pronounce that road a good road to go to such a place, the greater part of
which is plain and safe, though some parts of it are dangerous, and certainly fatal, to them
that travel in it; or to call that a good propensity, which is an inflexible inclination to travel
in such a way.
A propensity to that sin which brings God’s eternal wrath and curse (which has been
proved to belong to the nature of man) is evil, not only as it is calamitous and sorrowful,
ending in great natural evil; but as it is odious and detestable; for by the supposition, it tends
SECTION III. This tendency most corrupt and pernicious.
949
SECTION III. This tendency most corrupt and pernicious.