Chapter 74.—163. Petilianus said: "But these things do not alarm us Christians; for of
the evil deeds which you are destined to commit we have before a warning given us by the
Lord Christ. ‘Behold,’ He says, ‘I send you forth as sheep in the midst of wolves.’2175 You
fill up the measure of the madness of wolves, who either lay or are preparing to lay snares
against the Churches in precisely the same way in which wolves, with their mouths wide
open against the fold, even with destructive eagerness, breathe forth panting anger from
their jaws, suffused with blood."
164. Augustin answered: I should be glad to utter the same sentiment against you, but
not in the words which you have used: they are too inappropriate, or rather mad. But what
was required was, that you should show that we were wolves and that you were sheep, not
by the emptiest of evil-speaking, but by some distinct proofs. For when I too have said, We
are sheep, and you are wolves, do you think that there is any difference caused by the fact
that you express the idea in swelling words? But listen whilst I prove what I assert. For the
Lord says in the gospel, as you know full well, whether you please it or not, "My sheep hear
my voice, and follow me."2176 There are many sayings of the Lord on different subjects;
but supposing, for example, that any one were in doubt whether the same Lord had risen
in the body, and His words were to be quoted where He says, "Handle me, and see; for a
spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me have;"—if even after this he should be unwilling
to acquiesce in the belief that His body had risen from the dead, surely such a man could
not be reckoned among the sheep of the Lord, because he would not hear His voice. And
so too now, when the question between us is, Where is the Church? whilst we quote the
words that follow in the same passage of the gospel, where, after His resurrection, He gave
His body even to be handled by those who were in doubt, in which He showed the future
wide extent of the Church, saying, "Thus it is written, and thus it behoved Christ to suffer,
and to rise from the dead the third day; and that repentance and remission of sins should
be preached in His name throughout all nations, beginning at Jerusalem;"2177 whereas you
will not communicate with all nations, in whom these words have been fulfilled, how are
you the sheep of this Shepherd, whose words you not only do not obey when you have heard
them, but even fight against them? And so we show to you from this that you are not sheep.
But listen further whence we show you that, on the contrary, you are wolves. For necessarily,
when it is shown by His own words where the Church is to be found, it is also clear where
we must look for the fold of Christ. Whenever, therefore, any sheep separate themselves
from this fold, which is expressly pointed out and shown to us by the unmistakeable declar-
ation of the Lord,—and that, I will not say because of charges falsely brought, but on account
2175 Matt. x. 16.
2176 John x. 27.
2177 Luke xxiv. 39, 46, 47.
Chapter 74
1115
Chapter 74