of Christ), who had consulted you on this question,2723—I did not add it to the others for
two reasons, first,—because, in examining this opinion, we discuss not the incarnation of
the soul, but its nature; secondly, because this is the view held by those against whom I was
arguing, and the main design of my argument was to prove that the blameless and inviolable
nature of the Creator has nothing to do with the faults and blemishes of the creature, while
they, on their part, maintained that the substance of the good God itself is, in so far as it is
led captive, corrupted and oppressed and brought under a necessity of sinning by the sub-
stance of evil, to which they ascribe a proper dominion and principalities. Leaving, therefore,
out of the question this heretical error, I desire to know which of the other four opinions
we ought to choose. For whichever of them may justly claim our preference, far be it from
us to assail this article of faith, about which we have no uncertainty, that every soul, even
the soul of an infant, requires to be delivered from the binding guilt of sin, and that there
is no deliverance except through Jesus Christ and Him crucified.
Chap. IV.
8. To avoid prolixity, therefore, let me refer to the opinion which you, I believe, entertain,
viz. that God even now makes each soul for each individual at the time of birth. To meet
the objection to this view which might be taken from the fact that God finished the whole
work of creation on the sixth day and rested on the seventh day, you quote the testimony
526
of the words in the gospel, “My Father worketh hitherto, and I work.”2724 This you have
written in your letter to Marcellinus, in which letter, moreover, you have most kindly con-
descended to mention my name, saying that he had me here in Africa, who could more
easily explain to him the opinion held by you.2725 But had I been able to do this, he would
not have applied for instruction to you, who were so remote from him, though perhaps he
did not write from Africa to you. For I know not when he wrote it; I only know that he knew
well my hesitation to embrace any definite view on this subject, for which reason he preferred
to write to you without consulting me. Yet, even if he had consulted me, I would rather have
encouraged him to write to you, and would have expressed my gratitude for the benefit
which might have been conferred on us all, had you not preferred to send a brief note, instead
of a full reply, doing this, I suppose, to save yourself from unnecessary expenditure of effort
in a place where I, whom you supposed to be thoroughly acquainted with the subject of his
inquiries, was at hand. Behold, I am willing that the opinion which you hold should be also
mine; but I assure you that as yet I have not embraced it.
9. You have sent to me scholars, to whom you wish me to impart what I have not yet
learned myself. Teach me, therefore, what I am to teach them; for many urge me vehemently
2723 Letter CLXV.
2724 John v. 17.
2725 See Letter CLXV., p. 522.
1119
To Jerome