it, how could they accomplish their wish without the consent of the god or demon, when
they cannot touch so much as a sparrow unless it be caged?
There is, then, nothing to hinder the gods from mingling in a bodily form with men,
from seeing and being seen, from speaking and hearing. And if the demons do thus mix
with men, as I said, and are not polluted, while the gods, were they to do so, should be pol-
luted, then the demons are less liable to pollution than the gods. And if even the demons
are contaminated, how can they help men to attain blessedness after death, if, so far from
being able to cleanse them, and present them clean to the unpolluted gods, these mediators
are themselves polluted? And if they cannot confer this benefit on men, what good can
their friendly mediation do? Or shall its result be, not that men find entrance to the gods,
but that men and demons abide together in a state of pollution, and consequently of exclusion
from blessedness? Unless, perhaps, some one may say that, like sponges or things of that
sort, the demons themselves, in the process of cleansing their friends, become themselves
the filthier in proportion as the others become clean. But if this is the solution, then the
gods, who shun contact or intercourse with men for fear of pollution, mix with demons
who are far more polluted. Or perhaps the gods, who cannot cleanse men without polluting
themselves, can without pollution cleanse the demons who have been contaminated by hu-
man contact? Who can believe such follies, unless the demons have practised their deceit
upon him? If seeing and being seen is contamination, and if the gods, whom Apuleius
himself calls visible, “the brilliant lights of the world,”353 and the other stars, are seen by
men, are we to believe that the demons, who cannot be seen unless they please, are safer
from contamination? Or if it is only the seeing and not the being seen which contaminates,
then they must deny that these gods of theirs, these brilliant lights of the world, see men
when their rays beam upon the earth. Their rays are not contaminated by lighting on all
manner of pollution, and are we to suppose that the gods would be contaminated if they
mixed with men, and even if contact were needed in order to assist them? For there is
contact between the earth and the sun’s or moon’s rays, and yet this does not pollute the
light.
353 Virgil, Georg. i. 5.
405
Whether It is Reasonable in the Platonists to Determine that the Celestial…