to be a whore and a witch, and her children bastards, or children of adultery. Isa. lvii. . “Draw
near hither, ye sons of the sorceress, the seed of the adulterer and the whore.” We have the
like in other places. And so the body of the same people in Christ’s time—which Mr. W.
supposes even then to be branches of the true olive, in the same manner as the members of
the christian church were in the apostles’ times—are visibly declared not to be God’s children,
or children of the true church, but bastards, or an adulterous brood. Matt. xii. 39. “An evil
and adulterous generation seeketh after a sign.” Ver. 45. ” Even so shall it be with this wicked
generation.” And certainly the people were then, visibly and in the eyes of men, such as
Christ had visibly and openly, and in the sight of men, declared them to be.
If the question be not concerning the visibility which makes it lawful for others to admit
persons, but concerning the qualifications which render it lawful for them to come, still the
objection is no more against my scheme than against Mr. W.‘s. He (in p. 84—86.) says, that
such openly scandalous persons ought not to be admitted into the church; insinuating, that
these scandalous people among the Jews were otherwise when they were admitted at first:
but that being taken in, and not cast out again, it was lawful for them to be there, and they
had a lawful right to the privileges of the church. But this supposition, that all who are lawfully
admitted by others, may lawfully come into the church, and lawfully continue to partake of
its privileges till cast out, is utterly inconsistent with Mr. W.‘s own scheme. For according
to his scheme, it is not lawful for men that are not morally sincere, to partake of the privileges
of the church; but yet such may in some cases be lawfully admitted by others; for he main-
tains, that in admitting them, they are not to act as searchers of hearts, even with regard to
their moral sincerity; and so argues, (p. 106.) that Christ might give Judas the sacrament,
when not morally sincere. If Christ as head of the visible church might admit Judas to his
table, when he knew he was not morally sincere, and when it was not lawful for Judas himself
to come; then it is lawful for men to admit some, for whom it is not lawful to be there; con-
trary to Mr. W.‘s assertion in p. 86. b.
It is true, that persons may become grossly scandalous, after having been regularly ad-
mitted on Mr. W.‘s principles, on a profession in words of indiscriminate signification. And
so they may after being regularly admitted, according to my principles, on a credible profes-
sion of gospel-holiness in words of a determinate meaning: and therefore the gross
wickedness of such apostates as we read of in Scripture, is no more an objection against my
principles, than his.
Just in the same manner is Mr. W.‘s arguing (p. 59—63.) concerning the members of
churches mentioned in the epistles, equally against his own scheme and mine. He largely
insists on it, that the apostle speaks of many of them as grossly scandalous, notoriously
wicked persons, idolaters, heretics, fornicators, adulterers, adulteresses, &c. &c. In his arguing
from these things, he is inconsistent with his own principles, two ways. (1.) Such a character
is as plainly inconsistent with the character he insists on as necessary to render it lawful for
2005
SECTION XI. Arguments hostile to both sides