SECT. III.
The inconsistence of the fore-mentioned concessions with the lawfulness of unsanctified
persons coming to the Lord’s supper, and their right to sacraments in the sight of God.
Mr. W. in the book under consideration, which he entitles the true state of the question,
insists upon it that the question to be debated is the question Mr. Stoddard debated in his
dispute with Dr. Mather; in whose scheme Mr. W. declares himself to be. Mr. S. in his dispute
with Dr. Mather asserted, that it was lawful for some unsanctified men to come to the Lord’s
supper, and that they had a right so to do in the sight of God. And he declares that this was
the point in dispute between him and Dr. Mather; as in Appeal, p. 20. “That which I am to
show is, that some unsanctified men have a right before God to the Lord’s supper.” So Mr.
Blake (who is so great an author with Mr. W.) says in his treatise on the covenant, p. 244.
“That faith which is the condition of the promise, is not the condition in foro Dei [before
God] of a title to the seal.” And there (in the next p.) he insists, that it is a common faith,
that is believed by men not justified, which gives this title. Agreeable to these things Mr. W.
says, (p. 132. d.) Some men have a lawful right to the sacrament without sanctification.
Which is the same thing as to say, They have a right in the sight of God. For if they have no
right in the sight of God to come to the Lord’s supper, then it is not lawful in the sight of
God that they should come.
Here I would lay down this as a maxim;
There is some inward religion and virtue or other, some sincerity of heart, either moral
or saving, that is necessary to a right to sacraments in the sight of God, and in order to a
lawful coming to them. No man, I trust, will say, that a man has a right in God’s sight, who
has no sort of seriousness of mind; and that merely outward sounds and motions give him
this right in God’s sight, without regard to any property or quality of mind, and though this
outward show is joined with the most horrid and resolved secret irreligion and wickedness.
Mr. W. in particular utterly disclaims such doctrine as this, and always maintains that in
order to men’s lawful coming, they must be morally sincere; as in his Preface, and also in p.
25. d. e. p. 27. c. p. 30. d. p. 35. e. p. 111.—In p. 115, he supposes, that if a man makes a doubt
of his moral sincerity, no divine will advise him to come till he knows.
Having observed this, I now desire it may be considered, whether it be reasonable to
suppose, as Mr. W. does, that God would give men that are without grace, a lawful right to
sacraments, so that this qualification itself should be nothing necessary to a proper and
rightful claim to these ordinances; and yet that he would wholly forbid them to come, and
others to admit them, without their making some pretence to it, and exhibiting moral
evidence that they have it: that moral sincerity is the qualification which by God’s own ap-
pointment invests persons with a lawful right to sacraments, and that by his institution
nothing more is requisite to a lawful right; and yet that he has commanded them not to
come, nor others to allow them to come, without making a profession of something more
SECTION III. Of ungodly men's communing.
1925
SECTION III. Of ungodly men's communing.