are decreed by emperors against the parties who, having of their own accord brought forward
accusations, were unable to substantiate them, and who, when a welcome back to the bosom
of peace was offered to them on condition of their amendment, refused the terms, an outcry
is raised that this is an unworthy wrong, and it is maintained that no one ought to be coerced
to unity, and that evil should not be requited for evil to any one. What else is this than what
one of yourselves wrote: “What we wish is holy”?2171 And in view of these things, it was not
a great or difficult thing for you to reflect and discover how the decree and sentence of
Constantine, which was published against you on the occasion of your predecessors so fre-
quently bringing before the Emperor charges which they could not make good, should be
in force against you; and how all succeeding emperors, especially those who are Catholic
Christians, necessarily act according to it as often as the exigencies of your obstinacy make
it necessary for them to take any measures in regard to you.
15. It was an easy thing for you to have reflected on these things, and perhaps some time
to have said to yourselves: Seeing that Cæcilianus either was innocent, or at least could not
be proved guilty, what sin has the Christian Church spread so far and wide through the
world committed in this matter? On what ground could it be unlawful for the Christian
world to remain ignorant of that which even those who made it matter of accusation against
others could not prove? Why should those whom Christ has sown in His field, that is, in
this world, and has commanded to grow alongside of the tares until the harvest,2172—those
many thousands of believers in all nations, whose multitude the Lord compared to the stars
of heaven and the sand of the sea, to whom He promised of old, and has now given, the
blessing in the seed of Abraham,—why, I ask, should the name of Christians be denied to
all these, because, forsooth, in regard to this case, in the discussion of which they took no
part, they preferred to believe the judges, who under grave responsibility gave their decision,
rather than the plaintiffs, against whom the decision was given? Surely no man’s crime can
stain with guilt another who does not know of its commission. How could the faithful,
scattered throughout the world, be cognisant of the crime of surrendering the sacred books
as committed by men, whose guilt their accusers, even if they knew it, were at least unable
to prove? Unquestionably this one fact of ignorance on their part most easily demonstrates
that they had no share in the guilt of this crime. Why then should the innocent be charged
with crimes which they never committed, because of their being ignorant of crimes which,
justly or unjustly, are laid to the charge of others? What room is left for innocence, if it is
criminal for one to be ignorant of the crimes of others? Moreover, if the mere fact of their
ignorance proves, as has been said, the innocence of the people in so many nations, how
great is the crime of separation from the communion of these innocent people! For the
2171 “Quod volumus sanctum est.”—Tychonius.
2172 Matt. xiii. 24–30.
855
To Vincentius