Chapter 1.—The Point at Which the Discussion Has Arrived, and What Remains to Be
Handled.
Some have advanced the opinion that there are both good and bad gods; but some,
thinking more respectfully of the gods, have attributed to them so much honor and praise
as to preclude the supposition of any god being wicked. But those who have maintained
that there are wicked gods as well as good ones have included the demons under the name
“gods,” and sometimes though more rarely, have called the gods demons; so that they admit
that Jupiter, whom they make the king and head of all the rest, is called a demon by
Homer.334 Those, on the other hand, who maintain that the gods are all good, and far more
excellent than the men who are justly called good, are moved by the actions of the demons,
which they can neither deny nor impute to the gods whose goodness they affirm, to distin-
guish between gods and demons; so that, whenever they find anything offensive in the deeds
or sentiments by which unseen spirits manifest their power, they believe this to proceed not
from the gods, but from the demons. At the same time they believe that, as no god can hold
direct intercourse with men, these demons hold the position of mediators, ascending with
prayers, and returning with gifts. This is the opinion of the Platonists, the ablest and most
esteemed of their philosophers, with whom we therefore chose to debate this ques-
tion,—whether the worship of a number of gods is of any service toward obtaining
blessedness in the future life. And this is the reason why, in the preceding book, we have
inquired how the demons, who take pleasure in such things as good and wise men loathe
and execrate, in the sacrilegious and immoral fictions which the poets have written not of
men, but of the gods themselves, and in the wicked and criminal violence of magical arts,
can be regarded as more nearly related and more friendly to the gods than men are, and can
mediate between good men and the good gods; and it has been demonstrated that this is
absolutely impossible.
334 See Plutarch, on the Cessation of Oracles.
The Point at Which the Discussion Has Arrived, and What Remains to Be Handled.
383
The Point at Which the Discussion Has Arrived, and What Remains to Be H…