ages (which is now the subject of our argument), for he clearly speaks, not of the very essence
of God the Word, Who was in the beginning with God, but of Him Who emptied Himself
to take the form of a servant, and became conformable to the body of our humiliation702,
and was crucified through weakness.’ And again, ‘This is known to any one who even in a
small degree applies his mind to the meaning of the Apostle’s words, that he is not setting
forth to us the mode of the Divine existence, but is introducing the terms which belong to
the Incarnation; for he says, Him God made Lord and Christ, this Jesus Whom ye crucified,
evidently laying stress by the demonstrative word on that in Him which was human and
was seen by all703.’
“This, then, is what the man has to say who substitutes,—for we may not speak of it as
‘application,’ lest any one should blame for such madness men holy and chosen for the
preaching of godliness, so as to reproach their doctrine with a fall into such extravag-
ance,—who substitutes his own mind704 for the intention of the Apostles! With what con-
fusion are they not filled, who refer their own nonsense to the memory of the saints! With
what absurdity do they not abound, who imagine that the man ‘emptied himself’ to become
man, and who maintain that He Who by obedience ‘humbled himself’ to take the form of
a servant was made conformable to men even before He took that form upon Him! Who,
pray, ye most reckless of men, when he has the form of a servant, takes the form of a servant?
and how can any one ‘empty himself’ to become the very thing which he is? You will find
no contrivance to meet this, bold as you are in saying or thinking things uncontrivable. Are
you not verily of all men most miserable, who suppose that a man has suffered death for all
men, and ascribe your own redemption to him? For if it is not of the Word Who was in the
beginning and was God that the blessed Peter speaks, but of him who was ‘seen,’ and who
‘emptied Himself,’ as Basil says, and if the man who was seen ‘emptied Himself’ to take ‘the
form of a servant,’ and He Who ‘emptied Himself’ to take ‘the form of a servant,’ emptied
Himself to come into being as man, then the man who was seen emptied himself to come
into being as man705. The very nature of things is repugnant to this; and it is expressly
702 Cf. Phil. iii. 21.
703 The latter part of the quotation from S. Basil does not exactly agree with the Benedictine text, but the
variations are not material.
704 Reading ἑαυτοῦ for the ἑαυτῶν of Oehler’s text, for which no authority is alleged by the editor, and which
is probably a mere misprint.
705 The argument here takes the form of a reductio ad absurdum; assuming that S. Peter’s reference is to the
“visible man,” and bearing in mind S. Basil’s words that S. Peter refers to Him Who “emptied Himself,” it is said
“then it was the ‘visible man’ who ‘emptied himself.’ But the purpose of that ‘emptying’ was the ‘taking the form
of a servant,’ which again is the coming into being as man: therefore the ‘visible man’ ‘emptied himself,’ to come
into being as man, which is absurd.” The wording of S. Basil’s statement makes the argument in a certain degree
plausible;—if he had said that S. Peter referred to the Son, not in regard to his actual essence, but in regard to
334
He then explains the phrase of S. Peter, “Him God made Lord and Christ.”…