Chapter 17.—Of Those Who Fancy that No Men Shall Be Punished Eternally.
I must now, I see, enter the lists of amicable controversy with those tender-hearted
Christians who decline to believe that any, or that all of those whom the infallibly just Judge
may pronounce worthy of the punishment of hell, shall suffer eternally, and who suppose
that they shall be delivered after a fixed term of punishment, longer or shorter according to
the amount of each man’s sin. In respect of this matter, Origen was even more indulgent;
for he believed that even the devil himself and his angels, after suffering those more severe
and prolonged pains which their sins deserved, should be delivered from their torments,
and associated with the holy angels. But the Church, not without reason, condemned him
for this and other errors, especially for his theory of the ceaseless alternation of happiness
and misery, and the interminable transitions from the one state to the other at fixed periods
of ages; for in this theory he lost even the credit of being merciful, by allotting to the saints
real miseries for the expiation of their sins, and false happiness, which brought them no
true and secure joy, that is, no fearless assurance of eternal blessedness. Very different,
however, is the error we speak of, which is dictated by the tenderness of these Christians
who suppose that the sufferings of those who are condemned in the judgment will be tem-
porary, while the blessedness of all who are sooner or later set free will be eternal. Which
opinion, if it is good and true because it is merciful, will be so much the better and truer in
proportion as it becomes more merciful. Let, then, this fountain of mercy be extended, and
flow forth even to the lost angels, and let them also be set free, at least after as many and
long ages as seem fit! Why does this stream of mercy flow to all the human race, and dry
up as soon as it reaches the angelic? And yet they dare not extend their pity further, and
propose the deliverance of the devil himself. Or if any one is bold enough to do so, he does
indeed put to shame their charity, but is himself convicted of error that is more unsightly,
and a wresting of God’s truth that is more perverse, in proportion as his clemency of senti-
ment seems to be greater.1529
1529 On the heresy of Origen, see Epiphanius (Epistola ad Joannem Hierosol.); Jerome (Epistola 61, ad Pam-
machium); and Augustin (De Hæres, 43). Origen’s opinion was condemned by Anastasius (Jerome, Apologia
adv. Ruffinum and Epistola 78, ad Pammachium), and after Augustin’s death by Vigilius and Emperor Justinian,
in the Fifth (Œcumenical Council, Nicephorus Callistus, xvii. 27, and the Acts of the Council, iv. 11).—Coquæus.
Of Those Who Fancy that No Men Shall Be Punished Eternally.
1048
Of Those Who Fancy that No Men Shall Be Punished Eternally.