scribe—hence immediately arises enmity in the heart, now wholly under the power of self-
love; and nothing but war ensues, in a constant course, against God. As, when a subject has
once renounced his lawful sovereign, and set up a pretender in his stead, a state of enmity
and war against his rightful king necessarily ensues. It were easy to show, how every lust,
and depraved disposition of man’s heart, would naturally arise from this private original, if
here were room for it. Thus it is easy to give an account, how total corruption of heart should
follow on man’s eating the forbidden fruit, though that was but one act of sin, without God
putting any evil into his heart, or implanting any bad principle, or infusing any corrupt taint,
and so becoming the author of depravity. Only God’s withdrawing, as it was highly proper
and necessary that he should, from rebel-man, and his natural principles being left to
themselves, is sufficient to account for his becoming entirely corrupt, and bent on sinning
against God.
And as Adam’s nature became corrupt, without God’s implanting or infusing of any
evil thing into it; so does the nature of his posterity. God dealing with Adam as the head of
his posterity, (as has been shown,) and treating them as one, he deals with his posterity as
having all sinned in him. And therefore, as God withdrew spiritual communion, and his
vital gracious influence, from the common head, so he withholds the same from all the
members, as they come into existence; whereby they come into the world mere flesh, and
entirely under the government of natural and inferior principles; and so become wholly
corrupt, as Adam did.
Now, for God so far to have the disposal of this affair, as to withhold those influences,
without which, nature will be corrupt, is not to be the author of sin. But, concerning this, I
must refer the reader to what I have said of it in my discourse on the Freedom of the Will.
139 Though, besides what I have there said, I may here observe, that if for God so far to order
and dispose the being of sin, as to permit it, by withholding the gracious influences necessary
to prevent it, is for him to be the author of sin, then some things which Dr. T. himself lays
down, will equally be attended with this very consequence. For, from time to time he speaks
of God giving men up to the vilest lusts and affections, by permitting, or leaving them. 140
Now, if the continuance of sin, and its increase and prevalence, may be in consequence of
God’s disposal, in withholding needful grace, without God being the author of that continu-
ance and prevalence of sin; then, by parity of reason, may the being of sin, in the race of
Adam, be in consequence of Gods disposal, by his withholding that grace which is needful
to prevent it, without his being the author of sin.
If here it should be said, that God is not the author of sin, in giving up to sin those who
have already made themselves sinful, because when men have once made themselves sinful,
139 Part iv. § 9.
140 Key, § 388, note: and Par. on Rom. i. 24, 36.
1144
CHAPTER II. God not the Author of Sin.