of great advantage to the Arian cause, especially toward the close of Constantine’s reign.
From a letter addressed by this Eusebius to Paulinus of Tyre (Theodoret, H. E. I. 6) we learn
that Eusebius of Cæsarea was quite zealous in behalf of the Arian cause. The exact date of
the letter we do not know, but it must have been written at an early stage of the controversy.
Arius himself, in an epistle addressed to Eusebius of Nicomedia (Theodoret, H. E. I. 5),
claims Eusebius of Cæsarea among others as accepting at least one of his fundamental doc-
trines (“And since Eusebius, your brother in Cæsarea, and Theodotus, and Paulinus, and
Athanasius, and Gregory, and Ætius, and all the bishops of the East say that God existed
before the Son, they have been condemned,” etc.). More than this, Sozomen (H. E. I. 15)
informs us that Eusebius of Cæsarea and two other bishops, having been appealed to by
Arius for “permission for himself and his adherents, as he had already attained the rank of
presbyter, to form the people who were with them into a church,” concurred with others
“who were assembled in Palestine,” in granting the petition of Arius, and permitting him
to assemble the people as before; but they “enjoined submission to Alexander, and com-
manded Arius to strive incessantly to be restored to peace and communion with him.” The
addition of the last sentence is noticeable, as showing that they did not care to support a
presbyter in open and persistent rebellion against his bishop. A fragment of a letter written
by our Eusebius to Alexander is still extant, and is preserved in the proceedings of the Second
Council of Nicæa, Act. VI. Tom. V. (Labbei et Cossartii Conc. VII. col. 497). In this epistle
Eusebius strongly remonstrates with Alexander for having misrepresented the views of
Arius. Still further, in his epistle to Alexander of Constantinople, Alexander of Alexandria
(Theodoret, H. E. I. 4) complains of three Syrian bishops “who side with them [i.e. the
Arians] and excite them to plunge deeper and deeper into iniquity.” The reference here is
commonly supposed to be to Eusebius of Cæsarea, and his two friends Paulinus of Tyre and
Theodotus of Laodicea, who are known to have shown favor to Arius. It is probable, though
not certain, that our Eusebius is one of the persons meant. Finally, many of the Fathers
(above all Jerome and Photius), and in addition to them the Second Council of Nicæa, directly
accuse Eusebius of holding the Arian heresy, as may be seen by examining the testimonies
quoted below on p. 67 sq. In agreement with these early Fathers, many modern historians
have attacked Eusebius with great severity, and have endeavored to show that the opinion
that he was an Arian is supported by his own writings. Among those who have judged him
13
most harshly are Baronius (ad ann. 340, c. 38 sq.), Petavius (Dogm. Theol. de Trin. I. c. 11
sq.), Scaliger (In Elencho Trihæresii, c. 27, and De emendatione temporum, Bk. VI. c. 1),
Mosheim (Ecclesiastical History, Murdock’s translation, I. p. 287 sq.), Montfaucon (Prælim.
in Comment. ad Psalm. c. VI.), and Tillemont (H. E. VII. p. 67 sq. 2d ed.).
On the other hand, as may be seen from the testimonies in Eusebius’ favor, quoted below
on p. 57 sq., many of the Fathers, who were themselves orthodox, looked upon Eusebius as
likewise sound on the subject of the Trinity. He has been defended in modern times against
21
The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of Eusebius.