APPENDIX.
Being a
letter
to the
author
, in answer to his request of information concerning the opinion of Protestant Divines and Churches in general, of the Presbyterians in Scotland and Dissenters in England in particular, respecting
five questions
that relate to this controversy.
rev. and dear sir,
If you look into Mr. Baxter’s controversial writings against Mr. Blake, you will meet with such accounts of principles and facts, as I think may reasonably give an inquirer much satisfaction as to the common judgment of protestant churches and divines in the points you mention. I particularly refer you to his five disputations
of Right to Sacraments, and the true Nature of Visible Christianity
; where all or the most of your
queries
are considered and
answered, with a multitude of
testimonies
produced in favour of sentiments contrary to those of your excellent predecessor, the late
Mr. Stoddard.
I have not said this from any disposition to excuse myself from the labour of making some further inquiry, if it be thought needful. And as it may show my willingness to gratify your desire, I will now say something on your
questions
distinctly, but with as much brevity as I can.
Quest. I.
What is the general opinion respecting that
self-examination
required in
1 Cor. xi. 28.
Whether communicants are not here directed to examine themselves concerning the
truth of grace,
or their real godliness
?
Answ. This construction of the text, as far as I have had opportunity to inquire, appears to me very generally received; if I may judge by what many celebrated
expositors
have said on the place, and by what many famous divines have written in treatises of
preparation
for the Lord’s supper, besides what is contained in public
confessions, catechisms, directories,
&c. I think Dr. Reynolds, in his
Meditations on the Lord’s Supper,
has
summarily expressed the common judgment of Calvinists in these strong lines of his: “The
sacrament
is but a
seal
of the
covenant
; and the covenant essentially includes
conditions
; and the condition on our part is
faith.
No faith, no
covenant
; no covenant, no
seal
; no seal, no
sacrament.
—The
matter
then of this
trial
(says he) must be that
vital qualification,
which predisposeth a man for
receiving of these holy mysteries; and that is
faith.
“
However, I may venture to be confident, that Mr. Stoddard’s gloss on the text, who tells us in his controverted
sermon,
“The meaning is, that a man must
come solemnly
to that ordinance,
examining what
need
he has of it,
“ is quite foreign from the current sense of Calvinist writers. And, though he makes a different comment in his
Appeal to the Learned,
saying, “The
examination
called for is, whether they
understood the
nature
of the ordinance, that so they may
solemnly consider what they have to do
when they wait upon God in it,” neither can I find any appearance of a general consent of the learned and orthodox to this
new gloss,
at least as exhibiting the full meaning of the text. I might easily confront it with numerous authorities: but the
Palatine Catechism,
and that of the
Westminster Assembly,
with the common explanations and catechizings upon them, may be appealed to as
instar omnium.
And I shall only add here, if it be allowed a just expectation that the
candidate
for the communion
examine himself
about the
same
things at least as the
pastor,
to whom he applies for admission, ought to make the subject of his examination, then it was worth while to hear the opinion of those unnamed
ministers in New England,
(among whom the late Dr. Colman, I have reason to think, was the principal,) that answered Dr. Mather’s
Order
of the Gospel,
(anno 1700,) who, in the
Postscript
to their
Review,
thus express themselves: ”
We highly approve
—that the proponant of the Lord’s table be
examined
of his baptismal vow;
his sense
of spiritual wants, sinfulness, and wretchedness;
his hope, faith, experiences,
resolutions through the grace of God.” This, I think, is something beyond Mr. Stoddard.
Quest. II.
Whether it be the general opinion of those aforesaid, that some who
know
themselves to be
unregenerate,
and under the reigning power of sin,
ought
notwithstanding,
in such a state, to come to the Lord’s table
?
Answ. I am aware, Sir, though you have seen fit to take no notice of it to me, that Mr. Stoddard (in his
Doctrine of Instituted Churches)
is peremptory in the
affirmative
; but I have met with no author among Calvinists, at home or abroad, consenting with him, unless it be Mr. Blake, and some that were for a promiscuous admission, with little or no limitation. If divines in general, of the Calvinistic character, were for such a latitude as Mr.
Stoddard’s, what can we suppose to be the reason, that in treating on the
Lord’s supper,
they so constantly consider it as one of the
rights of the church, belonging to the truly faithful alone, exclusively of all others
? Why do we hear them declaring,
It is certain that the right of external fellowship resides in the faithful only
:
and as to the rest, they are in that communion only by accident, and it is also only by accident that they are suffered there
;
but being what they are, they have not any part in the rights of that society properly belonging to them
? If they thought the sacrament instituted for
conversion,
why do we never find them recommending it as a
converting
ordinance, and urging persons to come to it with that view, who
know
themselves to be in an
unconverted state
? If they thought that any such have a
right before God,
and may come to it
with a good conscience,
why do we
find them so solemnly
warning
all that are truly
convinced
of their remaining yet in a
natural
state, to
refrain
coming to the Lord’s table in their unbelief and impenitence; as if they judged it a
sinful
and
dangerous
thing for them to come under such circumstances? I know Mr. Stoddard, in his
Appeal,
disputes the
fact.
But it has occurred to me in abundance of instances, while reviewing my authors on this occasion.
Among the foreign protestants in Germany, France, &c. I shall name but two out of many instances before me. The
Heidelberg
or
Palatine Catechism,
which had the solemn approbation of the synod of Dort, and was especially praised by the divines of Great Britain; which has been in a manner universally received and taught, formerly in Scotland, and still all over Holland, and by reason of its excellency has been translated into no less than
thirteen
several languages; this is most express in claiming the
Lord’s supper
for a special privilege of such as have
true faith
and
repentance
; and forbidding it to
hypocrites,
as well as scandalous persons, declaring that none such ought to come. See the
eighty-first
and other questions and answers, with Ursin’s Latin
Explications,
and De Witte’s English
Catechizings
thereon. Here, Sir, indeed you have the judgment of a multitude in one.
Another celebrated book is Claude’s
Historical Defence of the Reformation
; in which I meet with repeated declarations of the same sentiments, perfectly on the
negative
side of the question in hand, but, I think, too many and too long to be here transcribed.—The language of some of them I have just now had occasion to make use of.
As for the church of Scotland, I find they have adopted the Westminster Confession, Catechisms, and Directory, which debar all
ignorant
and
ungodly
persons from the Lord’s table, and require every one to
examine
himself, not only as to his knowledge, but also his
faith, repentance, love, new obedience,
&c.—In their
books of discipline,
I observe sundry passages that appropriate the sacrament to the
truly penitent and faithful,
as the only proper subjects. Their
national covenant,
renewed from time to time, has this clause; to the which [true reformed kirk] we join ourselves willingly, in doctrine, faith, religion, discipline, and use of the holy sacraments,
as lively members
of the same
in Christ
our Head, &c. And among the
divines
of Scotland, I find many in their sermons, sacramental speeches, and other discourses, declaring themselves strongly on the
negative
part in the
question before us, advising to strictness in admission to the Lord’s supper, renouncing the opinion of its being a
converting ordinance,
inviting only the sincere friends of Christ to it, and frequently
warning
professors conscious of reigning sin and hypocrisy to forbear approaching the Lord’s table. I might bring much to this purpose from Mr. Andrew Gray’s book of sermons, published anno 1716; and his sermons printed anno 1746; with a preface by Mr. Willison.—So from Mr.
Ebenezer Erskine’s synodical sermon, anno 1732.—And from Mr. Ralph Erskine’s sermon on
Isa. xlii. 6.
and his discourse on fencing the tables, annexed to his sermon on
John xvi. 15.
.—So from Mr. Willison’s synodical sermon, anno 1733; where he sets down a variety of searching questions (no less than twenty-seven) which he advises to be put to proponants, and their answers to be waited for, before they are admitted.—The anonymous author of
a Defence of
National Churches against the Independents,
(who is reputed to be Mr. Willison,) asserts it as a presbyterian principle, that none have
right before God
to the complete communion of the church, but such as have
grace
; and that none are to be admitted but those who are
saints,
at least in profession; such as profess to accept of the offers of Christ’s grace, &c. and confess themselves to be
sincere.
Mr. Aytone, in his
Review,
against Mr. Glas,
owns that the Lord’s supper is not a formal mean of
conversion,
but of further growth and nourishment to those
already
converted. In the same strain is Mr. Nasmith’s
Treatise of the Entail of the Covenant.
—And Mr. Warden’s
Essay on Baptism.
In a word, I find Mr. Currie (in his synodical sermon, anno 1732) testifying of the ministers in Scotland, that they are
tender (i. e.
circumspect and cautious)
in admitting people to the holy table of the Lord
;
knowing the
design
of the ordinance is
not conversion,
but
confirmation
; and he observes, that all who approve themselves to God here, will a thousand times rather choose to have, was it but
one table
or
half
a table of honest communicants,
true believers
and
real saints,
than have a
hundred
tables, by admitting any that are
unworthy,
(or
Christless
souls, as he anon characterizes them,) of whom there are not moral
evidences of their
fitness
for this holy ordinance. And for the commendable practice of the church of Scotland, in being
pointed
and
particular
in
debarring
the unworthy from this ordinance, (says he,) God forbid ever it turn into desuetude. I think I may here not unfitly subjoin those remarkable passages in Mr. Anderson’s excellent
Defence of the Presbyterians,
against Mr. Rhind; where he informs us,
they look upon this holy ordinance as the common
privilege of the faithful
; and therefore they usually fence the Lord’s table, in the words of Scripture,
1 Cor. vi. 9.
or some such-like. To exclude the
impenitent
from the
privilege
of gospel-mysteries; to debar those from the
Lord’s table,
whom the Lord has, by the express sentence of his word, debarred out of the
kingdom of heaven,
is what every one, who is not quite lost in impiety, must own to be not only
lawful,
but a
duty.
Upon which I beg leave to observe, according to this principle I do not see but that a man who with apparent signs of credibility
confesses
himself habitually impenitent, ought to be debarred from the Lord’s table: and surely, by parity of reason, he that
knows
himself to be unregenerate, ought to
refrain
coming, since there can be no true repentance without regeneration. I think we have no just grounds to suppose Mr. Stoddard’s principle in this matter has
hitherto any general prevalence in the church of Scotland.
And now to pass over to England, neither do I find reason to think the
dissenters
there in general are for Mr. Stoddard’s latitude. The
Assembly of Divines
pronounce all the
ungodly,
as well as ignorant,
unworthy
of the Lord’s table; direct to
preparation
for it, by examining ourselves of our
being in Christ,
&c. And though they declare this sacrament appointed for the relief even of the
weak
and
doubting
Christian, who
unfeignedly,
desires to be
found in Christ
; and having directed
such
a one to bewail his unbelief and labour to have his doubts resolved, they assert that
so doing
he may and ought to come to the Lord’s supper, to be
further strengthened
: yet I do not find any appearance of a hint, as if others who
know
themselves to be in a natural state, or are conscious of their being certainly graceless, may and ought to come to this
ordinance, that they may be
converted.
Nay, they expressly declare of all
ungodly
persons, that while they remain such, they
cannot
without great sin against Christ partake of those holy mysteries.—As to particular divines, I find multitudes of them among the dissenters, in later as well as former times, expressing the same sentiments: distinguishing between natural and instituted duties, between initial
and confirming means, between special ordinances and
common: and declaring the Lord’s supper a
disciple-privilege,
peculiar to such as have
disciple-properties,
and admonishing as well the
close hypocrite,
as the more gross, of the
sin and danger
of coming to it in his unregenerate state, impenitent and unbelieving. Thus Mr. Bolton, in his discourse on
the Wedding Supper and the Wedding Garment,
warns the
graceless
not to come to the Lord’s supper; affirming, that an
unsanctified presence
will be
found as bad as a
profane absence.
—Mr. Baxter, in his
Five Disputations,
has much that runs in the same strain; so in his
Reformed Liturgy,
and in his
Christian Concord,
where we have his brethren joining their testimony with his. Likewise Mr. Charnock, in his discourse of
the Subjects of the Lord’s Supper
—Mr. Palmer, in his
Scripture—Rail to the Lord’s Table
—Mr. Saunders, in his
Anti—Diatribe
—Mr. Langley, in his
Suspension Reviewed
—Mr.
Doolittle, Mr. Henry, Dr. Earle, and others, in their books on the
Lord’s Supper
—Mr. Shower, in his
Sacramental Discourses
—Mr. Flavel, in his sermon on
Gospel—Unity,
and other pieces—Mr. Philip Henry, and Mr. Trosse, in the accounts of their
Live
s—Dr. Calamy, in his discourse on
Vows,
and his
Defence of Nonconformity
—Mr. Simon Browne, in the Continuation of
Henry’s Exposition,
on
1 Cor. xi. 28.
—Dr. Harris, in his
discourse on
Self—Dedication
—Dr. Jennings, in his sermons to
Young People
.—I could, from all these authors, cite passages much to the purpose: but it would be too tedious. Yet I will give you a few hints from some others.—Dr. Williams, in his
Gospel—Truth Stated,
says, Though a man had it revealed to him that he is one of the
elect,
yet so long as he remains
unregenerate,
he has no right to partake of the Lord’s supper.—Dr. Guyse, in his late sermon at Mr.
Gibbons’s ordination, observes, that men being
church-members
supposes them
already
to have a
good work begun
in them, and to be partakers of christian
love,
even such as proceeds from
faith,
in a prevailing degree; and persons (says he) that have nothing of this,
ought not
to be church-members.—Mr. Hall, in his
Exhortation
on the same occasion, remarks, that the seals of the covenant are to be used as
discriminating
signs of the real
separation of true believers from the world; and urges to have the fence kept up, which Christ has set about his church, that it may appear to be a body wholly
distinct
from the world: God’s house being erected for the entertainment, not of
hypocrites
and dead sinners, but of the living in Jerusalem.—But says Dr. Watts, in his
Humble Attempt,
it is true, this cannot be practised universally and perfectly here on earth, so as to prevent some
secret
sinners making
their way into our separate congregations, and joining with us in the most solemn ordinances; yet he declares such
not really worthy
of any room or place in the house of God.—And in his
Holiness of Times, Places, and People,
the Doctor observes, The
visible
christian church is founded on a
supposition,
that the members of it are, or should appear to be, members of the
invisible
: and
none
(says he) are to be admitted into the
visible
church, or esteemed complete members of it, but those who make such a declaration and profession of their faith in Christ and their avowed subjection to him, as may be supposed in a judgment of charity to manifest them to be real believers, true subjects of his spiritual kingdom, and members of the
invisible
church.—I find Dr. Doddridge in the same sentiments, by what he says in his
Family Expositor.
Thus, on the case of Ananias and Sapphira, he has this note, The
church
is never
happier,
than when the
sons of falsehood
are
deterred
from intruding into it: if its
members
are
less numerous,
it is a sufficient balance, that it is
more pure.
And on Simon’s case, he pronounces it to be
in vain
for men to
profess
themselves
Christians,
in vain to submit to
baptism,
&c. if their
heart
be not
right with God.
And
such persons
being admitted to
distinguishing
ordinances, he calls an evil, in the present state of things unavoidable; wishing for the
happy medium,
between
prostituting divine ordinances
by a foolish credulity, and
defrauding the children of the household of their bread,
by a rigorous severity and mistaken caution. He every where represents the Lord’s supper as the sacrament of
nutrition,
a reviving and nourishing ordinance; but never that I can find, as a
regenerating
or
converting
one. Upon
the case of Judas, the Doctor observes, that if he had truly stated the order of the story, then Judas certainly
went out
before the
Eucharist
was instituted: and indeed one cannot reasonably suppose, Christ would have commanded him to
drink of this cup
as the
blood shed for
him
for the remission of sins,
when he had just before been declaring in effect, that
his
sins should
never
be forgiven.—By which observation, I think, Dr. Doddridge has
quite demolished one of the most plausible pleas in favour of the secret and conscious hypocrite’s claim to the Lord’s supper.
In fine, even those who appear advocates for a latitude in admissions to the communion, I observe, generally in the course of the argument offer such
distinctions,
or make such
concessions,
as seem by fair consequence a giving up of the point, at least as stated in the present question. For they usually distinguish between a right
in foro Dei
and
in foro ecclesiæ
; accordingly treat these as two different questions,
Who ought to
come
? and,
Who ought to be admitted
? considering the latter as an
ecclesiastical
case, and here they assert a
latitude
; but the former, as a case of
conscience,
of private reference only, and here they grant a
limitation.
How large soever their principles, while taking the case in its
ecclesiastical
view, yet I have met with very few divines, that taking it as a
private case of conscience,
have gone Mr. Stoddard’s length,
in asserting, that
some unsanctified men have right before God to the Lord’s supper,
and
may come with a good conscience,
yea,
ought to come,
notwithstanding they
know
themselves at the same time to be in a
natural
condition. This he declares in his
Doctrine of Instituted Churches,
and confirms in his
Sermon and Appeal.
But then he has made some
concessions,
which seem to be subversive of his opinion. For he expressly allows, that the
sacrament
by institution supposes communicants to be
visible saints
; and this title of
visible saints
he assigns to “such as have a visible union to Christ, such as are in the judgment of rational charity believers, such as carry themselves so that there is reason to look upon them to be saints.” Now, taking the case as a
private case of conscience,
(in which light only Mr. Stoddard professes to have designed to consider it in his sermon, and not at all
as an
ecclesiastical
case,) I think, this
visibility of saintship
immediately respects the
proponant
for the Lord’s table, and must be referred to his own
private judgment
of himself. But then, how can there be a
visibility of saintship
in the eve of the man’s own conscience, when at the same time he
knows
himself to be in a
natural
condition? Or how can a man come to the Lord’s table with a good
conscience,
as having
right before God,
while he cannot form so much as a judgment of
rational charity
for himself; seeing he carries so, in the view of his own
conscience,
that he has no
reason
to look on himself to be a
saint,
nay, even
knows
he is still in a natural state, and therefore in the eye of his own impartial judgment is not such a one as the
sacrament
by institution
supposes
the communicant to be? Moreover, Mr. Stoddard, in describing visible saints, inserts into their
character
a serious profession of the true religion,
which he sometimes calls
a profession of faith and repentance, morally sincere
: and in his
Doctrine of Instituted Churches,
(p. 19.) he lays down a remarkable
position,
in these words, such a profession as being sincere makes a man a real saint, being morally sincere makes a man a visible saint. Now according to this, it seems to me, the
profession
itself, whether evangelically or morally sincere, is
always of a
uniform tenor
; having one and the same thing for the
matter
of it; and not respecting, in the different cases, a religion
specifically
different, or a faith and repentance of a higher and a lower
kind.
But then it is quite beyond me to comprehend, how a man who
knows
himself to be in a
natural
condition, can be so much as
morally
sincere in his
profession,
while it is in its matter and tenor
such a profession as being
(evangelically)
sincere makes a man a real saint.
For if he
knows
himself to be in a
natural
condition, he then as certainly
knows
he hath not (in the principle or exercise) that
faith and repentance,
which is the just matter of
such a profession
: and how therefore can he be reasonably supposed, with any degree of
moral sincerity,
to make
such a profession,
when for the matter of it, it is the very
same
profession he
would make, if he
knew
himself to be a
real saint
? Can a person in any sound gospel sense profess
himself a
saint
or
believing penitent,
and herein
speak the truth
with a common
moral honesty,
while yet he
knows
himself to be destitute of all such
characters
in the sight of God and conscience, being still in a
natural
condition, and under the dominion of
unbelief
and
impenitence
? For my own
part, I must confess this a difficulty in Mr. Stoddard’s scheme, that I am not capable of solving. His favourite hypothesis, I think, must fall, if his
position
stands, and his
concessions
be abode by; which serve clearly to determine the present
question
in the
negative,
agreeable to the general sense of protestant churches and divines.
Quest. III.
Whether it be not the general opinion, that persons admitted to the Lord’s table ought to
profess saving faith and repentance;
meaning that faith and repentance, which are the terms of the
covenant of grace?
Answ. I believe, after what has been already offered, we need be at no loss to know the mind of the generality respecting the subject of this inquiry. Were there occasion for it, I could easily produce a
cloud of witnesses,
to evidence that the general opinion is on the
affirmative
side, in this question. Repeated searches have been made by diligent and impartial inquirers, who though of varying judgment and practice in church-discipline, yet agree in their
reports: and from them I will give you the following attestations.
Mr. Lob (in his
True Dissenter)
tells us, It is the judgment of all the
Nonconformists,
that nothing less than the
profession
of
saving faith,
credibly significant of the thing professed, gives right to church-communion. And this he declares to be the rule of
all protestants
in general. He brings even Mr. Humphrey (though opposite in judgment) for his voucher: who acknowledges, that the
visible church
is defined by a
profession
of true regenerate faith, and of no less than that, according to the most
general
opinion of
protestant divines.
He speaks of it as the
common opinion,
that a profession of no less than true grace or justifying faith is the
rule of admission
to the church-sacraments. And though Mr. Humphrey went off from the received opinion, yet could he not come into Mr. Blake’s notions in this matter, who also had gone off from it, nor hope for their vindication:
hence he makes that challenge,
What man is there, that dares revive Mr. Blake’s cause, and defend it against Mr. Barter’s
right
to sacraments
?
Mr. Baxter in this his book very copiously argues a
profession
of
saving faith,
as the rule of admission to the sacraments, and much insists on its being so by the unanimous consent of judicious divines. He tells us, Mr. Gataker in his books has largely proved this by a multitude of quotations from protestant writers. And he adds his own testimony, repeatedly saying, It is indeed their
most common
doctrine—It is the
common protestant
doctrine.
And again, Certain I am, this is the
common
doctrine of reformed divines. He subjoins, I must profess, that I do not know of
any one protestant
divine, reputed orthodox, of the contrary judgment, before Dr. Ward and Mr. Blake, though some papists and Arminians I knew of that mind. And again, (beside Sir Henry Vane,) he says,
All
that I know of, since Dr. Ward, is Mr. Blake, Mr. Humphrey, and one John Timson; and John Timson, Mr. Humphrey, and Mr. Blake. He alleges Mr.
Vines, as thus witnessing in the case on his side. To this purpose
all our learned divines
have given their suffrage: I need not authors or churches. It is so plain a case, that I wonder those [of the contrary opinion] have not taken notice of it,
there is an army to a man against them.
Mr. Langley, in his
Suspension Reviewed,
observes, The
concurrent judgment
of divines, English and foreign, episcopal and presbyterian, that a man of vast and digested reading, the learned Mr. Baxter, hath demonstrated at large in sixty
testimonies
; sundry of which have
many
in them, being the judgment of many
churches
and many
learned
men therein; and more might easily be brought. In short, he calls it the
old
protestant
doctrine asserted against the
papists
; and wonders at the confidence of the men, who tell us, against our own eyes, that it is a
novelism.
To these attestations I subjoin that of our Mr. Mitchel, (in his introduction before the
Defence of the Synod,
1662,) who while asserting a different latitude of the two sacraments, yet pleads for strictness in admissions to the Lord’s table; and testifies, It is most evident, that
godly reforming divines
have in their doctrine
unanimously
taught, and in their practice (many of them) endeavoured, a
strict selection
of those who should be
admitted to the
Lord’s supper.
I think it may he not improperly observed here, that in a manuscript, drawn up by this eminent person for his own satisfaction, and inserted in the account of his life, he has left his solemn testimony against a lax
mode
of
profession,
(exclusive of all examinations and confessions, of a practical and experimental nature,) as having been found by plentiful experience a
nurse
of
formality
and
irreligion.
At the same time
declaring his judgment, with a particular eye to the churches of
New England,
that the
power of godliness
will be
lost,
if only
doctrinal
knowledge and
outward
behaviour come to be accounted sufficient for a title to all church-privileges; and the use of
practical confessions
and
examinations
of men’s
spiritual
estate be laid aside. For (says he) that which people see to be publicly required and held in reputation,
that
will they
look after, and usually
no more.
In another place he observes, this will not only lose the power of godliness, but in a little time bring in
profaneness
and
ruin the churches,
these two ways. (1.)
Election of ministers
will soon be carried by a formal looser sort. (2.) The exercise of
discipline
will by this means be impossible.—And discipline failing, profaneness riseth like a flood. Agreeably he says elsewhere; Certain it is, that we stand for the
purity
of the churches, when we stand for
such qualifications
as we do, in those whom we would admit to
full communion
; and do withstand those notions and reasonings that would infer a
laxness
therein, which hath apparent
peril
in it. In sum, (says he,) we make account that we shall be near about the
middle-way
of church reformation, if we keep
baptism
within the compass of the
non-excommunicable,
and the
Lord’s supper
within the
compass of those that have (unto charity) somewhat of the
power
of godliness, or grace in
exercise.
For Mr. Mitchel, as he thought faith
in the special and lively
exercise
thereof
necessary to a safe and comfortable participation of the Lord’s
supper,
so he judged an
appearance
of this unto rational charity, judging by
positive sensible
signs and evidences, justly required in order to admission into
full communion.
Whereas, he thought
baptism
annexed to
initial
faith, or faith in the
being
of it; the charitable judgment whereof (says he) runs upon a great
latitude
; and he conceived the same
strictness,
as to outward signs, not necessary unto a charitable probable judgment, or hope of the
being
of faith, which entitles to baptism, as of that
growth
and
special exercise
of faith, which is requisite to the Lord’s supper. These are the main
distinctions,
on
which he grounded his opinion of a
different
latitude of the two sacraments. For I must observe, as strenuously as he pleads for a various extent, as to the subjects of them, he never supposes any adult regularly admittable to either sacrament, but such as in ecclesiastical reputation sustain the character of
believers
; such as in the account of a rational charity (judging by probable signs) have the being of
regeneration
; or as he variously expresses it, have
true faith,
in the judgment of charity; and do in
some measure
perform the duties of faith and obedience, as to
church-visibility
and
charitable hope
; and therefore are such as the church ought to receive and hold as
heirs of the grace of life,
according to the rules of christian charity. Though it seems Mr. Shepard before him speaks of his
church charity
and
experimental charity
; so Mr. Mitchel had his
positive
charity and
his
negative,
and conducted his judgment and administrations accordingly, in admitting persons to the one sacrament or the other. I should not have been so prolix and particular here, but that I thought it might serve to prepare the way for a more easy, short, and intelligible answer to your remaining queries.
Quest. IV.
Whether it be the general opinion of protestant churches and divines, in the case of
adult
persons, that the terms of admission to
both
sacraments are the
same?
ANSW. I presume, Sir, the question does not respect a sameness in the
degree
of qualifications, experiences, and
evidences; but only a sameness in
kind,
or for the substance and general nature of things. I suppose, you had no view here to any such critical
distinction
as that before mentioned, between an
initial
faith and a
grown
faith; or between the simple
being
of faith, which entitleth to baptism, and the
special exercise
of faith, which fits for the Lord’s supper; nor aim at a nice adjustment of the several
characters of visibility,
or
motives of credibility,
in the one case and the other, but only intend in general to inquire, whether persons admittable to one or other sacrament, ought to profess
true justifying faith,
and not be admitted on the profession of any faith of a kind
inferior
and
specifically
different. Now, taking this to be the scope of
your question, I have good reason to apprehend, that the
generality
of protestant churches and divines, of the Calvinistic persuasion especially, have declared themselves for the
affirmative.
I think all that hold the
visible
christian church ought to consist of such as make a
visible and credible profession of faith and holiness,
and
appear to rational charity real members of the church invisible,
(which is the common language of protestants,) are to be understood as in principle exploding the conceit of a conscious unbeliever’s right before God to special church-ordinances, and as denying the apparent unbeliever’s right before the
church to admission, whether to one sacrament or the other. I observe,
Eadem est ratio utriusque sacramenti,
is a maxim (in its general notion) espoused by the several contending parties in this controversy about a right to sacraments.
That a credible profession of saving faith and repentance is necessary to
baptism,
in the case of the adult, I can show, by the authority of Claude’s approved
Defence
of
the Reformation,
to be the general opinion of French protestants; and by the Palatine Catechism, by the Leyden Professors’
Synopsis,
&c. to be the prevailing judgment of the reformed in Germany, Holland, and foreign parts.
And for the
Dissenters in England,
that they are in general of the same judgment, I might prove from the
Assembly of Divines’
Confession, Catechisms, and Directory; and from the Heads of Agreement assented to by the
United Ministers,
formerly distinguished by the names of
Presbyterian
and
Congregational
; as also by a large induction of particular instances among divines of every denomination, would it not carry me to too great a
length. I find Mr. Lob (in his
True Dissenter)
assuring us in general, “It is held by the dissenters, that nothing less than the
profession of a saving faith
gives a right to
baptism.
“ Nor do I see, by their writings of a later date and most in vogue, any just grounds to suppose a general change of sentiments among them. I will mention two or three moderns of distinguished name. Dr. Harris (in his
Self-Dedication)
tells us, The nature of the Lord’s supper
plainly supposes
faith
; and that none but
real
Christians have right in the sight of God; though a credible
profession
entitles to it in the sight of the church, who cannot know the heart. And he declares it the
same faith,
which qualifies the adult, both for
baptism
and for the
Lord’s supper
; there being the same common nature to both sacraments, and the latter only a
recognising
the former. The late Dr. Watts (in his
Holiness
of Times, Places, and People)
says, The christian church receives none but upon profession of
true
faith in Christ, and
sincere
repentance; none but those who profess to be members of the
invisible
church, and in a judgment of charity are to be so esteemed. Our
entrance
into it is appointed to be by a visible
profession
of our being
born of God,
of real faith in Christ, of true repentance, and inward holiness. In fine, to name no more, Dr. Doddridge
(in his
Family Expositor,
on
Acts viii. 37.
.) supposes a credible
profession
of their
faith in Christ
required of the adult in apostolic times, in order to their being admitted to
baptism
; even such (says he) as implied their cordially subjecting their souls to the gospel, and their being come to a point, so as to give up themselves to Christ
with all their heart.
And for the church of Scotland, Mr. Anderson, who well understood their principles and practice, assures us, (in his
Defence
of them,) that
presbyterians
will not baptize without a previous profession or sponsor. To the adult (says he) it is not only necessary (as it is also in infants) that they be
internally sanctified,
but also that they make an
outward profession,
of which baptism is the badge and token. To justify this, he observes
concerning the
catechumens
in primitive times, that during all that state they were probationers, not only as to their knowledge, but piety; and were obliged, before they could be admitted to
baptism,
to give moral evidences of the
grace of God in their hearts.
And he advances it as a
presbyterian
principle, that
faith
and
repentance
are
prerequired
to baptism, in adult persons at least. By this he points out the true
matter
of baptismal
profession: and then in opposition to such as pretend baptism to be a
converting
ordinance, he observes, If they can have
faith
and
repentance
without the
Spirit
and spiritual
regeneration,
which they say is not obtained but
in
and
by baptism,
I do not see why they may not go to
heaven
without the Spirit and spiritual regeneration: for I am sure,
repentance
toward God and
faith
toward our Lord Jesus Christ, is the sum of the
gospel.—Mr. Warden, another of their noted writers, (in his
Essay on Baptism,)
says in the name of
presbyterians,
We think that baptism
supposeth
men
Christians
; else they have
no right
to baptism, the seal of Christianity; all seals, in their nature, supposing the
thing
that is sealed. He that is of adult age, is to
profess
his
faith
in Christ, and his
compliance
with the whole device of salvation,
before
he can have
the seal of the covenant administered to him. The author of the
Defence of National Churches,
(thought to be Mr. Willison,) says, I know nothing more requisite to admission to the Lord’s supper,
in foro ecclesiastico,
than unto baptism in an adult person; they being both seals of the same covenant. And he thinks the objects of church-fellowship are “all who profess to accept the offers of Christ’s grace, with subjection to his ordinances, and a suitable walk, and who confess
themselves sincere.”
I have reserved Mr. Baxter for my last witness, because his attestation is comprehensive and of a general aspect. In his
Disputations of Right to Sacraments,
and other writings, he repeatedly declares, “It hath been the constant principle and practice of the
universal
church of Christ, to require a
profession
of saving
faith
and
repentance,
as necessary before they would
baptize
; and not to baptize any upon the profession
of any
lower
kind of faith. He must shut his eyes against the fullest evidence of history and church-practice, who will deny this. I desire those otherwise—minded to help me to an instance of any
one
approved baptism, since Christ’s time or his apostles, upon the account of a
faith
that was
short
of
justifying,
and not upon the profession of a justifying faith. Hitherto this is not done by them, but the contrary is fully done by others, and yet they
confidently except against my opinion as a
novelty.
Mr. Gataker’s books have multitudes of sentences recited out of our
protestant
divines, that affirm this which they call
new.
It is indeed the common
protestant
doctrine, that the sacraments do
presuppose
remission of sins, and our faith; that they are instituted to signify these
as in being
; and do solemnize and publicly own and confirm the mutual covenant
already
entered in heart. The
Jesuits themselves do witness this to be the ordinary
protestant
doctrine.—It seems not necessary to mention the judgment of our reformed divines, as expressed in any of their particular sayings, when their public confessions and practices are so satisfactory herein.” Mr. Baxter, however, recites a multitude of their testimonies; producing the judgment of Luther, Calvin, Beza, Pet. Martyr, Piscator, Melancthon, Altingius, Junius, Polanus, Zanchius, Ursinus, Paræus, Bucanus, Musculus,
Professores Leyd. et Salm. Wollebius, Vossius, Wendeline, Keckerman, Bullinger, Alsted, Deodate, Dr. Ames, Dr. Moulin; The Catechism of the Church of England, and English Divines; Bp. Usher, Dr. Willet, Dr. Fulk, Dr. Prideaux, Dr. Whitaker, Mr. Yates, Perkins, Cartwright, &c.; The Scottish Church in their Heads of Church-policy, and Divines of Scotland; Mr. Gillespie, Mr. Rutherford, and Mr. Wood; The Westminster Assembly of Divines, their Confession, Catechisms, and Directory; The Annot of
some of those Divines, &c. And for the
reformed
churches in general (Mr. Baxter observes) it is past all question, by their constant
practice,
that they require the profession of a
saving
christian faith, and take not up with any
lower.
And respecting the then practice in England, he says, This is manifest by our daily administration of baptism. I never heard (says he) any man baptize an infant but upon the parent’s, or susceptor’s, or offerer’s
profession
of a
justifying faith.
This leads to your last inquiry.
Quest. V.
Whether it be the general opinion, that the
same qualifications
are required in a
parent
bringing his child to baptism, as in an
adult
person for his own admission to this ordinance
?
ANSW. Here, Sir, I suppose you intend only the same qualifications in
kind
; or a profession and visibility, in some degree, of the
same sort
of faith and repentance; meaning that which is truly evangelical and saving. And understanding you in this sense, I am persuaded, by all I can observe, that the generality of protestants are in the
affirmative
; not assenting to a specific and essential difference, whatever circumstantial and
gradual disparity they may allow, between the two cases you mention.
Mr. Baxter, speaking of the judgment and practice of the christian
fathers,
tells us, that faith (justifying faith, and not another kind of faith) was supposed to be in the parent, for himself and his seed: because the condition or qualification of the infant is but this, that he be the
seed
of a
believer.
And he thinks the generality of the
reformed
are in these sentiments. He declares his own judgment in full concurrence herewith, and backs
the same with a variety of arguments, in his
Five Disputations,
and other writings. He observes, it seems strange to him that any should imagine, a
lower
belief in the parent will help his
child
to a title to baptism, than that which is necessary to
his own,
if he were unbaptized; because mutual consent is necessary to mutual covenant, and the covenant
must
be mutual. No man hath right to God’s part, that refuseth his own: they that have no right to remission
of sins, have no right given them by God to baptism. If God be not at all actually obliged in covenant to any
ungodly
man, then he is not obliged to give him baptism: but God is not obliged so to him.
Most of our divines
make the contrary doctrine Pelagianism, that God should be obliged to man in a state of nature in such a covenant. If the parent’s title be questionable, (says he,) the infant’s is so too; because the ground is the same: and it is from the parent that the child
must derive it; nor can any man give that which he hath not. We ought not (says he) to baptize those persons, or their children, as theirs, who are visible members of the kingdom of the devil, or that do not so much as profess their forsaking the devil’s kingdom: but such are all that profess not a saving faith. If such are not visibly
in
the kingdom of the devil, at least they are not visibly
out
of it. All that are duly baptized, are baptized
into
Christ; therefore they
are supposed to possess that
faith
by which men are united or ingrafted into Christ: but that is only justifying faith. Tell me (says he) where any man was ever said in Scripture to be united to Christ, without saving faith, or profession of it. In a word, Mr. Baxter takes occasion to declare himself in this manner: If Mr. Blake exacts not a profession of
saving
faith and repentance, I say he makes
foul work
in the church. And when such
foul work
shall be voluntarily
maintained,
and the word of God abused for the
defilement
of the church and ordinances of God, it is a greater scandal to the
weak,
and to the
schismatics,
and a greater reproach to the church, and a sadder case to considerate men, than the too common pollutions of others, which are merely through
negligence,
but not justified and defended.
We are told by other impartial inquirers, that
all the reformed
do in their directories and practices require
professions,
as well as promises, of
parents
bringing their children to baptism; even professions of present faith and repentance, as well as promises of future obedience; and these not merely of the moral, but the evangelical kind. The judgment of the church of Scotland may be known by their adopting the Confession, Catechisms, and Directory
of the
Assembly of Divines
; who, when they require a
parental profession,
(as in their
Catechisms,
&c.) intend it not of any
lower
kind, than a true gospel faith and obedience. The mind of the
dissenters
may be very much judged of by the
reformed liturgy,
presented in their name upon King Charles’s restoration; where parents’
credible profession
of their faith, repentance, and obedience, is required in order to the baptism of their
children. I might bring further evidence from the writings of particular divines among them, ancient and modern; but I must for brevity omit this. Only I will give you a specimen in two or three hints. Mr. Charnock, that great divine, observes, “Baptism
supposes
faith in the adult, and the profession of faith in the parent for his child.” The late eminent Dr. Watts, in his
Holiness of Times, Places, and People,
thus declares himself, with respect to the
infants of true
believers
: “In my opinion, so far as they are any way members of the
visible
christian church, it is upon
supposition
of their being (with their
parents)
members of the
invisible
church of God.”
On the whole, as to our fathers here in New England, it is true, they asserted a
baptism-right
in parents for themselves and children, whom yet they excluded from full communion; the ground of which difference was hinted before: and they denied a
parity of reason
between the
two cases
now in view, on some accounts. Their chief ground was, that
adult baptism
requires a measure of visible
moral fitness
or inherent holiness in the
recipient; whereas,
infant baptism
requires nothing visible in its subject, but a
relative fitness
or federal holiness, the
formalis ratio
of infant membership, accruing from God’s charter of grace to his church, taking in the infant seed with the believing parent. Baptism they supposed to run parallel with regular membership; and the child of such a parent entitled to this covenant-seal in its own right, on the foot of a distinct personal membership, derivative in point of
being,
but independent for its
duration,
and for the
privileges
annexed to it by divine institution. However, they certainly owned
parental profession,
as belonging to the due order and just manner of administration, both
meet
and
needful.
Accordingly they provided, that
parents
claiming covenant-privileges for their children, should own their covenant-state, have a measure of covenant-qualifications, and do covenant-duties, in some degree, to
the satisfaction of a rational charity. And it ought to be remembered, they have left it as their solemn judgment, that even taking
baptism-right
for a right of
fitness in foro ecclesiastico,
still the parents whose children they claimed
baptism
for, were such as must be allowed to have a title to it for
themselves,
in case they had remained unbaptized: looking upon them, although not duly fitted for the sacrament of communion and confirmation, yet sufficiently so
for the sacrament of union and initiation; professors in their infancy
parentally,
and now
personally,
in an initial way; appearing Abraham’s children, in some measure of
truth,
to a judicious charity; justly therefore baptizable, in their persons and offspring, by all the rules of the gospel. I am not here to argue upon the justness of this scheme of thought on the case; but only to represent the fact in a genuine light.
I have no room, Sir, for any further remarks. But must conclude, with christian salutes, and the tender of every brotherly office, from
Your very affectionate Friend
and humble Servant,
THOMAS FOXCROFT.
Boston,
June 26, 1749.