MEMORIALS OF TWO SISTERS [1862-67
a house here for about two months. It is only in such
great suffering that one learns to know all the comfort that
faith can give, and this she feels most thoroughly.
CATHERINE to Miss ANNETTE KNIGHT
HIGH CLEEVE, WESTON-SUPER-MARE,
April zjth, 1866.
I used to like writing letters years ago, and could write
some that were worth reading in a moderate way. But
of late I have got into the way of making only diaries or
bulletins of them, to save myself trouble ; so now my
epistles have a certain small value for my friends' hearts,
but none for their heads, and I always feel a little ashamed
of them, especially when I havejust read one of yours !
I saw that Review of " Ecce Homo " in the Quarterly.
It is extremely adverse and very unfair, in a way that
one could not explain without going through each detail
of criticism. I remember well the passage to which your
brother referred ; it is not shocking at all, but very fine, I
think. Only one thing in " EcceHomo " shocksmy feelings
that the writer thinks our Lord's prayer for forgiveness
on his enemies did not include the Jews. I think Bishop
Ellicott's Review in The Churchman much superior, though
also adverse. But the two seem to forget what "Ecce
Homo
" claims to be not the work of a Christian, fully
believing all the faith and announcing his conclusions on
points of doctrine, but merely the honest investigation of
a man who does not know what to believe about Christ,
and takes nothing for granted. It is a very imperfect work,
because it deals with only half of our Lord's work His
moral teachings and the polity He founded ; not with His
revelations of God and the relations of man to God and to
Himself. I think myself that this is a fundamental defect
in method, because Christ Himself so entirely grounds the
former half of His work on the latter ; you cannot separate
them without a certain arbitrariness of selection among His
sayings and doings. But I can conceive a state of mind in