26. In this question, however, of fasting or not fasting on the seventh day, nothing appears
to me more safe and conducive to peace than the apostle’s rule: “Let not him that eateth
despise him that eateth not, and let not him which eateth not judge him that eateth:”1579
“for neither if we eat are we the better, neither if we eat not are we the worse;”1580 our fel-
lowship with those among whom we live, and along with whom we live in God, being pre-
served undisturbed by these things. For as it is true that, in the words of the apostles, “it is
evil for that man who eateth with offence,”1581 it is equally true that it is evil for that man
who fasteth with offence. Let us not therefore be like those who, seeing John the Baptist
neither eating nor drinking, said, “He hath a devil;” but let us equally avoid imitating those
who said, when they saw Christ eating and drinking, “Behold a man gluttonous, and a
winebibber, a friend of publicans and sinners.”1582 After mentioning these sayings, the Lord
subjoined a most important truth in the words, “But Wisdom is justified of her children;”
and if you ask who these are, read what is written, “The sons of Wisdom are the congregation
of the righteous:”1583 they are they who, when they eat, do not despise others who do not
eat; and when they eat not, do not judge those who eat, but who do despise and judge those
who, with offence, either eat or abstain from eating.
Chap. XII.
27. As to the seventh day of the week there is less difficulty in acting on the rule above
quoted, because both the Roman Church and some other churches, though few, near to it
or remote from it, observe a fast on that day; but to fast on the Lord’s day is a great offence,
especially since the rise of that detestable heresy of the Manichæans, so manifestly and
grievously contradicting the Catholic faith and the divine Scriptures: for the Manichæans
have prescribed to their followers the obligation of fasting upon that day; whence it has
resulted that the fast upon the Lord’s day is regarded with the greater abhorrence. Unless,
perchance, some one be able to continue an unbroken fast for more than a week, so as to
approach as nearly as may be to the fast of forty days, as we have known some do; and we
have even been assured by brethren most worthy of credit, that one person did attain to the
full period of forty days. For as, in the time of the Old Testament fathers, Moses and Elijah
did not do anything against liberty of eating on the seventh day of the week, when they fasted
forty days; so the man who has been able to go beyond seven days in fasting has not chosen
the Lord’s day as a day of fasting, but has only come upon it in course among the days for
which, so far as he might be able, he had vowed to prolong his fast. If, however, a continuous
1579 Rom. xiv. 3.
1580 1 Cor. viii. 8.
1581 Rom. xiv. 20.
1582 Matt. xi. 19.
1583 Ecclus. iii. 1.
613
To Casulanus