doubtless, the death threatened in case of disobedience, which stands in direct opposition
to this, was an exposure to everlasting wickedness and misery, in separation from God, and
in enduring his wrath.
When God first made mankind, and made known to them the methods of his moral
government towards them, in the revelation he made of himself to the natural head of the
whole species—and letting him know, that obedience to him was expected, and enforcing
his duty with the sanction of a threatened punishment, called by the name of death—we
may with the greatest reason suppose, in such a case, that by death was meant the most
proper punishment of the sin of mankind, and which he speaks of under that name
throughout the Scripture, as the proper wages of sin; and this was always, from the beginning,
understood to be so in the church of God. It would be strange indeed, if it should be other-
wise. It would have been strange, if, when the law of God was first given, and enforced by
the threatening of a punishment, nothing at all had been mentioned of that great punishment,
ever spoken of under the name of death—in the revelations which he has given to mankind
from age to age—as the proper punishment of the sin of mankind. And it would be no less
strange, if when the punishment which was mentioned and threatened on that occasion,
was called by the same name, even death, yet we must not understand it to mean the same
thing, but something infinitely diverse, and infinitely more inconsiderable.
But now let us consider what that death is, which the Scripture ever speaks of as the
proper wages of sin, and is spoken of as such by God’s saints in all ages of the church. I will
begin with the New Testament. When the apostle Paul says, (Rom. vi. 23.) “The wages of
sin is death,“ Dr. T. tells us, (p. 120. S.) that this means eternal death, the second death, a
death widely different from the death we now die. The same apostle speaks of death as the
proper punishment due for sin, Rom. vii. 5. and Rom. viii. 13. 2 Cor. iii. 7. 1 Cor. xv. 56. In
all which places, Dr. T. himself supposes the apostle to intend eternal death. 36 And when
the apostle James speaks of death, as the proper reward, fruit, and end of sin, (James i. 15.)
“Sin, when it is finished, bringeth forth death;” it is manifest, that our author supposes
eternal destruction to be meant. 37 And the apostle John, agreeably to Dr. T.‘s sense, speaks
of the second death as that which sin unrepented of will bring all men to at last. Rev. ii. 11.
Rev. xx. 6, 14. Rev. xxi. 8. In the same sense the apostle John uses the word in his first epistle,
1 John iii. 14. “We know that we have passed from death to life, because we love the brethren.
He that hateth his brother, abideth in death.” In the same manner Christ used the word
from time to time, when he was on earth, and spake concerning the punishment of sin. John
v. 24. “He that heareth my word, and believeth, &c. hath everlasting life; and shall not come
36 See p. 78, note on Rom. vii. 5. and note on Rom. vii. 6. Note on Rom. vii. 8
37 By comparing what he says, p. 126, with what he often says of that death and destruction which is the de-
merit and end of personal sin, which he says is the second death or eternal destruction.
1032
SECTION II. Death threatened to our first parents.