CHAP. II.
THE EVIDENCE OF THE DOCTRINE OF ORIGINAL SIN FROM WHAT THE SCRIPTURE TEACHES OF THE APPLICATION OF REDEMPTION.
The truth of the doctrine of original sin is very clearly manifest from what the Scripture says of that
change of state,
which it represents as necessary to an actual interest in the spiritual and eternal blessings of the Redeemer’s kingdom.
In order to this, it speaks of it as absolutely necessary for every one, that he be regenerated, or
born again
.
John iii. 3.
“Verily, verily, I say unto thee, except a man (
NOT ENGLISH
) be begotten again, or born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God.” Dr. T. though he will not allow that this signifies any change from a state of
natural propensity
to sin, yet supposes that the new birth here spoken of, means a man’s
being brought to
a divine life, in a right use and application of the natural powers, in a life of true holiness
:
354
and that it is the attainment of
those habits of virtue and religion, which gives us the real character of true Christians, and the children of God
;‡
and that it is
putting on the new nature of right action
.
355
But in order to proceed in the most sure and safe manner, in understanding what is meant in Scripture by
being born again,
and so in the inferences we draw from what is said of the necessity of it, let us compare scripture with scripture, and consider what
other
terms or phrases are used, where respect is evidently had to the same change. And here I would observe the following things.
I. If we compare one scripture with another, it will be sufficiently manifest, that by regeneration, or being
begotten,
or
born again,
the same change in the state of the mind is signified with that which the scripture speaks of as affected in true repentance and conversion. I put repentance and conversion together, because the scripture puts them together,
Acts iii. 19.
and because they plainly signify much the same thing. The word
(
NOT ENGLISH
)
repentance,
signifies a
change of the mind
; as the word
conversion,
means a
change
or
turning
from sin to God. And that this is the same change with that which is called
regeneration
(excepting that this latter term especially signifies the change, as the mind is
passive
in it) the following things may show.
In the
change
which the mind undergoes in
repentance
and
conversion,
is attained that
character
of true Christians which is necessary to the eternal privileges of such.
Acts iii. 19.
”
Repent
ye therefore, and be
converted,
that your sins may be blotted out, when the times of refreshing shall come from the presence of the Lord.” And thus it is in
regeneration
; as is evident from what Christ
says to Nicodemus, and as is allowed by Dr. T.
The
change
of the mind in
repentance
is that in which
saving faith
is attained.
Mark i. 15.
“The kingdom of God is at hand,
repent
ye, and
believe
the gospel.” And so it is in being born
again,
or born of
God
; as appears by
John i. 12, 13.
“But as many as received him, to them he gave power to become the sons of God, even to them that
believe
on his name, which were
born
not of blood, &c. but
of God.
“ Just as Christ says concerning
conversion,
Matt. xviii. 3.
“Verily, verily, I say unto you, except ye be
converted,
and become as little children, ye shall not enter the kingdom of heaven:” so does he say concerning being
born again,
in what he spake to
Nicodemus.
By the change men undergo in
conversion,
they become
as little children
; which appears in the place last cited: and so they do by
regeneration.
(
1 Pet. i. 23.
and
ii. 2.
) “Being born again.—Wherefore as new-born babes, desire,” &c. It is no objection, that the disciples, to whom Christ spake in
Matt. xviii. 3.
were converted already: this makes it not
less proper for Christ to declare the necessity of conversion to them, leaving it with them to try themselves, and to make sure their conversion: in like manner as he declared to them the necessity of
repentance
, in
Luke xiii. 3, 5.
“Except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish.”
The change effected by
repentance,
is expressed and exhibited by
baptism.
Hence it is called the
baptism of repentance.
(
Matt. iii. 11.
Luke iii. 3.
Acts xiii. 24.
and
xix. 4
) And so is
regeneration,
or being born again, expressed by
baptism
; as is evident by such representations of regeneration as those:
John
iii. 5.
“Except a man be born of water, and of the Spirit.”—
Tit. iii. 5.
“He saved us by the washing of regeneration.”—Many other things might be observed, to show that the change men pass under in their
repentance
and
conversion,
is the
same
with that of which they are the subjects in regeneration.—But these observations may be sufficient.
II. The change which a man undergoes when born again, and in his repentance and conversion, is the same that the scripture calls the circumcision of the heart.—This may easily appear by considering, that as
regeneration
is that in which are attained the habits of true
virtue
and
holiness,
as has been shown, and as is confessed; so is
circumcision of heart
.
Deut. xxx. 6.
“And the Lord thy God will
circumcise thine
heart,
and the
heart
of thy seed, to love the Lord thy God with all thine heart, and with all thy soul.”
Regeneration
is that whereby men come to have the character of
true Christians
; as is evident, and as is confessed; and so is
circumcision of heart
: for by this men become
Jews inwardly,
or
Jews
in the spiritual and
christian sense,
(and that is the same as being
true Christians,)
as of old,
proselytes
were made
Jews
by circumcision of the flesh.
Rom. ii. 28, 29.
“For he
is not a
Jew
which is one outwardly; neither is that
circumcision
which is outward in the flesh: but he is a
Jew,
which is one inwardly; and
circumcision
is that
of the heart,
in the spirit and not in the letter, whose praise is not of men, but of God.”
That
circumcision of the heart,
is the same with
conversion,
or
turning
from sin to God, is evident by
Jer. iv. 1-4.
“If thou wilt
return,
O Israel,
return unto me. Circumcise
yourselves to the Lord, and put away the foreskins o
f your heart
“ And
Deut. x. 16.
”
Circumcise
therefore the foreskin of your
heart,
and be no more stiff-necked.”
Circumcision of the heart
is
the same change of the heart that men experience in
repentance
; as is evident by
Lev. xxvi. 41.
“If their
uncircumcised hearts
be humbled, and they accept the punishment of their iniquity.”
The change effected in
regeneration, repentance,
and
conversion,
is signified by
baptism,
as has been shown; and so is
circumcision of the heart
signified by the same thing. None will deny, that it was this internal circumcision, which of old was signified by external circumcision; nor will any deny, now under the New Testament, that inward and spiritual baptism, or the cleansing of the heart, is signified by external washing or baptism. But
spiritual circumcision and spiritual baptism are the same thing; both being
putting off the body of the sins of the flesh
; as is very plain by
Colos. ii. 11-13.
“In whom also ye are circumcised, with the
circumcision
made without hands, in putting off the body of the sins of the flesh, by the circumcision of Christ, buried with him in
baptism,
wherein also ye are risen with him,” &c.
III. This inward change, called
regeneration,
and
circumcision of the heart,
which is wrought in
repentance
and
conversion,
is the same with that spiritual resurrection so often spoken of, and represented as
a dying unto sin, and a living unto righteousness.—
This appears with great plainness
in that last cited place,
Col. ii.
) “In whom also ye are circumcised, with the
circumcision made without hands,—buried with him in baptism, wherein also ye are
risen with him,
through the faith of the operation of God, &c. And you, being dead in your sins, and the uncircumcision of your flesh, hath he
quickened together with him
; having forgiven you all trespasses.”
The same appears by
Rom. vi. 3-5.
“Know ye not, that so many of us as were baptized into Jesus Christ, were baptized into his death? Therefore we are buried with him by baptism into death; that like as Christ was
raised up from the dead,
by the glory of the Father, even so we also should walk in newness of life,” &c.
ver. 11.
“Likewise reckon ye also yourselves to be dead unto sin, but
alive unto God,
through Jesus Christ our Lord.” In which place also it is evident, and by the whole context, that this spiritual
resurrection
is that change, in which persons are brought to habits of holiness and to the divine life, by which Dr. T. describes the thing obtained in being
born again.
That a
spiritual resurrection
to a new, divine life, should be called a being
born again,
is agreeable to the language of Scripture. So those words in the
2nd Psalm
“Thou art my Son, this day have I begotten thee,” are applied to Christ’s
resurrection
,
Acts xiii. 33.
So in
Colos. i. 18.
Christ is called the
first
born
from
the dead
; and in
Rev. i. 5.
The first
begotten
of the dead.
The saints, in their
conversion or spiritual resurrection, are risen with Christ, and are begotten and born with him
.
1 Pet. i. 3.
“Who hath
begotten us again
to a lively hope, by the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead, to an inheritance incorruptible.” This inheritance is the same thing with that kingdom of heaven, which men obtain by being
born again,
according to
Christ’s words to
Nicodemus
; and that same
inheritance of them that are sanctified,
spoken of as what is obtained in true conversion.
Acts xxvi. 18.
“To turn them (or convert them) from darkness to light, and from the power of Satan unto God, that they may receive forgiveness of sin, and inheritance among them that are sanctified, through faith that is in me.” Dr. T’s own words, in his note on
Rom. i. 4.
speaking of that place in
the
2d Psalm
, are very worthy to be here recited. He observes how this is applied to Christ’s
resurrection
and exaltation, in the New Testament, and then has this remark, “note, begetting is conferring a new and happy state: a son is a person put into it. Agreeably to this, good men are said to be the sons of God, as they are the sons of the
resurrection to eternal life,
which is represented as a
NOT ENGLISH
,
a being
begotten, or born again, regenerated.” So that I think it is abundantly plain, that the
spiritual resurrection
spoken of in Scripture, by which the saints are brought to a new divine life, is the same with that being
born again,
which Christ says is
necessary
for every one, in order to his seeing the kingdom of God.
IV. This change, of which men are the subjects, when they are
born again, and circumcised in heart,
when they
repent,
and are
converted,
and spiritually
raised from the dead,
is the same change which is meant when the Scripture speaks of making the heart and spirit new, or giving a
new heart and spirit.
It is almost needless to observe, how evidently this is spoken of as
necessary
to salvation, and as the change in which are attained the habits of true virtue and holiness, and the character of a true saint; as has been observed of
regeneration, conversion
, &c. and how apparent it is, that the change is the
same.
Thus repentance, (
NOT ENGLISH
)
the change of the mind,
is the same as being changed to a new mind, or a new
heart and spirit.
Conversion
is the turning of the heart; which is the same thing as changing it so, that there shall be another heart, or a
new heart,
or a new spirit. To be
born again,
is to be born
anew
; which implies a becoming new, and is represented as becoming
new-born babes.
But none supposes it is the
body,
that is immediately and properly new, but the
mind, heart,
or
spirit.
And so a
spiritual resurrection
is
the resurrection of the spirit, or rising to begin a new existence and life, as to the
mind, heart,
or
spirit.
So that all these phrases imply, having a
new heart,
and being
renewed in the spirit,
according to their plain signification.
When
Nicodemus
expressed his wonder at Christ declaring it necessary, that a man should be
born again
in order to see the kingdom of God, or enjoy the privileges of the kingdom of the Messiah, Christ says to him,
Art thou a master of Israel, and knowest not these things
?
i. e.
“Art thou one who is set to teach others the things written in the law and the prophets, and knowest not a doctrine so plainly taught in your Scriptures, that such a
change is necessary to a partaking of the blessings of the Messiah’s kingdom?” But what can Christ refer to, unless such prophecies as that in
Ezek. xxxvi. 25-27.
? Where God, by the prophet, speaking of the days of the Messiah’s kingdom, says, “Then will I sprinkle clean water upon you, and ye shall be clean.—A
new heart
also will I give you, and a
new spirit
will I put within you—and I will put my Spirit within you.”
356
Here God speaks of having a
new heart and spirit,
by being
washed with water,
and receiving
the Spirit of God,
as the qualification of God’s people, that shall enjoy the privileges of the Messiah’s kingdom. How much is this like the doctrine of Christ to
Nicodemus,
of being
born again of water, and of the Spirit
! We have another like prophecy in
Ezek. xi. 19.
—Add to this, that regeneration, or a
being born again,
and the
renewing
(or making new) by the Holy Ghost, are spoken of as the same thing,
Tit. iii. 5.
“By the washing of
regeneration
and
renewing
of the Holy Ghost.”
V. It is abundantly manifest, that being
born again,
spiritually
rising from the dead to newness of life,
receiving a
new heart,
and being
renewed in the spirit of the mind,
are the same thing with that which is called
putting off the
old man,
and putting on the
new man.
The expressions are equivalent; and the representations are plainly of the same thing. When Christ speaks of being
born again,
two births are supposed: a
first and a second, an
old
birth and a
new
one
: and the thing born is called
man.
So what is born in the first birth is the
old man
; and what is brought forth in the
second birth,
is the
new man.
That which is born in the first birth (says Christ) is
flesh
: it is the
carnal man,
wherein we have borne the image of the
earthly Adam,
whom the apostle calls the
first man.
That which is born in the new birth, is
spirit,
or the spiritual and heavenly man: wherein we proceed from Christ the
second man,
the
new man,
who is made a quickening Spirit, and is the Lord from heaven, and the Head of the
new creation.—
In the new birth, men are represented as becoming
new-born babes,
which is the same thing as becoming
new men.
And how apparently is what the Scripture says of the spiritual
resurrection
of the Christian convert, equivalent and of the very same import with putting off the
old man,
and putting on the
new man.
So in
Rom. vi.
the convert is represented as
dying,
and being
buried with Christ
; which is explained in the
6th verse,
by this, that
the old man is crucified, that the
body of sin might be destroyed,
And in the
4th verse,
converts in this change are spoken of as
rising to newness of life.
Are not these things plain enough? The apostle in effect tells us, that when he speaks of spiritual death and resurrection, he means the same thing as
crucifying and burying the old man,
and rising as a
new man.
And it is most apparent, that spiritual
circumcision,
and spiritual
baptism,
and the spiritual
resurrection,
are all the same with
putting off the old man, and putting on the new man.
This appears by
Colos. ii. 11, 12.
“In whom also ye are circumcised with the circumcision made without hands,
in putting off
the body of the sins of the flesh, by the circumcision of Christ, buried with him in
baptism
;
wherein also ye are risen with him.” Here it is manifest, that the spiritual circumcision, baptism, and resurrection, all signify that change wherein men
put off the body of the sins of the flesh
: but that is the same thing, in this apostle’s language,
as putting off the old man
; as appears by
Rom. vi. 6.
“Our old man is crucified, that the body of sin may be destroyed.” And that putting off the
old man
is the same with putting
off the
body of sin,
appears further by
Ephes. iv. 22-24.
and
Colos. iii. 8-10.
As Dr. T. confesses, “that to be
born again,
is that wherein are obtained the habits of virtue, religion, and true holiness;” so how evidently is the same thing predicated of that change, which is called
putting off the old man, and putting on the new man
!
Eph. iv. 22-24.
“That ye put off the old man
,
which is corrupt, &c.
and put on the new man, which after God is created in righteousness and true holiness.”
And it is most plain, that this putting off the old man, &c. is the very same thing with making the
heart and spirit
n
e
w. It is apparent in itself; the spirit is called
the
man
, in the language of the apostle; it is called the
inward man
, and the
hidden man.
(
Rom. vii. 22.
2 Cor. iv. 16.
1 Pet. iii. 4.
) And therefore, putting off the o
ld man
, is the same
thing with the removal of the
old hea
rt; and the putting on of the n
ew man
, is the receiving of
a new heart, and a new
s
pi
r
i
t. Yea, putting on the
new man
is expressly spoken of as the same thing with receiving a
new spirit, or being renewed in spirit
,
Eph. iv. 22-24.
“That ye put off the old man—and be renewed in the spirit of your mind, and that ye put on the new man.”
From these things it appears, how unreasonable, and contrary to the utmost degree of scriptural evidence, is Dr. T.‘s way of explaining the
old man
, and the
new man
,
357
as though thereby was meant nothing
personal
; but that by the
old
ma
n was meant the
heathen state,
and by the
new man the christian dispensation,
or state of professing Christians, or the whole
collective body of professors of
Christianity, made up of
Jews
and
Gentiles
; when all the colour he has for it is, that the apostle once calls the christian church a
new man.
(
Eph. ii. 15.
) It is
very true, in the Scriptures often, both in the Old Testament and the New,
collective bodies,
nations, peoples
,
and cities, are figuratively represented by
persons
: particularly the
church
of Christ is represented as
one
holy person
,
and has the same appellatives as a particular saint or believer; and so is called a c
hild, a
s
on of
G
o
d, (
Exod. iv. 22.
Gal. iv. 1, 2.
)
a
servant
of God,
(
Isa. xli. 8, 9.
and
xliv. 1
)
The daughter of God, and spouse of Christ,
(
Psal. xlv. 10, 13, 14.
Rev. xix. 7.
) Nevertheless
,
would it be reasonable to argue, that such appellations, as a
servant of God, child of God,
&c. are
always
or
commonly
to be taken as signifying only the
church
of God in general, or great
collective bodies; and not to be understood in a
personal
sense? But certainly this would not be more unreasonable than to urge, that by the
old
and the
new man
, as the phrases are mostly used in Scripture, is to be understood nothing but the great collective bodies of pagans and of Christians, or the heathen and the christian world, as to their
outward
profession, and the dispensation they are under. It might have been proper, in this case, to have considered the
unreasonableness of that practice which our author charges on others, and finds so much fault with in them,
358
“That they content themselves with a
few scraps
of Scripture, which though wrong understood, they make the test of truth, and the ground of their principles, in contradiction to the
whole
tenor of revelation.
VI. I observe once more, it is very apparent, that
bein
g
born again,
and
spiritually raised
from death to a state of new existence and life, having a
new
hea
rt
created in us, being renewed in the spirit of our mind,
and being the subjects of that change by which we
put off the old man, and put on the new man,
is the same thing with that which in Scripture is called
being
created anew, or made new creatures.
Here, to pass over many other evidences which might be mentioned, I would only observe, that the representations are exactly equivalent. These several phrases naturally and most plainly signify the same effect. In the first
birth,
or generation, we are
created,
or brought into existence; it is then the
whole man
first
receives being
; the soul is then
formed,
and then our bodies
are fearfully and wonderfully made, being
curiously wrought by our Creator.
So that a new-born child is a
new creature.
So, when a man is
born again
,
he is created again
; in that
new birth,
there is a
new
creation
; and therein he becomes as a
new-born
babe
, or a new creature. So, in a
resurrection,
there is a
new creation.
When a man is
dead,
that which was made in the first creation is destroyed: when that which was dead is
raised
to
life, the mighty power of the author of life is exerted the second time, and the subject restored to a new existence, and a new life, as by a
new creation.
So giving a new heart is called creating
a clean heart
,
Psal. li. 10.
where the word, translated
create,
is the same that is used in the first verse, in
Genesis
. And when we read in Scripture of the
new creature,
the creature that is called new is man; and therefore the phrase,
n
e
w
man,
is evidently equipollent with
new creature
; and putting off the
old man,
and putting on the
new man,
is spoken of expressly as brought to pass by a work of
creation
.
Col. iii. 9, 10.
“Ye have put off the old man—and have put on the new man, which is renewed in knowledge, after the image of him that
created
him.” So
Eph. iv. 22-24.
“That ye put off the old man, which is corrupt, &c. and
be renewed in the spirit of your mind, and that ye put on the new man, which after God is
created
in righteousness and true holiness.” These things absolutely fix the meaning of
2 Cor. v. 17.
“If any man be in Christ, he is a
new
creature
: old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new.”
On the whole, the following reflections may be made:
1. That it is a truth of the utmost certainty
,
with respect to
every
man born of the race of Adam
,
by ordinary generation
, that unless he be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of
God.
This is true, not only of the heathen, but of them that are born of the professing people of God, as
Nicodemus,
and the
Jews,
and every man
born of the flesh.
This is most manifest by Christ’s discourse in
John iii.
3-11.
So it is plain by
2 Cor. v. 17.
That every man who is in Christ, is a
new creature.
2. It appears from this, together with what has been proved above, that it is most certain with respect to
every
one of the human race, that he can never have any interest in Christ, or see the kingdom of God, unless he be the subject of that change in the temper and disposition of his heart, which is made in
repentance and conversion, circumcision of heart, spiritual baptism, dying to sin, and
rising to a new and holy life
; and unless he
has the
old heart taken away, and a new heart and spirit given, and puts off the old man, and puts on the new man, and old things are passed away, and all things made new.
3. From what is plainly implied in these things, and from what the Scripture most clearly teaches of the nature of them, it is certain, that
every
man is
born
into the world in a state of
moral pollution.
For spiritual baptism is a cleansing from moral filthiness. (
Ezek. xxxvi. 25.
compared with
Acts ii. 16.
and
John iii. 5.
) So the washing of regeneration, or the NEW BIRTH, is a change
from a state of wickedness. (
Tit. iii. 3-5.
) Men are spoken of as purified in their regeneration. (
1 Pet. i. 22, 23.
See also
1 John ii. 29.
and
iii. 1,3.
) And it appears, that every man in his first or natural state is a
sinner
; for otherwise he would then need no repentance, no conversion, no turning from sin to God. And it appears, that every man in his original state
has a
heart of stone
; for thus the Scripture calls that
old h
e
art
, which is taken away, when a new heart and new spirit is given. (
Ezek. xi.19.
and
xxxvi. 26.
) And it appears, that man’s nature, as in his native state, is
corrupt according to the deceitful lusts,
and of its own motion exerts itself in nothing but
wicked deeds.
For thus the Scripture characterizes the old man, which is put
off, when men are renewed in the spirit of their minds, and put on the new man. (
Eph. iv. 22-24.
Col. iii. 8-10.
) In a word, it appears, that man’s nature, as in its native state, is a
body of sin,
which must
be destroyed,
must
die
,
be buried, and never rise more.
For thus the old man is represented, which is
crucified,
when men are the subjects of a spiritual resurrection.
Rom. vi. 4-6.
Such a
nature, such a body of sin as this, is put off in the spiritual renovation, wherein we put on the NEW MAN, and are the subjects of the spiritual circumcision.
Eph. iv. 21-23.
It must now be left with the reader to judge for himself, whether what the Scripture teaches of the application of Christ’s redemption, and the
change
of state and nature necessary to true and final happiness, does not afford clear and abundant evidence to the truth of the doctrine of
original sin.
354
Page 144.
355
Page 251.
356
Ezek. xxxvi. 25, 26.
357
Page 149-153. S.
358
Page 224.