Chapter 32.—72. Petilianus said: "For although there is only one baptism, yet it is
548
consecrated in three several grades. John gave water without the name of the Trinity, as he
declared himself, saying, ‘I indeed baptize you with water unto repentance: but He that
cometh after me is mightier than I, whose shoes I am not worthy to bear; He shall baptize
you with the Holy Ghost, and with fire.’2070 Christ gave the Holy Spirit, as it is written, ‘He
breathed on them, and saith unto them, Receive ye the Holy Ghost,’2071 And the Comforter
Himself came on the apostles as a fire burning with rustling flames. O true divinity, which
seemed to blaze, not to burn! as it is written, ‘And suddenly there came a sound from
heaven as of a rushing mighty wind, and it filled all the house where the apostles were sitting.
And there appeared unto them cloven tongues, like as of fire, and it sat upon each of them.
And they were all filled with the Holy Ghost, and began to speak with other tongues, as the
Spirit gave them utterance.’2072 But you, O persecutor, have not even the water of repentance,
seeing that you hold the power not of the murdered John, but of the murderer Herod. You
therefore, O traditor, have not the Holy Spirit of Christ; for Christ did not betray others to
death, but was Himself betrayed. For you, therefore, the fire in the spirit in Hades is full of
life,—that fire which, surging with hungry tongues of flame, will be able to burn your limbs
to all eternity without consuming them, as it is written of the punishment of the guilty in
hell, ‘Neither shall their fire be quenched.’"2073
73. Augustin answered: You are the calumnious slanderer, not the truthful arguer.
Will you not at length cease to make assertions of a kind which, if you do not prove them,
can apply to nobody; and even if you prove them, certainly cannot apply to the unity of the
whole world, which is in the saints as in the wheat of God? If we too were pleased to return
calumnies for calumnies, we too might possibly be able to give vent to eloquent slanderers.
We too might use the expression, "With rustling flames;" but to me an expression never
sounds in any way eloquent which is inappropriate in its use. We too might say, "Surging
with hungry tongues of flame;" but we do not wish that the tongues of flame in our writings,
when they are read by any one in his senses, should be judged hungry for want of the sap
of weightiness, or that the reader himself, while he finds in them no food of useful sentiments,
should be left to suffer from the hunger of excessive emptiness. See, I declare that your
Circumcelliones are burning, not with rustling but with headlong flames. If you answer,
What is that to us? why do not you, when you reproach with any one whom you will, not
listen in turn to our answer, We too know nothing of it? If you answer, You do not prove
the fact, why may not the whole world answer you in turn, Neither do you prove it? Let us
2070 Matt. iii. 11.
2071 John xx. 22.
2072 Acts ii. 2-4.
2073 Isa. lxvi. 24.
Chapter 32
1058
Chapter 32