8 GOSPEL ACCORDING TO CHAP. I.
saying,thattherewas a time when He was not. Where
then was the Word ? Illimitablethingsare not contained
in space. Where was He then? With God. For neither
is the Father bounded by place,nor the Son by aught
Orig. circumscribing.ORIGEN. It isworth whilenoting,that,
in°Joan!°whereasthe Word issaidto come i [be made] to some,as
c.'• to Hosea,Isaiah,Jeremiah,with God it is not made, as
Vuig.""1thoughitwere notwithHim before.But,theWord having
cameE.T.oeen alwayswith Him, itissaid,and the Word was with
God: forfrom the beginningitwas not separatefrom the
Chrj-s.Father. CHRYS. He hasnot said,was inGod, but was withHom.ni.GQiJ. exhibitingtous thateternitywhichHe had in accord-
Theoph.ancewithHis Person. THEOPHYL. Sabellinsisoverthrowninloco.by tliistext_ For he assertsthattheFather,Son,and Holy
Ghost are one Person,Who sometimes appearedas the
Father,sometimesastheSon,sometimesastheHoly Ghost.
But he ismanifestlyconfoundedby thistext,and the Word
was withGod ; forheretheEvangelistdeclaresthattheSon
isone Person,God the Fatheranother.
And theWord was God.
Hilsr.ii. HILARY. Thou wiltsay,thata word isthe soundof the
deTrin.voice,theenunciationofa thing,theexpressionofa thought:
thisWord was in the beginningwith God, becausethe
utteranceof thoughtiseternal,when He who thinkethis
eternal.But how was thatin the beginning,which exists
no timeeitherbefore,or after,I doubtevenwhetherin time
atall? For speechisneitherinexistencebeforeone speaks,
nor after;in the veryact of speakingitvanishes;forby
thetime a speechisended,thatfrom which itbegan does
not exist.But even ifthe firstsentence,in thebeginning
was theWord, was throughthy inattentionlostupon thee,
why disputestthouaboutthe next; and theWord teaswith
God? Didst thou hear it said,"In God," so that thou
shouldestunderstandthisWord to be only the expression
ofhiddenthoughts?Or didJohn say withby mistake,and
was not awareofthedistinctionbetweenbeinginand being
with,when he said,thatwhat was in thebeginning,was not
in God, butwithGod? Hear then the natureand name of