16. Yet one cannot discover by any rational process of reasoning, what is the meaning
of these statements. If the gods willed that the Alemanni3267 and the Persians should be
overcome because Christians dwelt among their tribes, how did they grant victory to the
Romans when Christians dwelt among their peoples also? If they willed that mice and locusts
should swarm forth in prodigious numbers in Asia and in Syria because Christians dwelt
among their tribes too, why was there at the same time no such phenomenon in Spain and
in Gaul, although innumerable Christians lived in those provinces also?3268 If among the
Gætuli and the Tinguitani3269 they sent dryness and aridity on the crops on account of this
circumstance, why did they in that very year give the most bountiful harvest to the Moors
and to the Nomads, when a similar religion had its abode in these regions as well? If in any
one state whatever they have caused many to die with hunger, through disgust at our name,
why have they in the same state made wealthier, ay, very rich, by the high price of corn, not
only men not of our body, but even Christians themselves? Accordingly, either all should
have had no blessing if we are the cause of the evils, for we are in all nations; or when you
see blessings mixed with misfortunes, cease to attribute to us that which damages your in-
terests, when we in no respect interfere with your blessings and prosperity. For if I cause it
to be ill with you, why do I not prevent it from being well with you? If my name is the cause
of a great dearth, why am I powerless to prevent the greatest productiveness? If I am said
to bring the ill luck of a wound being received in war, why, when the enemy are slain, am I
not an evil augury; and why am I not set forth against good hopes, through the ill luck of a
bad omen?
3267 Alemanni, i.e., the Germans; hence the French Allemagne. The ms. has Alamanni.
3268 [“Innumerable Christians:” let this be noted.]
3269 The Gætuli and Tinguitani were African tribes. For Tinguitanos, another reading is tunc Aquitanos; but
Tinguitanos is much to be preferred on every ground.
Chapter XVI.
933
Chapter XVI.