in no other sense than as holding forth a federal holiness.”—So that by this, they expressed
no hopes concerning any thing more than their federal holiness, as distinguished from real.
And he argues earnestly, through the two next pages, that they could not be looked upon,
many of them, as having real holiness. How does this consist with their being treated as
visible saints; under the notion of their having real holiness, and from respect to such a
character appearing on them? or with none being visible saints, but such as have a credible
visibility of gospel-holiness?
So in p. 63. b. he speaks of the gross scandals of many of those to whom the apostles
wrote, as an absolute proof, that they considered them only as federally holy; which he in
the same place distinguishes from real holiness. Then how were they treated (as he insists)
as those that had the character of real piety appearing on them, and as making a credible
profession of gospel-holiness, and real Christianity? Which, he abundantly allows, all must
make in order to being visible saints. See also p. 64. e.
In p. 58. Mr. W. insists, that it does not appear, that those who were admitted into the
primitive church, made a declaration that they had saving faith, but only that they engaged
to that faith.—But how does this consist with what he abundantly says elsewhere, that they
must pretend to real piety, make a profession of gospel-holiness, exhibit moral evidence,
that they have such holiness, &c.? These things are something else besides engaging to saving
faith and gospel-holiness for the future.
1999
SECTION IX. Mr. W. is inconsistent with himself.