87
least to have exacted from the criminal even this legally established garb of repentance which
you ought to have learned from him? as to have uttered no commination on the past? no
allocution touching the future? Nay, more; he goes further, and beseeches that they “would
confirm toward him affection,” as if he were making satisfaction to him, not as if he were
granting an indulgence! And yet I hear (him speak of) “affection,” not “communion;” as
(he writes) withal to the Thessalonians: “But if any obey not our word through the epistle,
him mark; and associate not with him, that he may feel awed; not regarding (him) as an
enemy, but rebuking as a brother.” 829 Accordingly, he could have said that to a fornicator,
too, “affection” only was conceded, not “communion” as well; to an incestuous man, however,
not even “affection;” whom he would, to be sure, have bidden to be banished from their
midst 830—much more, of course, from their mind. “But he was apprehensive lest they
should be ‘overreached by Satan’ with regard to the loss of that person whom himself had
cast forth to Satan; or else lest, ‘by abundance of mourning, he should be devoured’ whom
he had sentenced to ‘destruction of the flesh.’” Here they go so far as to interpret “destruction
of the flesh” of the office of repentance; in that by fasts, and squalor, and every species of
neglect and studious ill-treatment devoted to the extermination of the flesh, it seems to
make satisfaction to God; so that they argue that that fornicator—that incestuous person
rather—having been delivered by the apostle to Satan, not with a view to “perdition,” but
with a view to “emendation,” on the hypothesis that subsequently he would, on account of
the “destruction” (that is, the general affliction) “of the flesh,” attain pardon, therefore did
actually attain it. Plainly, the selfsame apostle delivered to Satan Hymenæus and Alexander,
“that they might be emended into not blaspheming,” 831 as he writes to his Timotheus.
“But withal himself says that ‘a stake 832 was given him, an angel of Satan,’ by which he was
to be buffeted, lest he should exalt himself.” If they touch upon this (instance) withal, in
order to lead us to understand that such as were “delivered to Satan” by him (were so de-
livered) with a view to emendation, not to perdition; what similarity is there between blas-
phemy and incest, and a soul entirely free from these,—nay, rather elated from no other
source than the highest sanctity and all innocence; which (elation of soul) was being re-
strained in the apostle by “buffets,” if you will, by means (as they say) of pain in the ear or
head? Incest, however, and blasphemy, deserved to have delivered the entire persons of
men to Satan himself for a possession, not to “an angel” of his. And (there is yet another
point): for about this it makes a difference, nay, rather withal in regard to this it is of the
utmost consequence, that we find those men delivered by the apostle to Satan, but to the
829 2 Thess. iii. 14, 15.
830 Comp. 1 Cor. v. 2.
831 1 Tim. i. 20.
832 2 Cor. xii. 7–10.
197
Of St. Paul, and the Person Whom He Urges the Corinthians to Forgive.