condemned because it has been abused. You do not condemn military armament for your
country because others have taken up arms against the country; the physician does not refuse
to use all drugs because some are baneful; because there are sophists one is not to deny the
value of eloquence. Cresconius seemed to regard its cultivation as injurious to the simplicity
of Christian law and teaching. He also had accused Augustin of persistent arrogance in his
pertinacious pursuit of the Donatists. Augustin claims to do a good work with good ends
in view, and says its fruit has been a rich harvest for the Church. So the discussion passes
386
on to the use of dialectics, which Cresconius assails, but Augustin defends as nothing else
than a demonstration of results, either the true from the true or the false from the false. He
justifies not disputatiousness, but the arguments by which truth is built up, for Christ em-
ployed it, and St. Paul wielded its weapons not only with the Jews but with Epicureans and
Stoics. In all this we have an illustration of that unfortunate tendency to undervalue culture
whenever a puristic community passes into the fires. Augustin applies the art to one of the
points which Cresconius had discussed, viz., rebaptism. He had endeavored to prove that
it was solely among them. Augustin concedes that the rite is there, but not its profit; in order
to enjoy its profit, it must be administered lawfully. The oneness of baptism as a ceremony
is not dependent on the oneness of the Church, whereas its profit is. A reprobate society
of heretics can have a good baptism, but it is not properly and not profitably administered
among them; the proper and profitable administration is solely in the Church to salvation;
the rite outside is to judgment.
In Book II. after a résumé of the previous book, he notices first the criticism as to the
true construction of the name Donatistœ; it should rather be Donatiani as Cresconius
claimed. He is ready to concede this, and in his controversy with the philologist will use
that form, but on all other occasion he would prefer the more familiar termination.
Cresconius also protests against the term heretic as applied to them, which he regards as a
divergence of views from the Christian faith; while a schism has sprung up among those for
whom the same Christ was born, died and rose again, who have one religion, the same sac-
raments, and no diversity in Christian observance. Augustin, however, while not particularly
dwelling on these agreements, presses upon him the articles of divergence, and asks why
they rebaptize? The recognition of Donatist ordination concerning which Cresconius had
asked, Augustin declares to be a matter of charity. As to the question of Cresconius, Why,
if the Donatists are such heretics and so sacrilegious, if they are indeed guilty of a nefarious
and inexpiable crime, some purification is not adopted when they come over to the Catholic
church? Augustin answers: We do not regard it as inexpiable, and baptism is not to be re-
peated, it is Christ’s; on coming to us the Donatist receives the Spirit signified by that rite;
he begins to have healthfully what he previously had hurtfully and unworthily. The relation
of the celebrant to the symbol as presented by Cresconius is a modification of Petilianism.
"Regard is had," says he, "to the conscience of the giver, not according to its actuality, which
665
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.