return to Him with whom it has not formerly been? By this one word alone are the supporters
of this one of the four opinions embarrassed. And yet I do not think that this opinion ought
to be held as refuted by this one word, for it may be possible to show that in the ordinary
style of scriptural language it may be quite correct to use the word “return,” as signifying
the spirit created by God returns to Him not because of its having been with Him before its
union with the body, but because of its having received being from His creative power.
11. I have written these things in order to show that whoever is disposed to maintain
and vindicate any one of these four theories of the soul’s origin, must bring forward, either
from the Scriptures received into ecclesiastical authority, passages which do not admit of
any other interpretation,—as the statement that God made man,—or reasonings founded
on premises so obviously true that to call them in question would be madness, such as the
494
statement that none but the living are capable of knowledge or of error; for a statement like
this does not require the authority of Scripture to prove its truth, as if the common sense
of mankind did not of itself announce its truth with such transparent cogency of reason,
that whoever contradicts it must be held to be hopelessly mad. If any one is able to produce
such arguments in discussing the very obscure question of the soul’s origin, let him help
me in my ignorance; but if he cannot do this, let him forbear from blaming my hesitation
on the question.
12. As to the virginity of the Holy Mary, if what I have written on this subject does not
suffice to prove that it was possible, we must refuse to believe every record of anything mi-
raculous having taken place in the body of any. If, however, the objection to believing this
miracle is, that it happened only once, ask the friend who is still perplexed by this, whether
instances may not be quoted from secular literature of events which were, like this one,
unique, and which, nevertheless, are believed, not merely as fables are believed by the simple,
but with that faith with which the history of facts is received—ask him, I beseech you, this
question. For if he says that nothing of this kind is to be found in these writings, he ought
to have such instances pointed out to him; if he admits this, the question is decided by his
admission.
1058
To Marcellinus