to answer. He desires him also to stir up his subordinates to greater care in restoring the
Catholic unity in the region of Hippo; indeed he cautions him to diligence on his own estates;
a friend there, who fears to be strict in the carrying out of the statutes, could have his position
alleviated by a word from Celer his patron. From this point we notice a decided sympathy
with the effort to break up Donatism by force.
Parmenian, the successor of Donatus the Great in the see of Carthage, was one of the
brightest disputants on their side. Against him Optatus of Milevis had directed his review
of the schism, full indeed of grave historical blunders, but not lacking in that suavity which
those who think they have the keys of heaven sometimes affect. When Tychonius had ex-
posed some of the inconsequences and weaknesses of the Donatist theory of the Church,
Parmenian undertook a reply, whose main object was to fortify the propositions, (1) that
the evil defile the good in the Church, and must therefore be cut off; and (2) that puristic
folly, that the Donatist community was absolutely pure in its membership and priesthood.
To this much-esteemed work, Augustin replies (c. 400 A.D.) in three books: Contra Epis-
tolam Parmeniani.
In Book I. the main question is, who really incurred the guilt of schism, and initiated
the appeal to the State? He opens with the praise of Tychonius as man and author, but
misses the acute drift of that great man’s argument. He seeks to answer the data of the origin
of the separation as given by Parmenian, who attributes it to the joint movement of Gaul,
Spain and Italy in seeking to make their views universal, and to the influence of Hosius over
Constantine, in winning him to their opinion; nor does Parmenius cease to deprecate the
imperial intervention. Augustin defends this use of the secular arm, but accuses the
Donatists by their history of beginning it in the appeal to Constantine, in the treatment of
the Rogatists and Maximianists, in the abuses of the Circumcelliones, in their petition to
Julian.
Book II. discusses the texts alleged by the Donatists in support of the purity of the
Church, the need of discipline, the sole validity of their baptism and ordination, the
blamelessness of their members and clergy. While both fail in exegetical principles, Parmeni-
an, after the manner of his school, is aggravatingly guilty of using mere catch-words, without
381
regard to text or context. He quotes indiscriminately whatever sounds favorable to his
cause. Some of the passages are: Is. v. 20, Prov. xvii. 15, Is. lix. 1–8, Ecclus. x. 2, Is. lxvi. 3,
Prov. xxi. 27, and others. Augustin gives his interpretations, and does not fail to prod his
opponent with barbs of Optatus, Maximianists, and Circumcelliones.
Book III. handles further the theory of purism in the light of Scriptural proofs. The first
part is mainly an endeavor to give the true significance of I Cor. v. 12, 13. (Compare his
correction in the Retractt. II. xvii.). Augustin is constrained to confess the need of some
internal discipline, and then enforces with wider range the notes of universality, unity and
toleration, especially as illustrated by Cyprian. [Cp. Retractt.. II. xvii.].
658
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.