Human nature must be created with some dispositions; a disposition to relish some
things as good and amiable, and to be averse to other things as odious and disagreeable:
otherwise, it must be without any such thing as inclination or will; perfectly indifferent,
without preference, without choice, or aversion, towards any thing as agreeable or disagree-
able. But if it had any concreated dispositions at all, they must be either right or wrong,
either agreeable or disagreeable to the nature of things. If man had at first the highest relish
of things excellent and beautiful, a disposition to have the quickest and highest delight in
those things which were most worthy of it, then his dispositions were morally right and
amiable, and never can be excellent in a higher sense. But if he had a disposition to love
most those things that were inferior and less worthy, then his dispositions were vicious.
And it is evident there can be no medium between these.
II. This notion of Adam being created without a principle of holiness in his heart, taken
with the rest of Dr. T.‘s scheme, is inconsistent with what the history in the beginning of
Genesis leads us to suppose of the great favours and smiles of Heaven, which Adam enjoyed
while he remained in innocency. The Mosaic account suggests to us, that till Adam sinned,
he was in happy circumstances, surrounded with testimonies and fruits of God’s favour.
This is implicitly owned by Dr. T. when he says, (p. 252.) “That in the dispensation our first
parents were under before the fall, they were placed in a condition proper to engage their
gratitude, love, and obedience.” But it will follow, on our author’s principles, that Adam,
while in innocency, was placed in far worse circumstances, than he was in after his disobedi-
ence, and infinitely worse than his posterity are in; under unspeakably greater disadvantages
for avoiding sin, and the performance of duty. For by this doctrine, Adam’s posterity come
into the world with their hearts as free from any propensity to sin as he, and he was made
as destitute of any propensity to righteousness as they: and yet God, in favour to them, does
great things to restrain them from sin, and excite them to virtue, which he never did for
Adam in innocency, but laid him, in the highest degree, under contrary disadvantages. God,
as an instance of his great favour, and fatherly love to man, since the fall, has denied him
the ease and pleasures of paradise, which gratified and allured his senses, and bodily appetites;
that he might diminish his temptations to sin. And as a still greater means to restrain from
sin, and promote virtue, has subjected him to labour, toil, and sorrow in the world: and not
only so, but as a means to promote his spiritual and eternal good far beyond this, has doomed
him to death. When all this was found insufficient, he, in further prosecution of the designs
of his love, shortened men’s lives exceedingly, made them twelve or thirteen times shorter
than in the first ages. And yet this, with all the innumerable calamities which God, in great
favour to mankind, has brought on the world—whereby their temptations are so vastly cut
short, and the inducements to virtue heaped one upon another to so great a degree—have
proved insufficient, now for so many thousand years together, to restrain from wickedness
in any considerable degree; while innocent human nature, all along, comes into the world
1027
SECTION I. Concerning Adam's original righteousness.