the voice from heaven which all had heard: "This is my beloved Son, believe Him." I think
it likely that if Christ had said that Moses wrote of Him, the ingenious hostility of the Jews
would have led them at once to ask what He supposed Moses to have written. The silence
of the Jews is a proof that Jesus never made such a statement.
3. My chief reason, however, for suspecting the genuineness of this verse is what I said
before, that in all my search of the writings of Moses I have found no prophecy of Christ.
But now that I have found in you a reader of superior intelligence, I hope to learn something;
and I promise to be grateful if no feeling of ill-will prevents you from giving me the benefit
of your higher attainments, as your lofty style of reproof entitles me to expect from you. I
ask for instruction in whatever the writings of Moses contain about our God and Lord which
has escaped me in reading. I beseech you not to use the ignorant argument that Christ affirms
Moses to have written of Him. For suppose you had not to deal with me, as in my case there
is an obligation to believe Him whom I profess to follow, but with a Jew or a Gentile, in
reply to the statement that Moses wrote of Christ, they will ask for proofs. What shall we
say to them? We cannot quote Christ’s authority, for they do not believe in Him. We must
point out what Moses wrote.
4. What, then, shall we point to? Shall it be that passage which you often quote where
the God of Moses says to him: "I will raise up unto them from among their brethren a
prophet like unto thee?"570 But the Jew can see that this does not refer to Christ, and there
is every reason against our thinking that it does. Christ was not a prophet, nor was He like
Moses: for Moses was a man, and Christ was God; Moses was a sinner, and Christ sinless;
Moses was born by ordinary generation, and Christ of a virgin according to you, or, as I
hold, not born at all: Moses, for offending his God, was put to death on the mountain; and
Christ suffered voluntarily, and the Father was well pleased in Him. If we were to assert
that Christ was a prophet like Moses, the Jew would either deride us as ignorant or pronounce
us untruthful.
5. Or shall we take another favorite passage of yours: "They shall see their life hanging,
and shall not believe their life?"571 You insert the words "on a tree," which are not in the
original. Nothing can be easier than to show that this has no reference to Christ. Moses is
uttering dire threatenings in case the people should depart from his law, and says among
other things that they would be taken captive by their enemies, and would be expecting
221
death day and night, having no confidence in the life allowed them by their conquerors, so
that their life would hang in uncertainty from fear of impending danger. This passage will
not do, we must try others. I cannot admit that the words, "Cursed is every one that hangeth
on a tree," refer to Christ, or when it is said that the prince or prophet must be killed who
570 Deut. xviii. 15.
571 Deut. xxviii. 66.
376
Faustus willing to believe not only that the Jewish but that all Gentile…