He contributed to promote, at least in his later writings, the Catholic faith of miracles,66
and the worship of Mary;67 though he exempts the Virgin only from actual sin, not from
original, and, with all his reverence for her, never calls her “mother of God.”68
At first an advocate of religious liberty and of purely spiritual methods of opposing error,
he afterwards asserted the fatal principle of forcible coërcion, and lent the great weight of
his authority to the system of civil persecution, at the bloody fruits of which in the middle
age he himself would have shuddered; for he was always at heart a man of love and gentleness,
and personally acted on the glorious principle: “Nothing conquers but truth, and the victory
of truth is love.”69
Thus even truly great and good men have unintentionally, through mistaken zeal, become
the authors of incalculable mischief.
3. But, on the other hand, Augustin is, of all the fathers, nearest to evangelical Protest-
antism, and may be called, in respect of his doctrine of sin and grace, the first forerunner
of the Reformation. The Lutheran and Reformed churches have ever conceded to him,
without scruple, the cognomen of Saint, and claimed him as one of the most enlightened
witnesses of the truth and most striking examples of the marvellous power of divine grace
in the transformation of a sinner. It is worthy of mark, that his Pauline doctrines, which are
66 In his former writings he expressed a truly philosophical view concerning miracles (De vera relig. c. 25,
§47; c. 50, §98; De utilit. credendi, c. 16, §34; De peccat. meritis et remiss. l. ii. c. 32, §52, and De civit. Dei, xxii.
c. 8); but in his Retract. l. i. c. 14, §5, he corrects or modifies a former remark in his book De utilit. credendi,
stating that he did not mean to deny the continuance of miracles altogether, but only such great miracles as oc-
curred at the time of Christ (“quia non tanta nec omnia, non quia nulla fiunt”). See Ch. Hist. III. §§87 and 88,
and the instructive monograph of the younger Nitzsch: Augustinus’ Lehre vom Wunder, Berlin, 1865 (97 pp.).
67 See Ch. Hist. III. §§81 and 82.
68 Comp. Tract. in Evang. Joannis, viii. c. 9, where he says: “Cur ergo ait matri filius; Quid mihi et tibi est,
mulier? nondum venit hora mea (John ii. 4). Dominus noster Jesus Christus et Deus erat et homo: secundum quod
Deus erat, matrem non habebat; secundum quod homo erat, habebat. Mater ergo [Maria] erat carnis, mater hu-
manitatis, mater infirmitatis quam suscepit propter nos.” This strict separation of the Godhead from the manhood
of Jesus in his birth from the Virgin would have exposed Augustin in the East to the suspicion of Nestorianism.
But he died a year before the council of Ephesus, at which Nestorius was condemned.
69 See Ch. Hist. III. §27, p. 144 sq. He changed his view partly from his experience that the Donatists, in his
own diocese, were converted to the catholic unity “timore legum imperialium,” and were afterwards perfectly
good Catholics. He adduces also a misinterpretation of Luke xiv. 23, and Prov. ix. 9: “Da sapienti occasionem et
sapientior erit.” Ep. 93, ad Vincentium Rogatistam, §17 (tom. ii. p. 237 sq. ed. Bened.). But he expressly discouraged
the infliction of death on heretics, and adjured the proconsul Donatus, Ep. 100, by Jesus Christ, not to repay the
Donatists in kind. “Corrigi eos cupimus, non necari.”
43
The Influence of St. Augustin on Posterity, and His Relation to Catholicism…