Chapter XXXII.—Valentinus Convicted of Plagiarisms from Plato.
I think that the heresy of Valentinus which is of Pythagorean (origin), has been suffi-
ciently, indeed more than sufficiently, delineated. It therefore seems also expedient, that
having explained his opinions, we should desist from (further) refutation (of his system).
Plato, then, in expounding mysteries concerning the universe, writes to Dionysius expressing
himself after some such manner718 as this: “I must speak to you by riddles,719 in order that
if the letter may meet with any accident in its leaves by either sea or land, he who reads
(what falls into his hands) may not understand it. For so it is. All things are about the King
of all, and on his account are all things, and he is cause of all the glorious (objects of creation).
The second is about the second, and the third about the third. But pertaining to the King
there is none of those things of which I have spoken. But after this the soul earnestly desires
to learn what sort these are, looking upon those things that are akin to itself, and not one
of these is (in itself) sufficient. This is, O son of Dionysius and Doris, the question (of yours)
which is a cause of all evil things. Nay, but rather the solicitude concerning this is innate in
the soul; and if one does not remove this, he will never really attain truth.720 But what is
astonishing in this matter, listen. For there are men who have heard these things—(men)
furnished with capacities for learning, and furnished with capacities of memory, and persons
who altogether in every way are endued with an aptitude for investigation with a view to
inference. (These are) at present aged speculators.721 And they assert that opinions which
at one time were credible are now incredible, and that things once incredible are now the
contrary. While, therefore, turning the eye of examination towards these (inquiries), exercise
caution, lest at any time you should have reason to repent in regard of those things should
they happen in a manner unbecoming to your dignity. On this account I have written
nothing concerning these (points); nor is there any treatise of Plato’s (upon them), nor ever
shall there be. The observations, however, now made are those of Socrates, conspicuous for
virtue even while he was a young man.”
Valentinus, falling in with these (remarks), has made a fundamental principle in his
system “the King of all,” whom Plato mentioned, and whom this heretic styles Pater, and
Bythos, and Proarche722 over the rest of the Æons. And when Plato uses the words, “what
718 Cruice thinks that the following extract from Plato’s epistles has been added by a second hand. [Cf. vol.
iii. p. 181, this series.]
719 There are some verbal diversities between the texts of Plato and Hippolytus, which a reference will show
(see Plat., Epist., t. ix. p. 76, ed. Bekker).
720 Some forty lines that follow in Plato’s letter are omitted here.
721 Here likewise there is another deficiency as compared with the original letter.
722 Miller’s text is, καὶ πᾶσι γῆν, etc. In the German and French edition of Hippolytus we have, instead of
this, καὶ Προαρχὴν. The latter word is introduced on the authority of Epiphanius and Theodoret. Bernays proposes
Valentinus Convicted of Plagiarisms from Plato.
231
Valentinus Convicted of Plagiarisms from Plato.