42 according to the threatening in the former chapter.” Now, if mankind became mortal,
and must die, according to the threatening in the former chapter, then doubtless the
threatening in the former chapter, Thou shalt die, had respect not only to Adam, but to
mankind, and included Adam’s posterity. Yea, and Dr. T. is express in it, and very often so,
that the sentence concerning dropping into the ground, or returning to the dust, did include
Adam’s posterity. So, p. 20. speaking there of that sentence, “Observe (says he) that we their
posterity are in fact subjected to the same affliction and mortality, here by sentence inflicted
on our first parents.”—P. 42. Note. “But yet men through that long tract, were all subject to
death, therefore they must be included in the sentence.” The same he affirms in innumerable
other places, some of which I shall have occasion to mention presently.
The sentence which is founded on the threatening, and (as Dr. T. says) according to the
threatening, extends to as many as were included in the threatening, and to no more. If the
sentence be upon a collective subject, indefinitely, the greatest part of which were not included
in the threatening, nor were ever threatened at all, then certainly this sentence is not according
to the threatening, nor built upon it. If the sentence be according to the threatening, then
we may justly explain the threatening by sentence. And if we find the sentence spoken to
the same person whom the threateningwas spoken, and spoken in the second person singular
in like manner with the threatening, founded on the threatening, and according to it; and if
we find the sentence includes Adam’s posterity, then we may certainly infer, that so did the
threatening. And hence, that both the threatening and the sentence were delivered to Adam
as the public head and representative of his posterity.
And we may also further infer from it, in another respect, directly contrary to Dr. T.‘s
doctrine, that the sentence which included Adam’s posterity, was to death, as a punishment
to that posterity, as well as to Adam himself. For a sentence pronounced in execution of a
threatening, is for punishment. Threatenings are of punishments. Neither God nor man are
wont to threaten others with favours and benefits.
But lest any of this author’s admirers should stand to it, that it may very properly be
said, God threatened mankind with bestowing great kindness upon them, I would observe,
that Dr. T. himself often speaks of this sentence as pronounced by God on all mankind, as
condemning them; as a sentence of condemnation judicially pronounced, or a sentence which
God pronounced on all mankind acting as their judge, and in a judicial proceeding. This he
affirms in multitudes of places. In p. 20. speaking of this sentence, which he there says,
subjects us, Adam’s and Eve’s posterity, to affliction and mortality, he calls it a judicial act
of condemnation. “The judicial act of condemnation (says he) clearly implies, a taking him
to pieces, and turning him to the ground from whence he was taken.” And (p. 28, 29. Note.)
42 The subsequent part of the quotation the reader will not meet with in the third edition of Dr. T. but the
second, of 1711.
1038
SECTION III. Adam a federal head, &c.