CHAP. XI.
J
CHRISTIAN RELixGION. 109
impropiiety and indecency conspicuous in most of them, and
the wanton licentiousness displayed in them by the painters
and statuaries, at which I have before hinted : I only assert,
that even if they were intrinsically faultless, still they would
be altogether unavailing for the purposes of instruction,
XIII. But, passing over that difference also, let us consider,
as we proceed, whether it be expedient to have any images at
all in Christian temples, either descriptive of historical events,
or representative of human forms. In the first place, if the
authority of the ancient Church have any influence with us,
let us remember, that for about five hundred years, while re-
ligion continued in a more prosperous state, aniTpurer doctrine
prevailedT" the- (Thhstian^chnrr'.hes WRre__P^fMTerall3^^
images. They were then^irsrintroHuced, therefo^^
ment the churches, whenThe purity of the minlstryhad beg;un
toj.egenerat.a,_-^will not dispute what was the reason which
influenced the first authors of them; but if you compare one
age with another, you will see that they were much declined
from the integrity of those who had no images. Who can
suppose, that those holy fathers would have permitted the
Church to remain so long destitute of what they judged use-
ful and salutary for it ? The fact was, that, instead of omitting
them through ignorance or negligence, they perceived them
to be of little or no use, but, on the contrary, pregnant with
much danger ; and, therefore, intentionally and wisely re-
jected them. This is asserted in express terms by Augustine :
" When they are fixed," says he, "in those places in an hon-
om*able elevation, to attract the attention of those who are
praying and sacrificing, though they are destitute of sense
and life, yet, by the very similitude of living members and
senses, they afl"ect weak minds, so that they appear to them
to live and breathe," &c. (e) And in another place : " For
that representation of members leads, and, as it were, con-
strains, the mind, which animates a body, to suppose that
body to be endued with perception, which it sees to be very
similar to its own," &c. And a little after : " Idols have more
influence to bow down an unhappy soul, because they have a
mouth, eyes, ears, and feet, than to correct it, because they
neither speak, nor see, nor hear, nor walk." This indeed
appears to be the reason of John's exhortation to " keep our-
selves," not only from the worship of idols, but " from idols "
themselves. And we have found it too true, that, through
the horrible frenzy, which, almost to the total destruction of
piety, hath heretofore possessed the world, as soon as images
are set up in churches, there is, as it were, a standard of idol-
re Epist. 49. De Civ. Dei. lib. iv. cip. 31