23 ἄτινά ἐστιν λόγον μὲν ἔχοντα σοφίας ἐν ἐθελοθρη-
words on this occasion, as practically abolishing the Mosaic distinction of meats by declaring all alike to be clean (καθαρίζων; see the note on ver. 16). (3) Both alike connect such ordinances with the practices condemned in the prophetic denunciation of Isaiah.
23. 'All such teaching is worthless. It may bear the semblance of wisdom; but it wants the reality. It may make an officious parade of religious service; it may vaunt its humility; it may treat the body with merciless vigour; but it entirely fails in its chief aim. It is powerless to check indulgence of the flesh.' ἄτινα] 'which sort of things.' Not only these particular precepts, μὴ ἄψῃ κ.τ.λ., but all precepts falling under the same category are condemned. For this force of ἄτινα as distinguished from ᾶ, see the notes on Gal. iv. 24, v. 19, Phil. iv. 3. The antecedent here is not ἐντάλματα καὶ διδασκαλίας κ.τ.λ., but the prohibitions given in ver. 21.
λόγον μὲν κ.τ.λ.] 'having a reputation for wisdom,' but not the reality. The corresponding member, which should be introduced by δέ, is suppressed; the opposite clause being postponed and appearing later in a new form, οὐκ ἐν τιμῇ τινι κ.τ.λ. Such suppressions are common in classical writers, more especially in Plato; see Kühner § 531, II. p. 813 sq., Jelf § 766, and comp. Winer § lxiii. p. 719 sq. Jerome therefore is not warranted in attributing St Paul's language here to 'imperitia artis grammaticae' (Epist. exxi, Op. II. p. 884). On the contrary it is just the license which an adept in a language would be more likely to take than a novice.
In this sentence λόγον ἔχοντα σοφίας is best taken as a single predicate, so that ἐστιν is disconnected from ἔχοντα. Otherwise the construction ἐστιν ἔχοντα (for ἔχει) would be supported by many parallels in the Greek Testament; see Winer § xlv. p. 437.
The phrase λόγον ἔχειν τινός, so far as I have observed, has four meanings. (A) Two as applied to the thinking subject. (i) 'To take account of, to hold in account, to pay respect to': e.g. Aisch. Prom. 231 βριτῶν δὲ τῶν ταλαιπώρων λόγον οὐκ ἔσχειν οὐδένα, Domosth. de Coron. § 199 εἴπερ ἢ δόξης ἢ προγόνων ἢ τοῦ μέλλοντος αἰῶνος εἶχε λόγον, Plut. Vit. Philop. 18 πῶς ἄξιον ἐκείνου λόγον ἔχειν τοῦ ἀνδρὸς κ.τ.λ. (ii) 'To possess the reason or account or definition of,' 'to have a scientific knowledge of'; Plato Gorg. p. 465 A τέχνην δὲ αὐτὴν οὗ φημὶ εἶναι ἀλλ' ἐμπειρίαν, ὅτι οὐκ ἔχει λόγον οὐδένα ὡν προσφέρει, ὁποῖα ἄττα τὴν φύσιν ἐστίν, and so frequently. These two senses are recognised by Aristotle, Eth. Nic. i. 13 (p. 1102), where he distinguishes the meaning of the expressions ἔχειν λόγον τοῦ πατρὸς ἢ τῶν φίλων and ἔχειν λόγον τῶν μαθητικῶν. (B) Two as applied to the object of thought. (iii) 'To have the credit or reputation of,' as here. This sense of ἔχειν λόγον, 'to be reputed,' is more commonly found with an infinitive: e.g. Plato Epin. 987 B αὐτὸς Ἀφροδίτης εἶναι σχέδον ἔχει λόγον. (iv) 'To fulfil the definition of, to possess the characteristics, to have the nature of'; e.g. Philo Vit. Cont. 4 (II. p. 477) ἐκάτερον δὲ πηγῆς λόγον ἔχον, Plut. Mor. p. 637 D τὸ δὲ ὡὸν οὔτε ἀρχῆς ἔχει λόγον, οὐ γὰρ ὑφίσταται πρῶτον, οὔτε ὅλου φύσιν, ἀτελὲς γὰρ ἐστιν, ib. 640 F δεῖ πρὸς τὸ ἐμφυτευόμενον χώρας λόγον ἔχειν τὸ δεξόμενον. The senses of λόγον ἔχειν with other constructions, or as used absolutely, are very various, e.g. 'to be reasonable,' 'to hold discourse,' 'to bear a ratio,' etc., but do not come under consideration here. Nor again does such an expression as Plut. Mor. p. 550 C μήτε τὸν λόγον ἔχων τοῦ νομοθέτου, 'not being in pos-
σκεία καὶ ταπεινοφροσύνη [καὶ] ἀφειδεία σώματος, οὐκ
session of, not knowing, the intention of the legislator'; for the definite article removes it from the category of the cases considered.
ἐν ἐθελοθρησκεία] 'in volunteered, self-imposed, officious, supererogatory service.' One or both of these two ideas, (i) 'excessive readiness, officious zeal,' (ii) 'affectation, unreality,' are involved in this and similar compounds; e.g. ἐθελοδουλεία, ἐθελοκάκησις, ἐθελοκίνδυνος, ἐθελοκωφεῖν, ἐθελορητωρ, ἐθελοπρόξενος: these compounds being used most frequently, though not always (as this last word shows), in a bad sense. This mode of expression was naturalised in Latin, as appears from Augustino Epist. exlix. 27 (II. p. 514) 'Sic enim et vulgo dicitur qui divitem affectat thelodives, et qui sapientem thelosapiens, et cetera hujusmodi.' Epiphanius, when writing of the Pharisees, not content with the word here supplied by St Paul, coins a double compound ἐθελοπερισσοθρησκεία, Haer. i. 16 (p. 34).
ταπεινοφροσύνη] The word is here disparaged by its connexion, as in ver. 18 (see the note there). The force of ἐθελο- may be regarded as carried on to it. Real genuine ταπεινοφροσύνη is commended below; iii. 12.
ἀφειδεία σώματος] 'hard treatment of the body.' The expression ἀφειδεῖν τοῦ σώματος is not uncommon, being used most frequently, not as here of ascetic discipline, but rather of courageous exposure to hardship and danger in war, e.g. Lysias Or. Fun. 25, Joseph. B. J. iii. 7. 18, Lucian Anach. 24, Plut. Vit. Pericl. 10; in Plut. Mor. p. 137 e however, of a student's toil, and ib. p. 135 E, more generally of the rigorous demands made by the soul on the body. The substantive ἀφειδεία or ἀφειδία does not often occur. On the forms in -εια and -ία derived from adjectives in -ης see Buttmann Ausf. Gramm. § 119, II. p. 416 sq. The great preponderance of manuscript authority favours the form ἀφειδεία here: but in such questions of orthography the fact carries less weight than in other matters. The καὶ before ἀφειδεία should probably be omitted; in which case ἀφειδεία becomes an instrumental dative, explaining λόγον ἔχοντα σοφίας. While the insertion would naturally occur to scribes, the omission gives more point to the sentence. The ἐθελοθρησκεία καὶ ταπεινοφροσύνη as the religious elements are thus separated from the ἀφειδεία σώματος as the practical rule.
οὐκ ἐν τιμῇ κ.τ.λ.] 'yet not really of any value to remedy indulgence of the flesh.' So interpreted the words supply the opposite clause to λόγον μὲν ἔχοντα σοφίας, as the presence of the negative οὐκ naturally suggests. If the sentence had been undisturbed, this opposite clause would naturally have been introduced by δὲ, but the interposition of ἐν ἐθελοθρησκεία κ.τ.λ. has changed its form by a sort of attraction. For this sense of ἐν τιμῇ comp. Lucian Merc. cond. 17 τὰ καινὰ τῶν ὑποδημάτων ἐν τιμῇ τινὶ καὶ ἐπιμελεία ἐστίν: similarly Hom. Il. ix. 319 ἐν δὲ ἰῇ τιμῇ κ.τ.λ. The preposition πρὸς, like our English 'for,' when used after words denoting utility, value, sufficiency, etc., not uncommonly introduces the object to check or prevent or cure which the thing is to be employed. And even though utility may not be directly expressed in words, yet if the idea of a something to be remedied is present, this preposition is freely used notwithstanding. See Isocr. Phil. 16 (p. 85) πρὸς τοὺς βαρβάρους χρήσιμον, Arist. H. A. iii. 21 (p. 522) συμφέρει πρὸς τὰς διαρροίας ἡ τοι-αύτη μάλιστα, de Respir. 8 (p. 474) ἀνάγκη γίνεσθαι κατάψυξιν, εἰ μέλλει τεύξεσθαι σωτηρίας τοῦτο γὰρ βοηθεῖ πρὸς ταύτην τὴν φθοράν, Lucian Pisc. 27 χρήσιμον γοῦν καὶ πρὸς ἐκείνους τὸ τοιοῦτον, Galen Op. XII. p. 399 χρωμὲ-νῳ γε τίνι πρὸς τὸ πάθος ἀρκτεῖῳ στέἐν τιμῇ τινὶ πρὸς πλησμονὴν τῆς σαρκός.
ατι, p. 420 τοῦ δόντος αὐτὰ πρὸς ἀλω-πεκίας φαλακρώσεις κ.τ.λ., p. 430 συνέ-θηκαν...φάρμακα πρὸς ρεούσας τρίχας, p. 476 βραχυτάτην ἔχοντι δύναμιν ὡς πρὸς τὸ προκείμενον σύμπτωμα, p. 482 τοῦτο δὲ καὶ πρὸς τὰ ἐν ὅλῳ τῷ σώματι ἐξανθήματα σφόδρα χρήσιμόν ἐστιν. p. 514 χρηστέον δὲ πᾶσι τοῖς ἀναγεγραμμένοις βοηθήμασι πρὸς τὰς γινόμενας δι' ἔγκαν-σιν κεφαλαλγίας, p. 601 κόλλιστον πρὸς αὐτὴν φάρμακον ἐγχείμενον νάρδινον μύρον. These examples from Galen are only a few out of probably some hundreds, which might be collected from the treatise in which they occur, the de Compositione Medicamentorum.
The language, which the Colossian false teachers would use, may be inferred from the account given by Philo of a Judaic sect of mystic ascetics, who may be regarded, not indeed as their direct, but as their collateral ancestors (see p. 86, note 2, p. 94), the Therapeutes of Egypt; de Vit. Cont. § 4 (II. p. 476 sq.) τρυφῶσιν ὑπὸ σο-φίας ἐστιώμενοι πλουσίως καὶ ἀφθόνως τὰ δόγματα χορηγούσης, ὡς καὶ...μό-λις δι' ἰξ ἡμερῶν ἀπογεύεσθαι τρο-φῆς ἀναγκαίας...σιτοῦνται δι'...ὄρτον εὐ-τελῆ, καὶ ὄψον ἄλες...πότον ὕδωρ ναμα-τιαῖον αὐτοῖς ἐστίν...πλησμονὴν ὡς ἐχθρόν τε καὶ ἐπίβουλον ἐκτρεπόμενοι ψυχῆς καὶ σώματος. St Paul apparently has before him some similar exposition of the views of the Colossian heretics, either in writing or (more probably) by report from Epaphras. In reply he altogether denies the claims of this system to the title of σοφία; he disputes the value of these δόγματα; he allows that this πλησμονή is the great evil to be checked, the fatal disease to be cured; but he will not admit that the remedies prescribed have any substantial and lasting efficacy.
The interpretation here offered is not new, but it has been strangely overlooked or despised. The passages adduced will I trust show the groundlessness of objections which have been brought against it owing to the use of the preposition; and in all other respects it seems to be far preferable to any rival explanation which has been suggested. The favourite interpretations in ancient or modern times divide themselves into two classes, according to the meaning assigned to πρὸς πλησμονὴν τῆς σαρκός. (1) It is explained in a good sense: 'to satisfy the reasonable wants of the body.' In this case οὐκ ἐν τιμῇ τινί is generally interpreted, 'not holding it (the body) in any honour.' So the majority of the fathers, Greek and Latin. This has the advantage of preserving the continuity of the words οὐκ ἐν τιμῇ τινὶ πρὸς πλησμονὴν κ.τ.λ.: but it assigns an impossible sense to πλησμονὴ τῆς σαρκός. For πλησμονή always denotes 'repletion,' 'surfeiting,' 'excessive indulgence,' and cannot be used of a reasonable attention to the physical cravings of nature; as Galen says, Op. xv. p. 113 πάντων εἰω-θότων οὐ μόνον ἰατρῶν ἀλλὰ καὶ τῶν ἄλ-λων Ἑλλήνων τὸ τῆς πλησμονῆς ὄνομα μᾶλλόν πως ἐπιφέρειν ταῖς ὑπερβο-λαῖς τῆς συμμέτρου ποσότητος: and certainly neither the Apostle nor the Colossian ascetics were likely to depart from this universal rule. To the long list of passages quoted in Wetstein may be added such references as Philo Leg. ad Gai. § 1 (II. p. 546), Clem. Hom. viii. 15, Justin Dial. 126, Dion. Alex. in Euseb. H.E. vii. 25; but they might be increased to any extent. (2) A bad sense is attached to πλησμονή, as usage demands. And here two divergent interpretations have been put forward. (i) The proper continuity of the sentence is preserved, and the words οὐκ ἐν τιμῇ τινὶ πρὸς πλησμονὴν τῆς σαρκός are regarded as an exposition of the doctrine of the false teachers from their own point of view. So Theodore of Mopsuestia, οὐ τίμιον νομίζον-
{"canonical_mapping_status":"native_coordinates_only; no canonical mapping inferred","footnote_boundary_status":"whole_native_row_preserved; no independent-note segmentation or note-count claim","html_tags":{"p":15},"id":"sqlite3:18d0fa08f9b61abe39b402806294c6cc80bd05266674df295094b04f2c75b3fd:commentaries:45","native_body_column":"text","native_module_context_literals":{"$context_sha256":"6a5da605c8557bc004c070d138969cc9df91b8441cd46e609333a901bec25f5a"},"native_module_metadata_ref":{"$context_sha256":"0fa22d44cfd532bf8ca61290c76d3112253de296bf0dd8291ae95151d9ec1b85"},"native_reference":{"book_number":580,"chapter_number_from":2,"chapter_number_to":2,"verse_number_from":23,"verse_number_to":23},"native_rowid":45,"native_table":"commentaries","projection":"HTML character data with explicit block newlines; no text-node deletion or whitespace folding; original HTML retained","public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"native-verse-keyed-module-record","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_family_classification":"sermonindex","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"74f03050381888d8038ccdef147bf7e9f72a1ea012718f3580c297c3b7e5f291"},"source_html_sha256":"74f03050381888d8038ccdef147bf7e9f72a1ea012718f3580c297c3b7e5f291","source_locator":{"$context_sha256":"2ce54c0d68ed7cbc9208da85eb19280dca0b3778e595c19dbe5dd07035f91ddf"},"source_origin_path":"SI-JBLIGHTFOOT.commentaries.SQLite3","source_sha256":"18d0fa08f9b61abe39b402806294c6cc80bd05266674df295094b04f2c75b3fd"}