proclaim to be truth’s enemy and in arms against public opinion? Who is it who begs the
readers of his book not ‘to look to the numbers of those who profess a belief, or to mere
tradition, or to let their judgment be biassed so as to consider as trustworthy what is only
suspected to be the stronger side?’ Can one and the same man write like this, and then make
those charges, scheming that his readers should follow his own novelties at the very moment
that he is abusing others for opposing themselves to the general belief? As for ‘brazening
out facts which give him the lie, and men’s censure,’ I leave the reader to judge to whom
this applies; whether to one who by a most careful self-restraint made sobriety and quietness
and perfect purity the rule of his own life as well as that of his entourage, or to one who ad-
vised that nature should not be molested when it is her pleasure to advance through the
appetites of the body, not to thwart indulgence, nor to be so particular as that in the training
of our life; but that a self-chosen faith should be considered sufficient for a man to attain
perfection. If he denies that this is his teaching, I and any right-minded person would rejoice
if he were telling the truth in such a denial. But his genuine followers will not allow him to
produce such a denial, or their leading principles would be gone, and the platform of those
who for this reason embrace his tenets would fall to pieces. As for shameless indifference
to human censure, you may look at his youth or his after life, and you would find him in
both open to this reproach. The two men’s lives, whether in youth or manhood, tell a widely-
different tale.
Let our speech-writer, while he reminds himself of his youthful doings in his native
land, and afterwards at Constantinople, hear from those who can tell him what they know
of the man whom he slanders. But if any would inquire into their subsequent occupations,
let such a person tell us which of the two he considers to deserve so high a reputation; the
man who ungrudgingly spent upon the poor his patrimony even before he was a priest, and
most of all in the time of the famine, during which he was a ruler of the Church, though
still a priest in the rank of presbyters90; and afterwards did not hoard even what remained
to him, so that he too might have made the Apostles’ boast, ‘Neither did we eat any man’s
bread for nought91;’ or, on the other hand, the man who has made the championship of a
tenet a source of income, the man who creeps into houses, and does not conceal his loathsome
affliction by staying at home, nor considers the natural aversion which those in good health
must feel for such, though according to the law of old he is one of those who are banished
from the inhabited camp because of the contagion of his unmistakeable92 disease.
46
Basil is called ‘hasty’ and ‘insolent,’ and in both characters ‘a liar’ by this man who ‘would
in patience and meekness educate those of a contrary opinion to himself;’ for such are the
90 ἔτι ἐν τῷ κληρῳ τῶν πρεσβυτερων ιερατεύων
91 2 Thess. iii. 8.
92 According to Ruffinus (Hist. Eccl. x. 25), his constitution was poisoned with jaundice within and without.
83
All his insulting epithets are shewn by facts to be false.