§4. He thus shows the oneness of the Eternal Son with the Father the identity of essence
and the community of nature (wherein is a natural inquiry into the production of wine), and
that the terms “Son” and “product” in the naming of the Only-Begotten include a like idea of
relationship.
What has been said, therefore, has clearly exposed the slackness which is to be found
in the knavery of our author, who, while he goes about to establish the opposition of the
essence of the Only-begotten to that of the Father, by the method of calling the one “ungen-
erate,” and the other “generate,” stands convicted of playing the fool with his inconsistent
arguments. For it was shown from his own words, first, that the name of “essence” means
one thing, and that of “generation” another; and next, that there did not come into existence,
with the Son, any new and different essence besides the essence of the Father, but that what
the Father is as regards the definition of His nature, that also He is Who is of the Father, as
145
the nature does not change into diversity in the Person of the Son, according to the truth
of the argument displayed by our consideration of Adam and Abel. For as, in that instance,
he that was not generated after a like sort was yet, so far as concerns the definition of essence,
the same with him that was generated, and Abel’s generation did not produce any change
in the essence, so, in the case of these pure doctrines, the Only-begotten God did not, by
His own generation, produce in Himself any change in the essence of Him Who is ungenerate
(coming forth, as the Gospel says, from the Father, and being in the Father,) but is, according
to the simple and homely language of the creed we profess, “Light of Light, very God of very
God,” the one being all that the other is, save being that other. With regard, however, to the
aim for the sake of which he carries on this system-making, I think there is no need for me
at present to express any opinion, whether it is audacious and dangerous, or a thing allowable
and free from danger, to transform the phrases which are employed to signify the Divine
nature from one to another, and to call Him Who is generated by the name of “product of
generation.”
I let these matters pass, that my discourse may not busy itself too much in the strife
against lesser points, and neglect the greater; but I say that we ought carefully to consider
the question whether the natural relation does introduce the use of these terms: for this
surely Eunomius asserts, that with the affinity of the appellations there is also asserted an
essential relationship. For he would not say, I presume, that the mere names themselves,
apart from the sense of the things signified, have any mutual relation or affinity; but all
discern the relationship or diversity of the appellations by the meanings which the words
express. If, therefore, he confesses that “the Son” has a natural relation with “the Father,”
let us leave the appellations, and consider the force that is found in their significations,
whether in their affinity we discern diversity of essence, or that which is kindred and char-
acteristic. To say that we find diversity is downright madness. For how does something
without kinship or community “preserve order,” connected and conformable, in the names,
He thus shows the oneness of the Eternal Son with the Father the identity of essence and the community of nature (wherein is a natural inquiry into the production of wine), and that the terms “Son” and “product” in the naming of the Only-Begotten include a like idea of relationship.
279
He thus shows the oneness of the Eternal Son with the Father the identity…