LETTER CXLVII. 291
Nevertheless "I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from
his way and live ; " ' and as it is not they that are whole who need a physician but they that
are sick,2 even after his sin I hold out a hand
to the prostrate sinner and exhort him, pollut-
ed as he is in his own blood,3 to wash away his stains with tears of penitence. But if even
then he shews himself unwilling to repent, and
if, after he has suffered shipwreck, he refuses
to clutch the plank which alone can save him,
I am compelled at last to say : " Thus saith the Lord, For three transgressions and for
four shall I not turn away from him ? " For
this " turning away " God accounts a punish- ment, inasmuch as the sinner is left to his own
devices. It is thus that he visits the sins of the
fathers upon the children unto the third and
fourth generation ; 4 not punishing those who sin immediately but pardoning their first of-
fences and only passing sentence on them for their last. For if it were otherwise and if God
were to stand forth on the moment as the aven-
ger of iniquity, the church would lose many of
its saints ; and certainly would be deprived of
the apostle Paul. The prophet Ezekiel, from
whom we have quoted above, repeating God's
words spoken to himself speaks thus : "Open thy mouth and eat what I shall give thee. And
behold," he says, " an hand was sent unto me ; and, lo, a roll of a book was therein ; and he
spread it before me ; and it was written within and without : and there was written therein
lamentations, and a song, and woe." " The first of these three belongs to you if you prove will-
ing, as a sinner, to repent of your sins. The
second belongs to those who are holy, who are
called upon to sing praises to God ; for praise
does not become a sinner's mouth. And the
third belongs to persons like you who in de-
spair have given themselves over to unclean-
ness, to fornication, to the belly, and to the low-
est lusts ; men who suppose that death ends all
and that there is nothing beyond it ; who say :
" When the overflowing scourge shall pass
through it shall not come unto us." " The book which the prophet eats is the whole series
of the Scriptures, which in turn bewail the
penitent, celebrate the righteous, and curse the
desperate. For nothing is so displeasing to
God as an impenitent heart. Impenitence is
the one sin for which there is no forgiveness.
For if one who ceases to sin is pardoned even
after he has sinned, and if prayer has power
to bend the judge ; it follows that every im-
penitent sinner must provoke his judge to
wrath. Thus despair is the one sin for which
there is no remedy. By obstinate rejection of
1 Kzek. xxxiii. n.
3 Cf . Ezek. xvi. 6.
* Ezek. iii. i : ii. 9, 10, Vulg.
8 Luke v. 31. 4 Ex. xx. 5.
• Is. xxviii. 15.
God's grace men turn His mercy into sternness and severity. Yet, that you may know that
God does every day call sinners to repentance,
hear Isaiah's words : " In that day," he says,
" did the Lord God of Hosts call to weeping
and to mourning and to baldness and to gird-
ing with sackcloth : and behold joy and glad-
ness, slaying oxen, and killing sheep, eating
flesh, and drinking wine; let us eat and drink,
for to-morrow we shall die." After these words filled with the recklessness of despair
the Scripture goes on to say : " And it was revealed in my ears by the Lord of Hosts,
Surely this iniquity shall not be purged from
you till ye die." Only when they become dead to sin, will their sin be forgiven them.
For, so long as they live in sin, it cannot be
put away.
4. Have mercy I beseech you upon your
soul. Consider that God's judgment will one day overtake you. Remember by what a
bishop you were ordained. The holy man was
mistaken in his choice ; but this he might well
be. For even God repented that he had an-
ointed Saul to be king.8 Even among the twelve apostles Judas was found a traitor.
And Nicolas of Antioch — a deacon like your-
self 3 — disseminated the Nicolaitan heresy and
all manner of uncleanness.4 I do not now
bring up to you the many virgins whom you
are said to have seduced, or the noble matrons
who have suffered death " because violated by you, or the greedy profligacy with which you
have hied through dens of sin. For grave and
serious as such sins are in themselves, they are
trivial indeed when compared with those which
I have now to narrate. How great must be
the sin beside which seduction and adultery are
insignificant ? Miserable wretch that you are !
when you enter the cave wherein the Son of
God was born, where truth sprang out of the
earth and the land did yield her increase," it is to make an assignation. Have you no fear
that the babe will cry from the manger, that
the newly delivered virgin will see you, that
the mother of the Lord will behold you ? The
angels cry aloud, the shepherds run, the star
shines down from heaven, the wise men wor-
ship, Herod is terrified, Jerusalem is in con-
fusion, and meantime you creep into a virgin's cell to seduce the virgin to whom it belongs. I
am filled with consternation and a shiver
runs through me, soul and body, when I try to
set before your eyes the deed that you have
done. The whole church was keeping vigil
by night and proclaiming Christ as its Lord ;
in one spirit though in different tongues the
1 Isa. xxii. 12-14. a ' Sam. xv. n.
1 Acts vi. 5. 4 Rev. ii. 6, 15. * Women guilty of adultery were legally punishable with
death until the time of Justinian- • Ps. Ixxxv. ii, 12.