13
Canon V.
Concerning those, whether of the clergy or of the laity, who have been excommunicated
in the several provinces, let the provision of the canon be observed by the bishops which
provides that persons cast out by some be not readmitted by others. Nevertheless, inquiry
should be made whether they have been excommunicated through captiousness, or conten-
tiousness, or any such like ungracious disposition in the bishop. And, that this matter may
have due investigation, it is decreed that in every province synods shall be held twice a year,
in order that when all the bishops of the province are assembled together, such questions
may by them be thoroughly examined, that so those who have confessedly offended against
their bishop, may be seen by all to be for just cause excommunicated, until it shall seem fit
to a general meeting of the bishops to pronounce a milder sentence upon them. And let
these synods be held, the one before Lent, (that the pure Gift may be offered to God after
all bitterness has been put away), and let the second be held about autumn.
Notes.
Ancient Epitome of Canon V.
Such as have been excommunicated by certain bishops shall not be restored by others,
unless the excommunication was the result of pusillanimity, or strife, or some other similar
cause. And that this may be duly attended to, there shall be in each year two synods in every
province—the one before Lent, the other toward autumn.
There has always been found the greatest difficulty in securing the regular meetings of
provincial and diocesan synods, and despite the very explicit canonical legislation upon the
subject, and the severe penalties attached to those not answering the summons, in large
parts of the Church for centuries these councils have been of the rarest occurrence. Zonaras
complains that in his time “these synods were everywhere treated with great contempt,”
and that they had actually ceased to be held.
Possibly the opinion of St. Gregory Nazianzen had grown common, for it will be re-
membered that in refusing to go to the latter sessions of the Second Ecumenical he wrote,
“I am resolved to avoid every meeting of bishops, for I have never seen any synod end well,
nor assuage rather than aggravate disorders.”59
Hefele.
Gelasius has given in his history of the Council of Nice, the text of the canons passed
by the Council; and it must be noticed that there is here a slight difference between his text
and ours. Our reading is as follows: “The excommunication continues to be in force until
it seem good to the assembly of bishops (τῳ κοινῷ) to soften it.” Gelasius, on the other
hand, writes: μέχρις ἄν τῷ κοινῷ ἢ τῷ ἐπισκόπῳ, κ.τ.λ., that is to say, “until it seem good
to the assembly of bishops, or to the bishop (who has passed the sentence),” etc.…Dionysius
59 Greg. Naz. Ep. ad Procop., Migne, Pat. Græc., No. cxxx.
Canon V.
58
Canon V.