Wisdom and Faith
James 1:5-8
5 But if any of you lacketh wisdom,-The careful reader will observe that quite often in James the leading word of the clause preceding becomes the chief point with which the verse following begins. This is a figure designated by grammarians as anadiplosis, defined by Webster as "Repetition of a word, especially the last word, of one clause, at the beginning of the next." The greeti11g of verse 1 ("joy to you"), is followed by "count it all joy," of verse 2; temptations (trials) lead on to "proving" in verse 3 ; patience, in verse 3, to "patience" in verse 4; lacking in nothing, in verse 4 to "if any man lack . . . " of verse 5; if any man lack, is followed by "let him ask of God who giveth" ; it shall be given him of verse 5, prompts the statement, let him ask in faith, nothing doubting which, in turn, results in "for he that doubteth is like the surge of the sea, driven by the wind and tossed .. . " and so on, frequently in the Epistle.
James had urged his readers to recognize in their varied trials the means by which, through patience, to develop full, spiritual maturity in faith and in life. It would appear that, at this point, he must have anticipated this question: "How is it possible for me to see in my difficulties a blessing? Surely, the ability to do this requires a much greater wisdom than I possess?" And, it is as if James answered, "Indeed so I But, do not despair; there is an unfailing and inexhaustible supply available and at hand."
let him ask of God,-The ability to see great blessings in sore trial is not an inherent one, and must, therefore be acquired. It is quite significant that James did not say, "But if any of you lacketh wisdom, let him study philosophy, or, let him meditate, or, let him consult the wise." The wisdom which we need, and must have, to turn our trials into triumphs is available only from God. But, what is this "wisdom" which only God can give? "wisdom," so Webster says, is the "ability to judge soundly and deal sagaciously with facts, esp. as they relate to life and conduct; discernment and judgment; discretion; sagacity." Knowledge, when contemplated apart from wisdom is an "acquaintance with fact; hence, scope of information." Knowledge is thus the possession of facts; wisdom the ability of judging soundly and correctly regarding them. Knowledge is obtained only through study; wisdom is a gift of God. One whose desire is to learn mathematical principles would not resort to prayer but to text books dealing therewith ; one who desires the divine wisdom must get down on his knees. Facts to be stored in the head are obtained only through mental effort; the wisdom which has its home in the depths of the soul only God can bestow. Of the manner in which God bestows this wisdom the writer does not deal ; it is fact of it which is here affirmed.
who giveth to all liberally and upbraideth not ;-If, therefore, we lack wisdom (and all of us do), let us "Ask of God who giveth. . . ." The words, "God who giveth" are, in the Greek order, tou didontos Theou, literally, THE GIVING GOD! This statement emphasizes the fact that such is characteristic of him ; he is revealed to us in the character of a Giver. It is a part of his nature to give. Moreover, he gives to all; there are no favored few among the faithful disciples; each is by him regarded with equal favor and his bounties bestowed accordingly. Were we liberal to a fault, our limited means make such widespread uestowal of bounty impossible. But even this does not exhaust the extent of his giving.
He gives to all liberally, haplos, a word meaning either generously, or without bargaining, either meaning being possible here, and both combining in our word liberally, simply, unreservedly, without any material expectation of return. We thus learn that (1) God gives; (2) he gives to all; (3) he gives liberally; and (4) he "upbraideth not" (me oneidizontos, present active participle of oneidizo, to cast into one's teeth, to reproach) because of our requests.
Often, when we give, we do so reluctantly, grudgingly, and with reproaches. Have we known this to happen? It is necessary for us to make a request, and then, later to repeat it, only to be met with this objection: "You were just asking for this yesterday, or last week; you are forever asking for something ; are you never satisfied?" God (may his name ever be praised for this fact) never thus upbraids, or casts our requests into our teeth ! Nor does he chide us for the misuse of the gracious bounties already received. He does not say when we make request of him, "What did you do with the things I have already given you? Make better use of them before you come back asking for more." In truth, we should rebuke ourselves for our own misuse of his rich gifts and the poverty which characterizes our efforts in their use.
and it shall be given him.- This reminds us of our Lord's marvelous promise in Matthew 7:7 : "Ask, and it shall be given you.·· (See, also, Luke 11:9.) Here is one prayer we may be certain the Father will answer. And it shall be given him. The answer to some prayers is conditional. In some instances we are to recognize the contingency of prayer in the petition: "If it please thee, grant our request." For example, it was necessary that our Lord should return to heaven. And, notwithstanding the fact that his disciples earnestly prayed, and fervently hoped that he would remain with them on earth, he departed. It was expedient that he go away. (John 16:7.) Of course, as is ever the case when a petition of God's faithful children is not granted affirn1atively, the sorrowing followers of the Lord ultimately come into possession of a vastly richer blessing than could ever have been theirs had he remained on earth.
There is, indeed, no such thing as an unanswered prayer ever 1,ttered by God's faithful children. He ans-&ers every prayer his children pray! True, he does not always say, "Yes." Often, he says, "No." But the "No," is as rnuch an answer as "Yes," would be, and springs from the same motive. When, for example, a child, because of its immaturity makes a request of its parents which, for the child's welfare, they must not grant, their refusal to grant the specific request is not a disregard of the petition of the child, it is an answer to it, and an answer based upon considerations of the child's welfare. In similar fashion, when we make requests of God which are not for our good; or, because he intends to give us richer blessings later, and he withholds the specific request, this is not a disregard of our prayer, it is an answer to It- an answer grounded in good for us. So it is, and so we should ever regard it, and thus be content with the divine wisdom ever evidenced in such instances.
6 But let him ask in faith, nothing doubting:-Our petitions to the Father must, of course, be made "in faith," inasmuch as "without faith it is impossible to be well-pleasing unto him." (Hebrews 11:6.) Faith is, as we have seen in our studies of Jas 1:3, much more than mere intellectual assent to the truthfulness of a proposition-belief that a statement is true--it is firm reliance upon the Lord, unwavering trust in his word, coupled with the disposition to obey fully his commands. We learn here that, i .n order to obtain wisdom (a) we must ask; (b) we must ask of God; (c) we must ask of God in faith; and (d) the petition must be made "nothing doubting." The wisdom which we need to rise to higher plateaus of usefulness, using life's difficulties as steppingstones on which to climb to these higher elevations must come only from God ; he alone can give it. But, we must receive it; and to receive it, we must believe in him who alone can bestow it. Surely it is idle to expect God to give us wisdom if we will not give him trust! "Doubting," (from diakrinomenos), the chief idea of which, as used in our text, is inner debate; and it presents the picture of a person torn by conflicting notions, now disposed to feel this way, now that. It is, as Thayer remarks, "to be at variance with one's self," to hesitate, to doubt; and, while it does not denote the utter absence of faith, it describes the disposition of a person who, at one moment, feels God will keep his promise, and, at another moment, that he will not. God's purpose in bestowing wisdom upon his children is to create a better relationship between him and them; and, if his children entertain doubts of the truth and reliability of his promises, the atmosphere is one of suspicion, and not of faith.
for he that doubteth is like the surge of the sea driven by the wind and tossed.-He who doubts is one beset by contradictory notions. The inspired writer compares him to the ceaseless and wild surge of the sea which, at one moment, moves shoreward, and at another moment, in the opposite direction, but always aimlessly and without intelligent direction. One torn by such inner conflict can never lean with confidence on God and on his gracious promises. Utterly wanting, in such a person, is that sense of assurance which would enable such a one to approach God in firmness of faith and in robustness of hope, confident that he is faithful who promised (1 Corinthians 1:9), and therefore able to keep that which we have committed unto him against that day (2 Timothy 1:12). We should ever strive to possess that spiritual poise which enables one to weather the winds of trial, temptation and all earthly difficulty and to exhibit that stability of heart and mind which cannot be moved.
7 For let not that man think that he shall receive anything of the Lord ;-The second clause of verse 6 describes the restlessness of the man who doubts; the first clause of verse 7 shows that such a one eliminates himself from all special favors from God. A state of mind ranging from hope one moment, to despair through doubt in the next, is not conducive to happiness; and one thus possessed is without claim upon God. There appears to be some contempt expressed by James in the phrase, that man, in this passage. One possessed of such a nature could not possibly be happy in life, and such a one makes no contribution whatsoever of a substantial nature to the times in which he lives. Jacob said of one of his sons, "Unstable as water, thou shalt not excel. ... " (Genesis 49:4. AV.) Not only is such a man not promised special blessings in wisdom in answer to prayer, he is not to expect them.
Let not that man so much as think that he shall receive anything of the Lord. "The Lord," as in James 4:15; James 5:10-11, is the Father, if James intended any distinction. It is quite likely that he used the term merely to designate deity without designing to distinguish between the members of the godhead.
8 a doubleminded man, unstable in all his ways.-"Doubleminded," in the original text is dipmchos, a man with two minds or souls. The word occurs in no other New Testament book, and in James only here and James 4:8. Inasmuch as there is no clear instance of its use before the Epistle of James was penned this has led to the conclusion that James coined it. Following its use in James, it was adopted by numerous later writers, such as Hermas, Clement, Barnabas, etc. A doubter is a doubleminded person and is in the position of attempting to pay homage to two masters. (Matthew 6:24.) He is, therefore, "unstable," (akatastatos, unsteady, wavering, in disposition and attitude). Such a person is restless, confused in his actions and in all of his ways.
A doubleminded man is in conflict with himself; this situation makes him unstable, a word used to describe a drunk man unable to walk a straight course, swaying now this way, now that, without definite direction in his course, and thus unable to get anywhere. Such a one is unstable "in all his ways," and not merely or solely with reference to petitions for wisdom. A waverer in faith will exhibit instability in every department of religious activity. This, incidentally, is the condition which characterizes a person involved in doubt religiously. While the philosophical world regards such a disposition with favor, James, the inspired writer, held the opposite view. Doubt, to him was no evidence of superior learning or unusual intellectual attainment; it was, instead, the mark of mental instability, evidence of confused intellectual processes.
{"canonical_mapping_status":"native_coordinates_only; no canonical mapping inferred","footnote_boundary_status":"whole_native_row_preserved; no independent-note segmentation or note-count claim","html_tags":{"p":16},"id":"sqlite3:5fb87c9182736a329b6c330747587f24405d46b6f2d3aad595a43ba53cae0300:commentaries:62","native_body_column":"text","native_module_context_literals":{"description":"A Commentary on the New Testament Epistles","language":"en"},"native_module_metadata_ref":{"$context_sha256":"ab52a70f08c2bf542a06a1ad0b8e172c2a748270bbf0ef42ed42537c4eccdce8"},"native_reference":{"book_number":660,"chapter_number_from":1,"chapter_number_to":1,"verse_number_from":5,"verse_number_to":8},"native_rowid":62,"native_table":"commentaries","projection":"HTML character data with explicit block newlines; no text-node deletion or whitespace folding; original HTML retained","public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"native-verse-keyed-module-record","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_family_classification":"sermonindex","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"daac42a994b9b93aa962537dea8120710661c077851ad63ebfb262d36994bcbf"},"source_html_sha256":"daac42a994b9b93aa962537dea8120710661c077851ad63ebfb262d36994bcbf","source_locator":{"$context_sha256":"82aff79f4ab45b9a631a8a82bad3bee9a43fc27bc0a39fc77336e8b7cafd19cc"},"source_origin_path":"SI-WOODS.commentaries.SQLite3","source_sha256":"5fb87c9182736a329b6c330747587f24405d46b6f2d3aad595a43ba53cae0300"}