into the mouth, but by the evil things which come out of it. In these and many other things
the doctrine of Jesus, as everybody knows, contradicts that of Moses.
7. Not to enumerate all the points of difference, it is enough to mention this one fact,
that most Christian sects, and, as is well known, the Catholics, pay no regard to what is
prescribed in the writings of Moses. If this does not originate in some error, but in the
doctrine correctly transmitted from Christ and His disciples, you surely must acknowledge
that the teaching of Jesus is opposed to that of Moses, and that the Jews did not believe in
Christ on account of their attachment to Moses. How can it be otherwise than false that
Jesus said to the Jews, "If ye believed Moses, ye would believe me also," when it is perfectly
clear that their belief in Moses prevented them from believing in Jesus, which they might
have done if they had left off believing in Moses? Again I ask you to show me anything that
Moses wrote of Christ.
8. Elsewhere Faustus says: When you find no passage to point to, you use this weak
and inappropriate argument, that a Christian is bound to believe Christ when he says that
Moses wrote of Him, and that whoever does not believe this is not a Christian. It would be
far better to confess at once that you cannot find any passage. This argument might be used
with me, because my reverence for Christ compels me to believe what He says. Still it may
be a question whether this is Christ’s own declaration, requiring absolute belief, or only the
writer’s, to be carefully examined. And disbelief in falsehood is no offence to Christ, but to
impostors. But of whatever use this argument may be with Christians, it is wholly inapplic-
222
able in the case of the Jew or Gentile, with whom we are supposed to be discussing. And
even with Christians the argument is objectionable. When the Apostle Thomas was in
doubt, Christ did not spurn him from Him. Instead of saying, "Believe, if thou art a disciple;
whoever does not believe is not a disciple," Christ sought to heal the wounds of his mind
by showing him the marks of the wounds in His own body. Does it become you then to tell
me that I am not a Christian because I am in doubt, not about Christ, but about the genu-
ineness of a remark attributed to Christ? But, you say, He calls those especially blessed, who
have not seen, and yet have believed. If you think that this refers to believing without the
use of judgment and reason, you are welcome to this blind blessedness. I shall be content
with rational blessedness.
9. Augustin replied: Your idea of taking any prophecies of Christ to be found in Moses,
as a fish out of the sea, while you throw away the water from which the fish is taken, is a
clever one. But since all that Moses wrote is of Christ, or relates to Christ, either as predicting
Him by words and actions, or as illustrating His grace and glory, you, with your faith in the
untrue and untruthful Christ from the writings of Manichæus, and your unbelief in Moses,
will not even eat the fish. Moreover, though you are sincere in your hostility to Moses, you
are hypocritical in your praise of fish. For how can you say that there is no harm in eating
a fish taken out of the sea, when your doctrine is that such food is so hurtful, that you would
378
Faustus willing to believe not only that the Jewish but that all Gentile…