448 JEROME.
415, presided over by Bishop John, and a second, at Diospolis in 416, had been admitted to communion. Jerome
appears to have taken no part in these proceedings, and having been at peace with Bishop John for nearly twenty
years, was no doubt unwilling to act against him. But he had come to look upon Pelagius as infected with the
heretical " impiety," which he looked upon (i. 28)as far worse than moral evil ; and connected him, as we see from his letter to Ctesipnon (CXXXIII.), with Origenism and Rufinus ; and he brings his great knowledge of Scripture to
bear upon the controversy. He quotes a work of Pelagius, though giving only the headings, and the numbers
of the chapters, up to 100 (i. 26-32) ; and, though at times his conviction appears weak, and there are passages
(i. 5, ii. 6-30, iii. ij which give occasion to the observation that he really, if unconsciously, inclined to the views
of Pelagius, and that he isa " Synergist," not, like Augustin, a thorough predestinarian, the Dialogue, as a whole, is clear and forms a substantial contribution to our knowledge. Although its tone is less violent than that of his
ascetic treatises, it appears to have stirred up the strongest animosity against him. The adherents of Pelagius
attacked and burned the monasteries of Bethlehem, and Jerome himself only escaped by taking refuge in a tower.
His sufferings, and the interference of Pope Innocentius in his behalf, may be seen by referring to Letters
CXXXV.-CXXXVII., with the introductory notes prefixed to them.
The following is a summary of the argument : Atticus, the Augustinian, at once (c. i) introduces the question:
Do you affirm that, as Pelagius affirms, men can live without sin ? Yes, says the Pelagian Critobulus, but I do
not add, as is imputed to us, " without the grace of God." Indeed, the fact that we have a free will is from grace. Yes, replies Atticus, but what is this grace ? Is it only our original nature, or is it needed in every act. In every
act, is the reply (2) ; yet one would hardly say that we cannot mend a pen without grace (3), for, if so, where is
our free will? But, says Atticus (5), the Scriptures speak of our need of God's aid in everything. In that case, says Critobulus, the promised reward must be given not to us but to God, Who works in us. Reverting then to
the first point stated, Atticus asks, does the possibility of sinlessness extend to single acts, or to the whole life?
Certainly to the whole as well as the part, is the answer. But we wish, or will to be sinless ; why then are we
not actually sinless? Because (8) we do not exert our will to the full. But (9) no one has ever lived without
sin. Still, says the Pelagian, God commands us to be perfect, and he does not command impossibilities.
Job, Zacharias, and Elizabeth are represented as perfectly righteous. No, it is answered (12), faults are attributed
to each of them. John says, " He that is born of God sinneth not" (13) ; yet, " If we say we have no sin we
deceive ourselves." The Apostles, though told to be perfect (14) were not perfect : and St. Paul says (143)," I count
not myself to have apprehended." Men are called just and perfect only in comparison of others (16), or because of general subjection to the will of God (18), or according to their special characteristics (19), as we may speak
of a bishop as excellent in his office, though he may not fulfil the ideal of the pastoral epistles (22).
The discussion now turns to the words of Pelagius' book. " All are ruled by their own will " (27). No ; for
Christ says, " I came not to do My own will." " The wicked shall not be spared in the judgment." But we must distinguish between the impious or heretics who will be destroyed (28) and Christian sinners who will be for-
given. Some of his sayings contradict each other or are trifling (29, 30). " The kingdom of heaven is promised
in the Old Testament." Yes, but more fully in the New. Returning to the first thesis, "That a man can be
without sin if he wills it, "the Pelagian says, If things, like desires which arise spontaneously and have no issue, are reckoned blamable, we charge the sin on our Maker ; to which it is only answered that, though we cannot
understand God's ways, we must not arraign His justice. In the rest of the book, Atticus alone speaks, going through the Old Testament, and showing that each of the saints falls into some sin, which, though done in igno-
rance or half-consciousness, yet brings condemnation with it.
Prologue.
\. After writing the ' letter to Ctesiphon, in which I replied to the questions propounded,
I received frequent expostulations from the
brethren, who wanted to know why I any
longer delayed the promised work in which I undertook to answer all the subtleties of the
preachers of Impassibility.8 For every one knows what was the contention of the Stoics
and Peripatetics, that is, the old Academy,
some of them asserted that the TtdSr),
which we may call emotions, such as sorrow,
joy, hope, fear, can be thoroughly eradi-
cated from the minds of men ; others that
their power can be broken, that they can be
governed and restrained, as unmanageable
horses are held in check by peculiar kinds of
bits. Their views have been explained by
Tully in the " Tusculan Disputations," and
Origen in his " Stromata " endeavours to blend them with ecclesiastical truth. I pass over
» Letter CXXXIII.
Manichaeus,1 Priscillianus," Evagrius of Ibora,
Jovinianus, and the heretics found through- out almost the whole of Syria, who, by a
perversion of the import of their name, are
commonly called 3 Massalians, in Greek, Euchiies, all of whom hold that it is possible
for human virtue and human knowledge to
attain perfection, and arrive, I will not say
merely at a likeness to, but an equality
1 Priscillian was a Spaniard, who began to propagate his views, which were a mixture of various heresies, about the year
370. See Robertson, p. 295 sq., and Note on Jerome, Letter
CXXXIII.
2 Evagrius Iberita. The name is taken either from a town named Ibera or Ibora in Pontus, or from the province of Iberia.
Jerome, in the letter to which he refers, styles Evagrius Hyper- borita, but this is thought to be an error for Hyborita. It has
been suggested that Jerome was playing on the word Iberita.
He -was born in 345. He wrote, amongst many other works, a treatise Ilepi dwafleia? (On Impassibility), and no doubt Jerome refers to this a few lines above. He was a zealous champion of
Origen. See also Jerome, Letter CXXXIII. and note. 3 The Massalians or Euchites derived their name from their
habit of continual prayer. The words are etymological equiva-
lents (JH assail ans, from K?¥ to pray). The perversity lay in the
misinterpretation of such texts as Luke xviii. i, and i Thess. v. 17.