Bull is a subordinationist, and so are all the great orthodox divines. When Origen maintains
the μοναρχία (the Father as the root and source of the Godhead, as do all the Greeks2482),
and also a subordination of the Son in the divine οὐσία, he is surely consistent with the
Athanasian doctrine;2483 and, if he is led to affirm a diversity of essence in connection with
this subordination, he does it with such limitations as should convince us that he, too, would
have subscribed the ὁμοούσιον, in which Alexandrians no whit inferior to him finally for-
mulated the convictions and testimonies of their predecessors.2484
304
II.
(Since the body of the Catholic Church is one, etc., p. 296.)
As so shortly preceding the meeting of the Great Council, this letter is most important
as a clear testimony to the meaning the first council attached to that article of the Creed
which affirms “one holy Catholic and Apostolic Church.” We must compare the Treatises
of Cyprian for the West, with this and the Letter of Firmilian2485 for the East, as clearly
elucidating the contemporary mind of the Church, and hence the meaning of those words
which reflect their mind in the Creed. To make any reflections of my own would be out of
place, save only, negatively, as I compare it with the modern creed of the Council of Trent
(Pius IV.), which defines the Catholic Church to be the communion which acknowledges
the Church of Rome as “the mother and mistress of churches.”
The concluding section of this letter is decisive as to the absolute autonomy of the Alex-
andrian diœcese.2486 To all the other churches Alexander merely communicates his sentence,
which they are all bound to respect. Whether the Christian Church at this period reflected
the Apostolic Institutions is not the question, but merely what its theory was in the fourth
century, and how far East and West accorded with the theory of Cyprian.
2482 On Tertullian’s orthodoxy, see notes, vol. iii. p. 600, etc.
2483 When we consider his refinements about the words substance, idea, image, etc., in the dispute with
Celsus, while yet these terms were not reduced to precision, we cannot but detect his effort to convey an orthodox
notion. Observe Dr. Spencer’s short but useful note, vol. iv. p. 603, note 3.
2484 See vol. iv. p. 382, Elucidations I., II., and III.
2485 Vol. v. p. 390, this series.
2486 See the force of this spelling, p. 240, supra.
686
Elucidations.