Excursus on the Chorepiscopi.
There has been much difference of opinion among the learned touching the status of
the Chorepiscopus in the early Church. The main question in dispute is as to whether they
were always, sometimes, or never, in episcopal orders. Most Anglican writers, including
Beveridge, Hammond, Cave, and Routh, have affirmed the first proposition, that they were
true bishops, but that, out of respect to the bishop of the City they were forbidden the exercise
of certain of their episcopal functions, except upon extraordinary occasions. With this view
Binterim71 also agrees, and Augusti is of the same opinion.72 But Thomassinus is of a dif-
ferent mind, thinking, so says Hefele,73 that there were “two classes of chorepiscopi, of
whom the one were real bishops, while the other had only the title without consecration.”
The third opinion, that they were merely presbyters, is espoused by Morinus and Du
Cange, and others who are named by Bingham.74 This last opinion is now all but universally
rejected, to the other two we shall now devote our attention.
For the first opinion no one can speak more learnedly nor more authoritatively than
Arthur West Haddon, who writes as follows;
(Haddon, Dict. Christ. Antiq. s.v. Chorepiscopus.)
The chorepiscopus was called into existence in the latter part of the third century, and
first in Asia Minor, in order to meet the want of episcopal supervision in the country parts
of the now enlarged dioceses without subdivision. [They are] first mentioned in the
Councils of Ancyra and Neo-Cæsarea a.d. 314, and again in the Council of Nice (which is
subscribed by fifteen, all from Asia Minor or Syria). [They became] sufficiently important
to require restriction by the time of the Council of Antioch, a.d. 341; and continued to exist
in the East until at least the ninth century, when they were supplanted by ἔξαρχοι.
[Chorepiscopi are] first mentioned in the West in the Council of Riez, a.d. 439 (the Epistles
of Pope Damasus I. and of Leo. M. respecting them being forgeries), and continued there
(but not in Africa, principally in France) until about the tenth century, after which the name
occurs (in a decree of Pope Damasus II. ap. Sigeb. in an. 1048) as equivalent to archdeacon,
an office from which the Arabic Nicene canons expressly distinguish it. The functions of
chorepiscopi, as well as their name, were of an episcopal, not of a presbyterial kind, although
limited to minor offices. They overlooked the country district committed to them, “loco
episcopi,” ordaining readers, exorcists, subdeacons, but, as a rule, not deacons or presbyters
(and of course not bishops), unless by express permission of their diocesan bishop. They
confirmed in their own districts, and (in Gaul) are mentioned as consecrating churches
71 Binterim, Denkwürdigkeiten, vol. i. part ii. pp. 386–414.
72 Augusti, Denkwürdigkeiten, vol. xi. p.159 et seqq.
73 Hefele, Hist. of the Councils, vol. ii. p. 322.
74 Bingham, Antiquities, ii. xiv. 2, 3.
Excursus on the Chorepiscopi.
73
Excursus on the Chorepiscopi.