neither them nor you: not them, for they lied to me about you; nor you, for you quote to
me that Scripture which I had believed on the authority of those liars. But far be it that I
should not believe the gospel; for believing it, I find no way of believing you too. For the
names of the apostles, as there recorded,268 do not include the name of Manichæus. And
who the successor of Christ’s betrayer was we read in the Acts of the Apostles;269 which
book I must needs believe if I believe the gospel, since both writings alike Catholic authority
commends to me. The same book contains the well-known narrative of the calling and
apostleship of Paul.270 Read me now, if you can, in the gospel where Manichæus is called
an apostle, or in any other book in which I have professed to believe. Will you read the
passage where the Lord promised the Holy Spirit as a Paraclete, to the apostles? Concerning
which passage, behold how many and how great are the things that restrain and deter me
from believing in Manichæus.
268 Matt. x. 2-4; Mark iii. 13-19; Luke vi. 13-18.
269 Acts i. 26.
270 Acts ix.
214
Against the Title of the Epistle of Manichæus.