5. For Herod slew him, a good man and one who exhorted the Jews to come and receive
baptism, practicing virtue and exercising righteousness toward each other and toward God;
for baptism would appear acceptable unto Him when they employed it, not for the remission
of certain sins, but for the purification of the body, as the soul had been already purified in
righteousness.
6. And when others gathered about him (for they found much pleasure in listening to
his words), Herod feared that his great influence might lead to some sedition, for they ap-
peared ready to do whatever he might advise. He therefore considered it much better, before
any new thing should be done under John’s influence, to anticipate it by slaying him, than
to repent after revolution had come, and when he found himself in the midst of difficulties.195
On account of Herod’s suspicion John was sent in bonds to the above-mentioned citadel of
Machæra,196 and there slain.”
7. After relating these things concerning John, he makes mention of our Saviour in the
same work, in the following words:197 “And there lived at that time Jesus, a wise man, if
to doubt that it is, for such a dispassionate and strictly impartial account of John could hardly have been written
by a Christian interpolator.
195 Josephus differs with the Evangelists as to the reason for John’s imprisonment, but the accounts of the
latter bear throughout the stamp of more direct and accurate knowledge than that of Josephus. Ewald remarks
with truth, “When Josephus, however, gives as the cause of John’s execution only the Tetrarch’s general fear of
popular outbreaks, one can see that he no longer had perfect recollection of the matter. The account of Mark is
far more exact and instructive.”
196 Machæra was an important fortress lying east of the northern end of the Dead Sea. It was the same fortress
to which the daughter of Aretas had retired when Herod formed the design of marrying Herodias; and the word
“aforesaid” refers to Josephus’ mention of it in that connection in the previous paragraph.
197 Ant.XVIII. 3. 3. This account occurs before that of John the Baptist, not after it. It is found in all our mss.
of Josephus, and was considered genuine until the sixteenth century, but since then has been constantly disputed.
Four opinions are held in regard to it; (1) It is entirely genuine. This view has at present few supporters, and is
absolutely untenable. A Christian hand is unmistakably apparent,—if not throughout, certainly in many parts;
and the silence in regard to it of all Christian writers until the time of Eusebius is fatal to its existence in the
original text. Origen, for instance, who mentions Josephus’ testimony to John the Baptist in Contra Cels. I. 47,
betrays no knowledge of this passage in regard to Christ. (2) It is entirely spurious. Such writers as Hase, Keim,
and Schürer adopt this view. (3) It is partly genuine and partly interpolated. This opinion has, perhaps, the most
defenders, among them Gieseler, Weizsäcker, Renan, Edersheim, and Schaff. (4) It has been changed from a
bitter Jewish calumny of Christ to a Christian eulogy of him. This is Ewald’s view. The second opinion seems
to me the correct one. The third I regard as untenable, for the reason that after the obviously Christian passages
are omitted there remains almost nothing; and it seems inconceivable that Josephus should have given so colorless
a report of one whom the Jews regarded with such enmity, if he mentioned him at all. The fourth view might
be possible, and is more natural than the third; but it seems as if some trace of the original calumny would have
152
Testimonies in Regard to John the Baptist and Christ.