Chapter 27.—Of the Apparently Conflicting Opinions of Plato and Porphyry, Which
Would Have Conducted Them Both to the Truth If They Could Have Yielded to One An-
other.
Statements were made by Plato and Porphyry singly, which if they could have seen their
way to hold in common, they might possibly have became Christians. Plato said that souls
could not exist eternally without bodies; for it was on this account, he said, that the souls
even of wise men must some time or other return to their bodies. Porphyry, again, said that
the purified soul, when it has returned to the Father, shall never return to the ills of this
world. Consequently, if Plato had communicated to Porphyry that which he saw to be true,
that souls, though perfectly purified, and belonging to the wise and righteous, must return
to human bodies; and if Porphyry, again, had imparted to Plato the truth which he saw, that
holy soul, shall never return to the miseries of a corruptible body, so that they should not
have each held only his own opinion, but should both have held both truths, I think they
would have seen that it follows that the souls return to their bodies, and also that these
bodies shall be such as to afford them a blessed and immortal life. For, according to Plato,
even holy souls shall return to the body; according to Porphyry, holy souls shall not return
to the ills of this world. Let Porphyry then say with Plato, they shall return to the body; let
Plato say with Porphyry, they shall not return to their old misery: and they will agree that
they return to bodies in which they shall suffer no more. And this is nothing else than what
God has promised,—that He will give eternal felicity to souls joined to their own bodies.
For this, I presume, both of them would readily concede, that if the souls of the saints are
to be reunited to bodies, it shall be to their own bodies, in which they have endured the
miseries of this life, and in which, to escape these miseries, they served God with piety and
fidelity.
Of the Apparently Conflicting Opinions of Plato and Porphyry, Which Would Have Conducted Them Both to the Truth If They Could Have Yielded to One Another.
1131
Of the Apparently Conflicting Opinions of Plato and Porphyry, Which Would…